⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4 stars)
Coven Mitt by Rebecca Regnier is a fun, fast-paced paranormal cozy mystery that leans hard into humor, community, and supernatural chaos—in the best way possible. Returning to Widow’s Bay felt like slipping back into a familiar, delightfully weird small town where vampires roam, witches are learning the ropes (and battling hot flashes), and danger is always just around the corner.
Marzie Nowak continues to be an engaging and relatable lead. Juggling her role as the town’s only reporter, a suspicious murder, a growing vampire problem, and a brand-new coven keeps the story moving at a brisk pace. The mystery surrounding the murdered farmer is solid, with plenty of suspects and red herrings to keep things interesting, even as the paranormal elements ramp up.
One of the highlights of this installment is the expanded focus on the coven itself. The addition of The Crones and their old-school magical wisdom adds depth and plenty of laughs, especially as the newer witches try to figure out spells, teamwork, and their own powers. Agnes the snarky cat once again steals scenes, and the banter throughout the book is sharp and entertaining.
While some plot threads feel a bit crowded at times—with vampires, witches, werewolves, and home renovations all competing for attention—the humor and charm carry the story through. Fans of cozy mysteries with a supernatural twist, strong female friendships, and plenty of sass will find a lot to enjoy here.
Coven Mitt is a playful and engaging sequel that builds nicely on the world of Widow’s Bay and leaves me eager to see what magical trouble comes next.