Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

In a Yellow Wood

Rate this book
By night the glittering world of Times Square, cinemas, clubs and the brittle, played-out demi-monde ...by day a wasteland of hollow men, lonely apartments and empty morning coffee stands ...Robert Holton has just returned from the torment and strife of war in Europe and settled in a solitary existence working for a New York stockbroking business. The haunting memories of nights of love spent in Florence are suppressed as he struggles to succeed in an arid city. And when Carla turns up unexpectedly from his more passionate past, Robert finds he must choose between the fixed path of money-making and dull conventionality and the fraught, uncertain path of love and freedom.

Paperback

First published January 1, 1947

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Gore Vidal

240 books1,939 followers
Gore Vidal was an American novelist, essayist, screenwriter, playwright and political commentator known for his sharp wit, provocative opinions and criticism of American society. Raised in Washington, D.C., he attended several preparatory schools before graduating from Phillips Exeter Academy in 1943. His maternal grandfather, Thomas Pryor Gore, a Democratic senator from Oklahoma, profoundly influenced his early interest in politics. During World War II, Vidal served in the United States Army and worked aboard a supply ship in the Aleutian Islands. His experiences inspired his first novel, Williwaw (1946), published shortly after his military service.
Vidal attracted controversy with The City and the Pillar (1948), one of the early American novels to portray male homosexuality openly. Its subject provoked conservative critics and established his reputation as a writer willing to challenge prevailing social conventions. He subsequently explored different genres, writing novels, plays, essays and screenplays. His stage comedy Visit to a Small Planet became a theatrical success, while his work in Hollywood included contributions to the screenplay for Ben-Hur (1959).
His historical novels brought him particular recognition. Julian (1964) examined the Roman emperor's attempt to restore paganism, while Burr (1973) and Lincoln (1984) offered fictional interpretations of American political history. Myra Breckinridge (1968), a provocative satire of Hollywood and gender conventions, further demonstrated his willingness to challenge cultural assumptions. His later historical fiction included 1876, Empire and Hollywood, forming part of his broader exploration of American power and national identity.
Vidal was equally influential as an essayist and public intellectual. His collections addressed American foreign policy, religion, sexuality and the political establishment. United States: Essays 1952-1992 won the National Book Award in 1993. His memoir Palimpsest (1995) offered personal reflections on his family, relationships and literary career. Vidal also became famous for televised confrontations with conservative commentator William F. Buckley Jr. during the 1968 presidential election coverage. Their bitter exchanges made him a prominent figure in American political debate.
His political involvement extended beyond commentary. He ran unsuccessfully for the United States House of Representatives in New York in 1960 and for the United States Senate in California in 1982. He later chaired the People's Party and remained an outspoken critic of American militarism, corporate influence and the expansion of executive power. His views frequently placed him at odds with political leaders and fellow intellectuals, including writer Norman Mailer.
Vidal spent much of his later life in Italy before returning to the United States. He continued writing essays, novels and memoirs into his final years, maintaining his reputation for intellectual independence and irreverence. His work examined the relationship between private ambition and public power, often questioning conventional accounts of American history. He died in 2012, leaving a substantial literary legacy spanning fiction, political criticism and cultural commentary.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
17 (16%)
4 stars
31 (30%)
3 stars
38 (36%)
2 stars
14 (13%)
1 star
3 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews
Profile Image for David Haws.
872 reviews16 followers
February 28, 2019
Vidal’s second novel flirts with some of the themes he would subsequently tackle in The City and the Pillar, eschewing a dependence on plotline and paying more attention to character development. The introductory prose feels somewhat stilted—as if, as with Williwaw, in emulation of writerly minimalists like Hemingway—but loosens up as the narrative progresses. He also tends, here, to overwrite (“Holton crossed his legs, giving himself time to think,” p.181) and is sometimes unnecessarily overt (“She said this in a way to let him know she was being humorous.” p. 81). Vidal does love his adverbs, but can do so stunningly (“He was thin and moved stiffly, self-consciously, like a woman thinking of rape,” p. 145) and I loved the way he referenced lighting in allusion to the social isolation of the novel’s era (“The room was dark except for the lighted dots of windows in the buildings opposite and, over the buildings, like unorganized window lights, cold stars shone clearly,” p. 186). Other then having come from a very young Vidal, the novels principal value may well be as an illumination of this social anxiety—rampant during the short-lived interim of post-War/pre-Imperial America.

Reading the novel now, as meticulous as it is, I can’t help but wonder how different Vidal’s life would have been if he had decided not to publish The City and the Pillar. In its absence, I can see him easily becoming the type of academic he came to scorn—publishing, once or twice a decade, the kind of meticulous novel whose principal use is pedagogical. I also wonder if this second novel—skirting issues of homosexuality, sometimes stereotypically—gave Vidal a sense of obligation to treat the topic in a more forthright way (precipitating his decade under a publisher’s anathema) and if, without this pressure to write for a larger audience, Vidal would still have developed into the premiere writer of his generation.
Profile Image for "Ben" Yair.
428 reviews105 followers
July 24, 2026
"For a moment he felt himself sinking. It was like a dream of falling. He seemed to be descending into a pit without bottom. There was no longer a Robert Holton: only a series of masks, cracked now and no longer usable, no longer convincing. He could never use one again.
He stopped falling; by an effort of will he stopped himself. Carla was gone and he was sorry. There was no one else and loneliness now crept out of the silence. He would have to build the barricades stronger and higher. He would shut loneliness out."

-Vidal, Gore. In a Yellow Wood (pg. 181)
603 reviews3 followers
November 22, 2022
Somewhere between a three and a four, this is another interesting early Vidal novel that is probably only of interest to completists.

With an almost embarrassingly obvious title alluding to one of the most famous poems of all time, I was a little apprehensive about this one. Williwaw is a minor classic of WWII lit; like most first novels, it benefits from a healthy dollop of autobiographical insight. While this second novel is also full of autobiographical parallels, it represents Vidal's first attempt to write a "serious" novel of ideas. It is equally indebted, in Vidalian fashion, to modernist literature of the 1920s (in its shifting interior POV and attempts to catalog the minutiae of one 24 hour span in NYC) as well as (at least for me) classic Hollywood melodrama.

Vidal's novel focuses on Robert Holton, a veteran who has returned from the war and is dutifully taking his place in the growing post-war capitalist society. While he knew adventure, traveled widely, and had a number of sexual relationships during the war, he makes a conscious effort to forget those experiences and emotions as he attempts to fulfill what he understands to be his duty. This effort faces immense pushback when, unexpectedly, he runs into his former overseas lover at a well-described cocktail party. Suddenly our main character faces a choice.

As other reviewers have noted, the book is overwritten and really only comes alive about halfway through. I enjoyed the minute descriptions of office life in the late 1940s from a historical perspective, however, and found there to be a fair amount of ironic horror present in Vidal's exacting descriptions of day-to-day drudgery at an office 9-5. There are a number of other strengths here as well:

1) As Elizabeth Samet's "The Good War" points out, then-contemporary fiction was considerably more ambiguous about the role of veterans in a postwar society. Vidal's book has a lot to say about this topic and comes at it from an interesting angle.
2) Vidal is also extraordinarily prescient in his critique of postwar American society. Written as the era we think of as "the 50s" was just getting off the ground, Vidal masterfully sees through the falseness of a capitalistic society that reduces bright young men to glorified number crunchers in brokerage houses while also dooming complicated women to a life defined by their relationship to said men;
3) The book also brilliantly dissects the way that the war was, paradoxically, a freeing and liberating experience for most American soldiers (rather than a horrific ordeal) in that it showed them alternatives to a constrained version of American middle-class existence;
4) It's also very frank about sexual relationships and the presence of gay men in a society we are retroactively taught to think of in terms of a second Victorian age.

However, the book also has numerous flaws, including its reliance on Hollywood-style melodrama, a persistent overwriting, and an ending that simply churns on too long despite the brief length of the book.

An interesting footnote to the era, but not the work of a generation that Vidal was obviously thinking of when he wrote it. An enjoyable and idiosyncratic read but, again, not essential.
Profile Image for Bryan Serwatka.
Author 2 books3 followers
August 3, 2012
I had only read essays and articles of Vidal's and had been meaning to read his fictional work for years now. I'll admit I only really checked In a Yellow Wood out because I stumbled across it in the library the day after his death and I've got to say, I enjoyed this much more than I expected.

Aesthetically, the imagery and character stereotypes of In a Yellow Wood were evocative of what I know of the golden age of Hollywood. I even mentally pictured a young William Holden portraying the protagonist Robert Holton from start to finish (alternatively I couldn't help but think of the effete George Robert Lewis being played by Beverly Leslie). The conversations throughout the book seemed contrived and predictable like their contemporary celluloid counterparts, but they were as equally charming and rewarding.

On paper (pardon the pun), a novel this simple with a seemingly unexceptional core story would have been something I'd write off after a short while, but there was an underlying allure to In a Yellow Wood that kept me hooked and let me blow through it in a matter of hours. Still waters really do run deep and the internal conflicts of seemingly cliché characters of post-WWII America drew me right in.
Profile Image for Seamus Mcduff.
166 reviews5 followers
November 30, 2020
Not a gripping tale but well written in a direct Hemingway-esque style, with smartly drawn characters.
The novel deals in part with a post WW2 sense of lostness, and the attempt to adjust to workaday civilian life. At the same time the main character struggles to choose between a conventional, unsatisfying path but one which is known and safe, versus a free and full life, and the risk of the unknown.
Profile Image for Sara.
249 reviews26 followers
September 2, 2025
What a marvelous discovery it was Gore Vidal. The book started out slowly but the pace picked up and one discovers the characters in such a deep and personal way, it is clear we are dealing with a humanist writer, who know America deeply and is not afraid to dive into the soul. The main character is trying to fit it and emerging himself into the capitalist dream rejects love and adventure - and even though we can blame him, we discover ourselves wondering what our own decision would be. So many other characters orbitate around him and although it shouldn't work, Vidal clearly is a master of storytelling. I look forward to reading more from this author.
Profile Image for Arthur.
13 reviews9 followers
February 25, 2022
A little bit like Death of a Salesman, but Vidal's work was published two years before the play.
6 reviews
May 24, 2022
Gore Vidal was an exceptional writer and this is one of his finest reads.
Profile Image for Justin Clark.
133 reviews3 followers
February 26, 2023
In a Yellow Wood (1947) is Gore Vidal’s second novel and more in the personal vein of later works like The Season of Comfort (1949) and the Judgement of Paris (1952). Robert Holton, a WWII veteran, has returned to civilian life in New York City as a financial analyst for a big firm. He’s trying to live the conventional life, but his past continues to interrupt his present. He runs into a war colleague who he has trouble reconnecting with and a past lover from Italy who he deeply cares for but is unable to commit to. He’s a man at a crossroads, and he chooses the path of least resistance in the end, trying to conform in an age of oppressive conformity.

Much like some of his early work, this is a novel where Vidal is finding his style as a writer, with all the limitations therein. I think his novels are better when they tackle bigger issues of philosophy, religion, history, and politics. The novel doesn’t really address any major themes, beyond having to choose between the past and the present, and I found myself a little bored at times with the writing. Its prose is rather utilitarian, similar to Williwaw (1946), but it doesn’t have the narrative thrust that novel had. My favorite part of the novel is Holton’s interactions with a diner waitress, and I hoped that maybe they would form a more meaningful connection as the story progressed, but alas, that didn’t happen. This is a read for Vidal enthusiasts only, but for the general reader interested in learning about his work, his later, more substantive novels are better fare.
1,349 reviews28 followers
April 1, 2015
gore vidal gives us an effortless seeming book about trying to find your place in the world, attempting to ascend to the place expected of you by social standards, and giving up on all possibilities for happiness. on a single day we follow a broker through his job and to a party where he confronts past friends and lovers, each giving him the opportunity to be happy and each opportunity yltimately rejected. the core of this novel is full of sad blood, frozen to its depths. it's a reminder of a quote the author gave outside of the text, "Beneath my cold exterior, once you break the ice, you find: cold water." So it goes with In a Yellow Wood.
Profile Image for Grant Fish.
1 review
September 14, 2016
I enjoyed the first few chapters; I thought they were innovative and interesting. However as the story progresses the title character becomes increasingly unlikable.
Profile Image for Sean Harding.
5,865 reviews35 followers
March 18, 2017
Second Gore Vidal book and he really comes into his own here with this great little read.
It really takes you into the characters life and you feel like you are with him on the journey.
Author 1 book108 followers
April 30, 2014
Sorry, but this book is just bad. Makes "Williwaw" seem good.
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews