Review of the Dragons of a New Age Trilogy.
It's not an easy task to step into Weis and Hickman's shoes and write a central trilogy for an established fantasy world. Weis and Hickman are professional performers of high fantasy and, despite the fact that Dragonlance is essentially a fantasy world created for a roleplaying game, they created a world that exists independent of its typecast mould. They invented characters that they cared deeply about and that readers could sympathise with. Jean Rabe tries to put her stamp upon the the series as it enters a new age. The Chaos War has upended most of Krynn's power structures and those holes are filled by newer, bigger, vicious dragons. Kellendros is a portal traveling blue dragon searching for the human soulmate, Kitiara, while Malystryx is a foreign red monster without a shred of compassion. As the dragons divide up the land and rally Dark Knights to control the populace, Goodmoon, now an old lady, teams up with Palin Majere and gathers a new generation of heroes. Rabe strikes the balance quite well, not relying too much on Weis and Hickman's main characters but giving them their due. Palin Majere, as the main mover and shaker, develops well into a troubled, frustrated soul still determined to make the world a better place. In the first book he is the only older character to play a major role as we are introduced to a new and varied cast - Dhamon, Feril, Rig, Shaon, Blister, Jasper and Groller. The success of the trilogy hangs on the shoulders of those characters.
It's a shaky start but by the end of the first book some of the characters start to come into their own. Rig is a welcome protagonist, brave, reckless and unforgiving. Blister breaks the kender mould and has a lovable heart. Feril, a nature sorceress elf, is just a cool addition to a fantasy adventure. Shaon's sensitive, stubborn soul provides the first book with some believable sense of tragedy. Groller, the deaf half-ogre, and Jasper, Goldmoon's apprentice, seem initially irrelevant but both grow as the trilogy progresses. A lot of the book's success, however, depends on Dhamon. The typical tortured soul/troubled past hero gives the first and second books of the trilogy its twists and turns. It's a shame that Dhamon himself is rather lacking in character because some of the plots that revolve around him are quite intriguing. Rabe is actually very good at withholding secrets and tying her many loose ends together. The disadvantage of this is the sheer number of plots and characters that she tries to bring in. The second book, Day of the Tempest, suffers greatly from this. Adventures in the white dragon's realm and the green dragon's jungle are rushed and over-populated, despite some exciting scenes. Everyone, no doubt, would favour different additions to the story - I enjoyed, for example, the return of Gilthanas and the conclusion of his romance with Silvara - but Rabe has chosen to put all of them in and the result is a bit cluttered. I would have liked to read about Ulin, Palin's son, and his lust for knowledge and magic, but there isn't time here to make the story work.
The biggest problem is that Rabe spends far too long bogged down in bloody, impossible battles. Far too often, the characters are brought to the brink of death through horrendous injuries, only to be brought back by miraculous healing. Too often are they rescued by fabulous spells. This is all contradictory because the majority of the plot revolves around the fact that magic and the Gods have departed the world. They busy themselves searching for powerful magical artifacts to return magic to the world but always seem to come up with an immensely powerful enchantment whenever it's needed. Groller, in particular, suffers countless deaths - broken back, burned, stabbed - and Rig and Dhamon always fight on with superhuman strength and endless stamina. Rabe isn't afraid to kill off a main character or two but you're never quite sure whether or not they are going to stay dead. Weis & Hickman are also guilty of this, it has to be said, but usually they stay within the boundaries of what the story has led you to believe is possible. By the end, Malystryx and her allies have gathered such power that it all seems a bit ridiculous and climatic battles, such as against the sea dragon Brine, just don't seem probable.
That said, I enjoyed the third book most of all. The tension between Rig and Dhamon is palpable and Jasper comes into his own, ending with some true heroics and providing yet another twist. I liked the mysterious conclave of wizards and the betrayal of Palin - it's one of the tensest scenes in the trilogy. Rabe rushes through the end - the quest to retrieve the crown from the sea elves and the final confrontation - and there is far too much convenient teleporting around to make the grand plot possible, but I liked most of the characters by that point and wanted to know how it ended. There are so many questions left unanswered - Who is the shadow dragon? What happened to the shadow sorcerer? Will Kellendros find Kitiara or will Malystryx have her revenge? And will Dhamon find peace and redemption? When I read these books 20 odd years ago I remember dying to know what happened next. I never did read the follow on trilogy though, which does say something about the less attractive prospect of reading Jean Rabe compared to the draw of letting Weis and Hickman pull you into their next trilogy. This time, I will read on, if only for completion's sake. For Dragonlance fans there is plenty to enjoy here. A few less action scenes, less blood and near death situations, and more of the intrigue and secrets that she does so well, and Jean Rabe would have a much worthier successor to Dragons of Summer Flame.