Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Labyrinth: Knossos, Myth and Reality

Rate this book
Crete was famous in Greek myth as the location of the labyrinth in which the Minotaur was confined in a palace at somewhere called ‘Knossos'. From the Middle Ages travelers searched unsuccessfully for the Labyrinth. A handful of clues that survived, such as a coin with a labyrinth design and numerous small bronze age items. The name Knossos had survived – but it was nothing but a sprinkling of houses and farmland so they looked elsewhere. Finally, in 1878, a Cretan archeologist, Minos Kalokairinos discovered evidence of a Bronze Age palace. British Archaeologist and then Keeper of the Ashmolean Arthur Evans came out to visit and was fascinated by the site. Between 1900 and 1931 Evans uncovered the remains of the huge palace which he felt must be the that of King Minos, and he adopted the name ‘Minoans' for its occupants. He employed a team of archeologists, architects and artists, and together they built up a picture of the Bronze Age community that had occupied the elaborate building. They imagined a sophisticated, nature-loving people, whose civilization peaked, and then disintegrated. Evans's interpretations of his finds were accurate in some places, but deeply flawed in others. The Evans Archive, held by the Ashmolean, records his finds, theories and (often contentious) reconstructions.

256 pages, Paperback

Published February 28, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Andrew Shapland

7 books1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
6 (46%)
4 stars
7 (53%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
Profile Image for Carlton.
734 reviews
May 14, 2023
A beautiful book with copious clear photos of artefacts, prints and maps, as well as twentieth century photos of the site at various times of excavation and reconstruction.
After an introduction to the exhibition catalogue, the first chapter is formed from five essays on the history of archaeological excavation, conservation and research since the late nineteenth century of the Knossos and wider Cretan sites. This provides a historical context to the presentation of the ancient site of Knossos, but is rather dry.

The following chapter, Looking for the Labyrinth, traces the historical record of the Knossos site and labyrinth beginning with Ancient Greek artefacts (red and black figure cups and amphoras) and literary references, which illustrate various aspects of the Minoan myths (the Cretan Bull, Pasiphae, the Minotaur (Asterion), Daedalus and Icarus, Theseus and Ariadne). The chapter also explores medieval and later representations of Knossos and conjectures as to its location, which had been lost by the time of historical records. This culminated with
Minos Kalokairinos’ rediscovery of the likely site of Knossos at the end of the 1870’s followed by Arthur Evans’ excavation of the site from 1899 (after this became politically possible following relaxation of earlier Ottoman rule).
Again, although this chapter is academically necessary to set out how the Minoan myths were perpetuated since Ancient Greece and the historical search for, and rediscovery of, Knossos, this is dry reading.

The third chapter considers the excavation at Knossos under the direction of Arthur Evans through to the 1930’s. This is the most interesting section of the book, well illustrated, and explaining Evans’ approach and concentration on the Bronze Age archaeological remains.
Although with hindsight and the benefit of improved archaeological techniques one can understand how some may criticise Evans’ approach, this reader agrees with the opinion of one of the writers that:
The range of opinions about the restorations at Knossos is wide, but one fact is incontrovertible: had Evans not initiated restorations so soon and so aggressively, Knossos would have largely disintegrated.

The final chapter, again including sections by different authors on specific discoveries, considers the archaeological evidence since the 1930’s and is useful in trying to place the site of Knossos in the larger archaeological story of Crete and the period from the neolithic through to the early Byzantine.
As Andrew Shapland concludes:
But as the reworking by Odysseus of heroic genealogy to cast himself as the brother of Idomeneus shows, myths are malleable. From Homer onwards, different authors found their own truths in the story of Theseus, Ariadne and the Minotaur, and the Labyrinth shifted between an Egyptian Temple, a cave near Gortyn and the coins of Knossos.
Although archaeologists will never demonstrate the truth in myth, they have shown that Knossos is one of the oldest continually inhabited places in Europe, and that, for a long period, it was the most important centre of Crete. It is impossible to prove that the textile workers or dancers of the Bronze Age palace were remembered in Ariadne's ball of thread or dancing floor, or that exquisitely crafted objects such as shell-shaped stone vessels or bronze daggers inlaid with griffins inspired stories about the master craftsman Daedalus. It is speculation to connect the labyrinthine plan of the Bronze Age palace to the Labyrinth, or frescoes of bulls to the Minotaur.
Instead scholars - Minos Kalokairinos, Sir Arthur Evans and those who followed them - have reworked the myths of Crete by combining them with the material remains of Knossos. Their archacological finds at Knossos have added to the many layers of meaning of the Labyrinth.
Profile Image for Rosalind.
42 reviews
July 27, 2023
I enjoyed the exhibition & revisited it in the catalogue. I grew up with the Arthur Evans (& Mary Renault) interpretation of Knossos, so it's exciting to see all the excavations & reinterpretation that has happened more recently. Something to follow up - a photo of the entrance hall of Arthur Evans' house near Oxford, with Minoan style pillars and a replica of the Knossos throne at the end. I wonder what the rest of the house was like...
Profile Image for Susan.
734 reviews2 followers
November 1, 2023
Beautiful book to accompany the exhibition at the Ashmolean Museum earlier this year. Brought back happy memories of our visit to the exhibition and also to Crete in 2022.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews