Bought this long ago but gave up on it as I found it hard to get into. Dusted it off recently and tried again, and managed to grind through it this time, even though overall, I didn’t much enjoy it.
It actually has some OK material. Plus, I liked the intent of it. But it’s let down by the writing style and lots of bias and inconsistencies in the thinking.
It tries to take a more informal and pragmatic approach to leadership. No problems with that. So you get cartoons, anecdotes and case studies sprinkled through it to break up the thinking. But these often degenerate into dismissive and sweeping personal observations and opinions from the author with little substantiation. (e.g. “smart” people don’t make good leaders). There are some obvious biases and weaknesses in the thinking.
Many times, the author ridicules a behaviour and then demonstrates that same behaviour a few pages later. He says leaders have self-awareness but doesn’t show much of it in his writing.
It also pulls on a leadership survey he ran with what he calls 700 “top leaders” which is fine. However, you don’t get much detail on the results or how this was done. You get the odd percentage or quote, but you’ve no idea how the sample was selected. Was it random and representative? Or just a bunch of his consulting cronies and networking connections?
The case studies are mostly quite weak and don’t add much in the way of evidence. He makes a point, tells a story about what happened to him once, and then assumes that proves his point.
By the end was left with the feeling that despite his saying “anyone can learn to be a leader”, it’s only those who’ve been to public schools and are Oxbridge-educated who get to the top. Not because of what they know, but because of their nepotistic old-school tie connections.
The basic model of 3 and 1/2 Ps of leadership isn’t too bad, and he’s also good at pointing out common leadership flaws. However, there’s a consistent negative vibe where it’s his way to the top and no other way will work.
If you buy into this style, you’ll like this book. But there are other paths to becoming a leader. This narrow-minded, prescriptive approach wasn’t one I could buy into. A below-par business read.