This was a tricky one to rate, as it earned another star in the last hour. I'll try and be as honest as possible here.
First off, clearly, Brite can write the hell out of anything. I feel a shot of reader's adrenaline when something's a bit more nuanced than the mainstream, not in content/plot, but delivery. Barker had it. I love that thrill when it hits, and recall in the last 10 years feeling it with writers such as Matthew Tait and Autumn Christian (both of whom I cannot recommend enough).
Here's the honest bit, and this is just my personal experience. I'm coming to Brite very late in the game. I was frequently recommended Brite in my 20s, but I felt that her work wouldn't be my thing. Why? Because of the people recommending her. Brite felt very 'faux goth' at the time (around 2000 when nu metal peaked in popularity). Reading Brite was like a more extreme piercing, or a larger tattoo. Rice was for your trendy goth, Brite was only appreciated by the real deal. Apparently. Of course, no one could tell me what made Brite special, only that you simply had to read it. To me, it felt like a fashion accessory. Of course, once times moved on, people generally stopped recommending Brite. Okay, history lesson over.
I wish I had challenged my own dismissive ideals and given her a go. I think I would have had more of that special feeling when these stories were fresh and contemporary. While I can see why work of this nature attracted the fashionably alternative boundary pushers late in the last century, there's significantly more at play here.
So I started this collection, written between the mid-80s to early 90s. Initially, I was going to rate this with three stars. I've been in this situation before, in that while the author has phenomenal skill, its the book itself that is its weakness. How? Well...the sum is not greater than its parts. Hear me out.
Firstly, as I say, this is an older collection. In all the years between, we may read the same plots to the point they're now tropes, but back then, they were genuinely remarkable. With this book, and especially perhaps the introduction over-hyping, I didn't find anything too challenging or unsettling. Splatterpunk was thrown around, and I feel that the meaning of the team has changed over the 30 years represented here. Additionally, we generally would not have been reading about characters with varying sexualities and desires when these stories were released, not in the main stream, so I feel that this is another factor that made Brite stand out from the pack. Again, not such a controversial topic now. Without igniting any kind of political debate, if I read about a male character in a same sex relationship wherein they do the usual loving relationship things: holding hands, kissing, sleeping together, vacuuming out the car on a Sunday...its just people going about their lives. Back in the late 80s, this aspect may have raised a few eyebrows with readers not exposed to what was considered an 'alternative lifestyle'. Therefore, while this shows change in society but is to the detriment of the book, some of the stories lose a little of their...challenge?
Secondly, while I have nothing against pale, sensitive, darkly thoughtful, artistic young male musicians in bohemian sexual lifestyles with each other...grouping several stories that feature these characters types became tedious very quickly. With the start of each story, I had a mental bingo card of character traits and was disappointed as they rolled out one by one. This is further exacerbated with each story being quiet in its horror, with our now somewhat cookie cut characters experiencing some slight supernatural or personal tragedy. All the stories tended to blur together. Around the halfway mark, a story features a pair of musicians for the second time, and I didn't realise straight away. I even wondered if these two had been the same two characters in the other stories, but no.
The book earned a further star with the last two stories that knock it out of the park. Perhaps it was because Brite mixed it up with the characters, or that they're a bit more down to earth and thus relatable. I really connected with the thoughts around loss, the contemplation of choices made, the regrets, the intrusive images. Wonderful. The heart-breaking penultimate story, The Elder, sits nicely in my top five short stories. Ever.
The fact I wrote all this shows that there's more going on than usual, and I applaud a book that makes you think about, well, what you think about it!