So much to say about this book!
First - the positive: As someone who works - and lives - in the television industry, I enjoyed this book. Bill Carter is a great writer and reporter. It's like he was present at every single important network meeting over the course of a few years. I'm impressed at his ability to get so much behind-the-scenes intel.
Now, the negative (and don't let this take away from the fact that I enjoyed this book, I just have a lot to say): Looking at this book 15+ years later, I can't help but think it it a missed opportunity. The TV industry changed - seismically - right as this book was being written & published. For example, SNL's "Lazy Sunday" sketch in 2005 became one of the first clips to go viral. At first, the network execs tried to pull those videos offline, until they realized that they were reaching a huge audience (and that was translating into renewed interest in the program).
This digital revolution is huge! And... there's nothing in the book that hints at this. The only time something like this is mentioned comes when Carter talks about how the execs decided to stick with "The Office" after learning that four of its episodes of the Office were in iTunes' top five for downloads.
That's my big problem - I just wish that Carter had waited a year or so (maybe until the 06-07 writer's strike) before coming out with the book. It would have been completely different - and so much more interesting on that level.
There are parts of the book that are dated, but that's not a criticism. In fact, it's rather amusing. For example, NBC exec Jeff Zucker congratulates himself for solving the situation with Conan O'Brien & Jay Leno (he was afraid that Conan was going to bolt for another network, so he promised Conan "The Tonight Show" five years down the road. Five years later, after the book was published, that decision totally blew up NBC late night -- a story chronicled in another excellent Bill Carter book).
Oh, and there's also the Zucker comment, after "The Apprentice" took over the Thursday timeslot once occupied by "Friends": "Who needs "Friends" when you have Donald Trump?"
(Of course, I know a bunch of people who, even today, would agree with that statement)
My only other comment is that the author was clearly infatuated with the show "Desperate Housewives" (I mean, check the name of his book), as so many pages are spent with him telling us how brilliant the script was, and he keeps going back to its development. The funny thing - of all the shows from the early 2000s, 'Housewives' really had the least impact on the cultural zeitgeist. Compare that to "Survivor", "American Idol", "CSI", "The Apprentice", "Lost", "The Office", "Grey's Anatomy", "Dancing With the Stars", "The Bachelor", "The West Wing" and so many others that we are still talking about today. All those get mentioned - in fact, there are chapters devoted to those first five - but Carter just kept going back to "Housewives."
Like I said, I had so much to say about this book. Of course, I think the big takeaway: there are so many executives who have become so incredibly wealthy because of decisions they made over what to air and when, and... they're totally lucky. A show like "Friends" falls in your lap and you look like a genius. The rest of the time you're trying to talk yourself - and advertisers - into watching "Joey".