The book jacket says Robert Parker, the author of The Early Spenser is a successor of Hammett and Chandler. They wrote noire detective novels in the 1930’s and ‘40’s. Parker’s protagonist is in the 50’s or 60’s. So, you can see that the subject matter is more modern, but rapidly becoming dated. Pay phones, newspapers, and the rent Spenser must pay on both his downtown Boston apartment and office are relics of a past generation. Also, scandalous affairs exploited by blackmailers and shootouts with criminal kingpins appear quaint by today’s morality. In the modern world celebrity publicists would find a way to promote scandalous behavior and, maybe where the nation’s economic structure, as a wealthy upper-class miles away from the poor and destitute, with a shrinking middle class between, the criminal element consists of unscrupulous, unseen financiers at one end, far removed from street thugs at the other. Between, the “middle level” criminals have become scarce. I really don’t think you’re going to come face to face with top level gangster armed equally with you, to settle things in a shoot-out. I’m not an expert, but come on.
But for entertainment’s sake The Early Spenser was enjoyable to read. The private detective, Spenser, is sarcastic and sassy, and the staccato dialog moves the plot right along. I would point out the whole thing is done without profanity, which, in my opinion, is a rare feat for a crime novel still in circulation. Also, Spenser uses several literary references, presumably to elevate Spenser’s stature to “educated,” or “sensitive,” which seems, to me, a little incongruous, given the number of lumps he’s taken to his head over the years. I would think he would be a candidate for Traumatic Brain Injury or at least partial memory loss, especially with the amount of alcohol he consumes. But here it’s funny and sharp. Then the description of characters’ attire, food, furniture, street scenes all show Parker’s eye for detail that the next generation of detective novelists could learn from. The motives of people probably transcend time as well. Finally, Parker becomes philosophical toward the end of the third selection in the book. He says men, “need a system” or set of principles by which they live. When those principles come into conflict, the individual must sort them out. Spenser’s lesson to a character is bring a gun and be ready to use it. Well, I guess that might’ve been accepted in the U.S. in the 1950’s. But in 2023, you can’t really “gun down” all your enemies. In my opinion.