Don’t have much time for the pedantic over-intellectualizing of most academic film criticism… the better the film, the more difficult it is to say anything worthwhile about it, and almost impossible to do so in the mode engaged here. That said, Malick’s Heideggerian roots are endlessly fascinating to me and do illuminate the nature of his project in some remarkable ways. The first essay in this collection, “Voicing Meaning: On Terrence Malick’s Characters” by Steven Rybin, is deeply insightful in this regard and one of the best considerations of Malick I’ve read. It will be on my mind as I engage his films in the future and I’ll probably return to the essay itself as well. And the closing essay by Elizabeth Walden, a reflection on The New World’s myth “whereof one cannot speak,” approaches with the meditative posture more proper to interaction with great art.