Counterpleasures

by Karmen MacKendrick

Takes up a series of literary and physical pleasures that do not appear to be pleasurable, ranging from Christian saintly asceticism to Sadean narrative to contemporary s/m practices. Counterpleasures takes up a series of literary and physical pleasures that do not appear to be pleasurable, ranging from saintly asceticism to Sadean narrative to leathersex. Each is placed in its cultural context to unfold a history of transgressive pleasure and to argue for the value and power of such pleasures as resistant to more totalizing forms of power. "This book is about paradoxes in erotic experience, focused on the ways that pleasure and pain can become indistinguishable and what this confusability of the two conditions means to bodies of knowledge, such as Freudian psychology, predicated on understanding pleasure and pain as opposites. MacKendrick goes far beyond simply showing us what we probably already know--that tension can be pleasure, that pain can be a component of joy, etc. She does not leave this meeting of Eros and Thanatos mysterious, but instead offers plausible theories to account for the paradoxical experiences of 'perverse' writers, saints, martyrs, and late-twentieth-century s/m practitioners. She goes on to explain how these theories augment or revise philosophical and psychoanalytic texts on the same topics. A lot has been written about masochism and sadism by feminists in the 1980s and 1990s, but MacKendrick offers a fresh perspective and many new insights. She really does value what is different and shows why recognition of it is valuable both to the ways we think and the ways we live." -- Carol Siegel, coeditor of Genders "This book is a joy to read. MacKendrick's personal voice comes through in a highly-engaging, indeed, seductive way. Her approach combines classical philosophical analysis with theological theory, and brings these two disciplines into conversation with each other in original ways that intersect with contemporary theories of sexualities and genders. While s/m per se may seem to be a 'marginal topic,' MacKendrick uses s/m and other 'counterpleasures' to address a broad range of issues that are of the utmost concern to anyone working in the field of contemporary cultural studies." -- Lynda Hart, University of Pennsylvania

Genres: Philosophy, Religion, Nonfiction

Paperback

First published May 1, 1999

About the author

Karmen MacKendrick is a professor of philosophy with a love for theology, dance, music, and just about all things made of words.

Reviews

[Io Perl-Strahan · Rating 5 out of 5]

Read this for my thesis, loved it. Especially the last chapter or two, theory as poetry, as what hits u hard. Love and loss and forgoing the self of it all.

[Amy Hughes · Rating 2 out of 5]

The "ok" part is not so much a quibble with MacKendrick as much as it was just not in my interest to read deeply about Sade and Masoch at this particular juncture. I was primarily interested in her working out of the connection (if any) between desire, pleasure, pain and restraint within the context of Christian asceticism. This was a fruitful reading if for nothing else than to put forth the rather uncomfortable discussion that on a philosophical and bodily level Christian asceticism and s/m cross paths in their respective portrayals of power and restraint, subjectivity and negotiation of limits with respect to the body.

[Henny Sari · Rating 4 out of 5]

hm.... it's amazing knowing n feeling the flow from masochism to ascetism.... betul2 spiritual. masokis sejati... bukan spt yang banyak kita ketahui.., hanya fisik dan berhenti pada tubuh. McKendrick justru sanggup menjelaskan rinci dengan rasional intensitas yang menjadikan segalanya dekat... benci dengan cinta... sakit dengan nikmat... masokis dg asketis.. ck..ck..ck...

[BookAddict ✒ La Crimson Femme · Rating 2 out of 5]

This book was too philosophical for me. After the first few chapters, I just didn't care enough. There were some interesting parts to it. After a while, it was too much like work and I have other books I'd rather enjoy.