More than perhaps any other of Sand’s many novels, this one written a little later in her career gives the most realistic portrait of everyday life in the Berry countryside of the mid-19th century. Even more than her trio of pastoral novels (La Mare au Diable, La Petite Fadette and François le Champi), Sand delves into the daily routines, foibles, and disappointments of the simple country folk whom she knew so well at her estate at Nohant. Unfortunately, in my opinion, this is also the least compelling and appealing of all the Sand novels I have read. I just found the characters flat and their various frustrations, jealousies, etc., uninteresting. Nevertheless, this novel still gets a lot of praise from Sand fans and literary critics, and merits an entire chapter in the 1995 book Romantic Visions: The Novels of George Sand (1995) by Robert Godwin-Jones who praises its regional and historical authenticity. Jones also likes Sand’s emphasis on family, nature, religion, and music, which marks her post-1848 departure from the social protests in her earlier fiction. Yes, Sand does meticulously describe the region down to the tiniest villages, forests, ponds, etc., Brulette is a pretty peasant girl loved by several young men in the area. Her cousin Etienne reluctantly accepts that she has no romantic feelings for him. Lifelong friend Josèph also loves Brulette, but feels unworthy of her. But then, he has another interest—learning to play and perform on the bagpipes. (No, pipes are not just Scottish. The instrument has a long Celtic tradition in western France). And the mule driver Huriel has captured her interest. Then a baby shows up quite literally on Brulette’s doorstep. How might this change her future? Probably the most admirable part of the story is that Brulette is spunky enough to believe in herself and in the idea that partners in marriage should be equal. Except for one bizarre and unexpected tragedy in the narrative, this is a nice little slice of Sand in which almost all eventually goes well—sweet and a bit bland.