The rating is from me; I appreciated many of the stories' themes and the words chosen to convey certain truths. I underlined this book for my own benefit, though I did think it was unnecessarily long-winded in getting to its points.
For my kids, it would've been more of a two-star. They cheered when we finished this morning. "Boring," was one child's review. "They use the word 'expostulate' too much. Everyone is expostulating all over the place," was another child's. For my part, I think many of the morals were too advanced for them at the ages Ambleside recommends this book, and the natural history was also honestly a bit beyond them for several stories. I did appreciate the ability to practice narration, but even for the older kids, we had to stop after every couple paragraphs to make sure we were all still following. It was a slow process. We've been reading this book in segments for years, only finishing (finally) because of my determination/compulsion to complete 99% of books I start.