Rating, of course, reflective of compendium itself rather than its constituents; grateful to have fifty influential insights so neatly packaged—as much as, inevitably, I might dispute some inclusions—but Aldous' editorial intros are as lacking in linguistic flair as they are any insight beyond bare essentials. If that latter point seems harsh it's only born out of disappointment, given the strength of Colm Tóibín's stage-setting foreword; the former point bears evidence aplenty in ludicrous lines like "Dukes was not father to the emerging 'Celtic tiger', but could justifiably claim that he opened the door at the maternity hospital for the expectant mother". What lumpen platitudinal nonsense, justly exposed as such by the rich rhetoric it's so often disserving.