There is probably only one way to nearly destroy an excellent account of a powerful testimony. It would be to endorse almost exclusively the ones who caused that suffering in the first instance.
This book had many choices, and when it comes to denomination, thousands, or better said tens of thousands of choices. The easiest choice would have been to simply leave any division or denomination out, and simply tell the story of a Christian church of an amazing Christian pastor who helped the Jews. Then indeed it would have been a truly excellent book with outstanding investigation of historical details.
But the book did not only start with a second salvation of the main actor through one of the 'greatest' of all false teachers, Billy Graham who also happened to be one of the 'greatest' mouthpieces for Catholicism in history - it went to another extreme which even leaves Graham in the shadows.
Among tens of thousands of denominations to choose from, it chose the 2 which were directly responsible for the rise of antisemitism, Lutheranism and Catholicism. I do not know which of those played a more evil role, but probably when it comes to religion, Catholicism, and when it comes to a person, Luther himself, also an Augustinian 'by trade'.
The only reason I see to have included Luther (and his religion) into this book, -and it would have been a perfect opportunity- would have been to apologize in the name of the Reformed / Lutheran Church for the Holo*aust which would probably not have existed without Luther (very hard words but we cannot ignore this well-known truth). Luther's anti-Judaistic views contributed significantly to the development of antis**itism in Germany. But to present now precisely a Lutheran as savior of those who suffered the ugly consequences of Luther's antis**itism, is ridiculous at best, it is audacious. It is the exact same scheme found in the books and movies of other popular accounts of the Holo*aust.
Now coming to Catholicism, we can say with absolute certainty, that the Hol**aust would not have existed without it. A quick look at Wikipedia reveals the following summary: "During the Middle Ages [Roman Empire 5c. AD - Renaissance 13-15c. AD], the Catholic Church institutionalized antis**itism through the creation of discriminatory laws and the establishment of the Inquisition. This led to widespread persecution of Jews, including forced conversions, expulsions, and pogroms. Jews were expelled from Catholic kingdoms, including England and Spain and many of the principalities and cities of the Holy Roman Empire and Italy."
Catholics only (and very suddenly) changed their way of walking, when the Holocaust made persecuting Jews no longer socially acceptable and suddenly dozens of heroic stories came up from Catholics, who helped Jews. What a farce, especially when considering that Catholics only half-heartedly apologized after decades, and it took the Vatican 46 years after Israel's independence to recognize them as a state (see also the podcast 'What is the real cause of Antisemitism?' by the Berean Call Podcast).
PROS
+ Superb writing style.
+ Very great display of faith.
+ Beautiful display of some Germans, who at least showed their sympathy to the Jews.
NEUTRAL
o Some of the stories seem a bit far-fetched. Everything could be perfectly true, because THEOS truly works miracles. But it is questionable that it really happened that a daughter could walk in and out of a Synagogue converted into a prison, in order to visit her mother. It is questionable that after this, she entered with friends through a tunnel into another prison, was caught there / on the way back (vague details) and only put on a black list instead of being imprisoned. It is questionable how they could flee in a train by the direct hands of Nazis, although they probably had all the same clothing and were obviously war prisoners.
CONS
- The original edition 'Angels in the Camp: A Remarkable Story of Peace in the Midst of the Holo*aust' (published by Tyndale House, 1979) is being marketed as 'A FICTIONALIZED ACCOUNT of a young Jewish girl's life in war-torn Germany where she discovers the differences IESOUS CHRISTOS makes, even in the midst of the holo*aust.'
This third edition 'Trapped in Hitler's hell' (published by Lighthouse Trails Publishing, 2013) is being marketed as 'Trapped in Hitler's Hell is the TRUE ACCOUNT of holo*aust horror but also of G-d's miraculous mercy on a young girl who spent her teen-age years desperately fighting for survival ...'
How can a FICTIONALIZED ACCOUNT suddenly turn into a TRUE ACCOUNT?
- Strong promotion of Augustinian (Catholic) denominations.
"Living above us in our apartment complex was a Catholic family who invited me to attend church with them one Sunday. Mother, who recognized the same spiritual hunger within me as she had felt as a child, allowed me to go. I, too, was being exposed to Jesus in public school religion classes, which, ironically, the G-d-hating Hitler had not stopped. As I sat through the cathedral service that Sunday morning, G-d's Spirit began to move in my young life. I gasped in awe at the breathtaking stained-glass windows depicting the life of Jesus. How graphically I saw His birth, life, death, and resurrection. Jesus had to be more than a carpenter masquerading as a king. With all the religious options I had as a six-year-old, it is incredible that I could discern that Jesus truly was G-d. I did not believe in the rituals of Judaism or Catholicism, or Father's ardent atheism, or Mother's wavering practice of theosophy." [notice that she only criticizes the rituals, but highly endorses the religion]
"We were given a hot meal at a nearby Catholic day-care center that still dared show an ounce of kindness to a Jew, but I could hardly eat."
"The Christmas carols from the church steeple are telling Jesus' story, Mother!" I exclaimed with delight. "I know the words to the carol. I learned them at the Catholic day-care center. Could I sing them?"
"However, in the Lord's timing, the book did not take shape until sometime in the winter of 1977, after I had reaffirmed my faith in Jesus Christ and renewed my total commitment to Him during one of Billy Graham's Crusades on TV."
"My sincere appreciation also goes to my dear friend Dr. H. Allan Talley of Hope Presbyterian Church, Minneapolis whose care and concern for me have been a constant source of comfort and encouragement. He in turn introduced me to the talented young writer of this book Jan Markell."