I enjoyed this one as much as the prior books in this series.
I don't think that we had enough clues in advance to actually solve it, though - perhaps one suspicious clue, but nothing conclusive. I had my eye on a different suspect.
I hadn't realized that this series is holiday themed. "Hail to the Chef" is around Thanksgiving and Christmas, and "Eggsecutive Orders" is around Easter. I don't generally read holiday-themed books out of season, but had this one on hand. Poor Ollie is always too busy preparing for the various holidays to actually enjoy them. They seem like more stress and work to her, although she does get the satisfaction of a job well done.
Tom still does not give Ollie the benefit of the doubt, although I realize that even off-duty skepticism is a career hazard for law enforcement. He refused to listen to the strong distinction between Ollie sleuthing, and people telling her things without her questioning them or bringing up the topic. I'm not sure that Ollie herself really thought this through with such clarity either.
I liked the apology that Ollie gave her family. It is genuine, without being manipulative. Gary Chapman, in "The 5 Apology Languages" would've labeled her apology as Acts of Service, but with the high quality of the food involved, I could've also seen it labeled as a Gift.
I also liked meeting Ollie's family, and seeing that they usually get along well. Too many authors only write about dysfunctional families, and so it's good to see a family enjoying being together.
"The Church - and in particular, our parish - fed their need to be needed." It's an interesting thought, worth the self-reflection. I hope I help out because of the genuine needs of others, and not to boost myself, either in my own eyes or the eyes of others.
"Why do you need to understand? Why can't you just accept the facts as presented to you?" I can relate to that statement, even if it's not in the realm of solving mysteries. I do want to see the underlying data first, to see if it's been verbally described accurately and charted accurately. At our office party, they wanted each of us to take a personality quiz, and mine came up as "Skeptic." Everyone else's read some light-hearted version of "Encourager" or "Harmony", which is, I suppose, fitting for educators but not engineers.
If someone had asked me, "Why do you need to understand? Why can't you just accept the facts as presented to you?" I would've responded, "Because I have a brain." Or, if I were being more polite, perhaps I'd say, "I think. That's who I am."
I was a little disappointed in Mrs. Campbell's lack of help in this one.
Yes, Ollie should've informed security when one character claimed to know whodunit. Why is that even a question rather than something she decided not to do, just because he is an unusual character? He still might know something.
I wanted to know more about that last-mentioned meal for and with the Campbells. What did they eat and who prepared it and what did they talk about?
SPOILER ... One other reader complained that Ollie talked about her relationship with Tom as "...more than just lovers. We'd reached a level of comfort and intimacy...". and then this reviewer added, "but she dumped him so she could snoop in the case."
SPOILER CONTINUED ... Well, I am not on the pro-Tom side. After reading the first book, I wrote, "I didn't care much for Ollie's boyfriend, Tom. He should've cared more about what matters to her, and he was sulky and uncommunicative for a long time. Demanding, rude, not giving her the benefit of the doubt, not even listening to her. Admittedly, he can't talk about his job, but he shut her out entirely. Other than his good looks, I don't see that he has anything good to bring to a relationship." I am not sorry to see him go, even if, as I suspect, he might come back later in the series.
SPOILER STILL CONTINUED ... I prefer to think of Ollie's dumping him as she came to her senses. She thinks of it in terms of not being able to be herself around him, herself being, primarily a snoop. Eh, that one I'm not so worked up about. She can mature and work on the morality of when it is and isn't appropriate, and they might've been able to come to a consensus. But I hope she also realizes his other red flags and moves on.
Favorite quote:
"~ boosted our morale by his very presence." I've known people like that. Although I hope to be someone like that, I feel I don't have the necessary effervescence and extroversion for it.