Once thought to be the task of metaphysics, the synthesis of knowledge has been discounted by many philosophers today. Benedict Ashley, a leading Thomistic scholar, argues that it remains a valid and intellectually fruitful pursuit by situating metaphysics as an endeavor that must cross disciplinary and cultural boundaries.
Working from a realist Thomistic epistemology, Ashley asserts that we must begin our search for wisdom in the natural sciences; only then, he believes, can we ensure that our claims about immaterial and invisible things are rooted in reliable experience of the material. Any attempt to share wisdom, he insists, must derive from a context that is both interdisciplinary and intercultural.
Ashley offers an ambitious analysis and synthesis of major historical contributions to the unification of knowledge, including non-Western traditions. Beginning with the question "Nonsense or Wisdom?" Ashley moves from a critical examination of the foundations of modern science to quantum physics and the Big Bang; from Aristotle's theory of being and change, through Aquinas's five ways, to a critical analysis of modern and postmodern thought. Ashley is able to interweave the approaches of the great philosophers by demonstrating their contributions to philosophical thought in a concrete, specific manner. In the process, he accounts for a contemporary culture overwhelmed by the fragmentation of data and thirsting for an utterly transcendent yet personal God. The capstone of a remarkable career, The Way Toward Wisdom will be welcomed by students in philosophy and theology.
Benedict M. Ashley, O.P. is Emeritus Professor of Moral Theology at Aquinas Institute of Theology in St. Louis, Missouri. Before his conversion to Catholicism, Fr. Ashley was a professed atheist and communist. He found his way to the Church through his study of the works of St. Thomas Aquinas under Mortimer Adler at the University of Chicago. Before his ordination to the priesthood through the Order of Preachers in 1948, he received his Doctorate in Political Science at the University of Notre Dame. Fr. Ashley also holds a Ph.D. in Philosophy and a Master’s in Sacred Theology. He is an Associate Faculty of Philosophy for the Institute for Advanced Physics, and was a Senior Fellow of the National Catholic Center for Bioethics. Among Fr. Ashley’s books is Health Care Ethics, co-authored in 1975, a fundamental text on the topic of Catholic medical ethics, now in its fifth edition.
In his book, The Way Toward Wisdom: An Interdisciplinary and Intercultural Introduction to Metaphysics, Dr. Benedict M. Ashley, O.P., advocates for a postmodern revival of metaphysics as the only mediating discipline that can facilitate dialogue between material and spiritual worldviews and among specialized academic disciplines. He first notes the pressing need for such a recovery by giving historical and typological accounts of the philosophical and religious origins of today's worldwide secular culture, which tends to reduce all knowledge to modern science and brackets questions of spiritual realities to the level of irrational thinking. Our present day Secular Humanism, he argues, does not provide the foundational principles that are found in a predecessor discipline to metaphysics concerned with the study of mobile bodies. Such a study would provide clear, consistent concepts about causality, time, and place that are necessary for the modern sciences to attain a fuller understanding of its own findings. They would also open the way towards rediscovering the spiritual dimension of human persons and their place in a community of both material and purely spiritual creatures that are all ordered towards their ultimate fulfillment in a truly existing God.
Such a project, Ashley reasons, would establish the principles of a science concerned with the study of contingently existing beings and the nature of the cause(s) responsible for their contingent being, the study known as metaphysics. This would be done by using analogies taken from our common experiences of the world around us and reasoning from those very same effects to establish some likeness to be found in the spiritual causes that caused them. This is one way Ashley helps his readers to understand the nature of God and the internal logical consistency in the Christian dogma of the Triune God. He also spends a great part of his book showing the ways in which metaphysics provides orderliness and unification among the various special disciplines (e.g. ancient/modern mathematics, physics/chemistry, logic, ethical sciences--including politics, economics/business, literature and the arts, traditional and revisionist historical studies, etc.). It is this type of intellectual unity that would help curious students entering the university system for the first time to "make sense of it all" or "get it all together."
Ashley's book helps one to contextualize his or her studies in Aristotelian-Thomist primary texts within the milieu of a postmodern, secular society. In other words; his book introduces new, creative, and attentive means that ensure that every one of us who are engaged in the Great Conversation understands the objectively empirical origins of the language we use.
Throughout his book, Ashley made copious references to Dr. John Deely, a Philosophy professor at Saint Vincent College in La Trobe, Pennsylvania, and promulgator of the study of semiotics, or of 'signs.' Deely's main contention, in the words of Ashley, is that because we first understand something to exist before we come to a more reasoned understanding of its nature and because the relational nature of signs transcends the foundational subjects in which they cohere, and are thus 'suprasubjective,' realists and idealists can engage, at the very least, in effective dialogue with one another, each in his/her own contentious but perhaps difficult and confused understanding of the tangled 'semiotic web' of relations between the mind-independent and mind-dependent objects found in this initial understanding of Being. Interestingly, Ashley and Aquinas extend the meaning of this 'suprasubjective,' relational understanding of purely intellectual relations in order to defend the internal, logical consistency of the notion of three 'Persons' in one divine substance. They claim that because the very of nature of these relations transcends their subject-hosts, they do not complexify or divide their internal unities. Hence, there is no logical conflict in arguing that three purely intellectual, 'subsistent relations' are truly, undividedly, and really identical with its divine essence, 'Three Persons in One God.'
I highly recommend this book to any intellectually-minded, curious philosophy student who wishes to get their feet wet in the Aristotelian-Thomistic perspective of philosophy. This book is for a student who wants to understand how everything in the world around us--and in us--all fit together in a way that is logically consistent and truly satisfying to our most natural desire for truth.
This is also a great book for its footnotes, which references other authors and their books for deeper study.
At the heart of the book is a clear realisation that people inevitably (and inescapably) apply metaphysics in their lives and thinking patterns. And they do so whether they are aware of it or not, and they even do so when they are denying the existence of metaphyics. (As such a denial is in fact a metaphysical claim!).
What the author sets out to do is to recognise the unavoidability of metaphysics and so to suggest an agenda whereby readers can acquire a healthy metaphysics. The first step of that agenda is renaming the subject to metascience. Part of the reason for that renaming is that metaphysics has been subject to philosophical disputes over the centuries, so to some extent those old issues can be side-stepped by renaming. Whether the side-step gain is worth the price of novelty and consequent confusion about the term is less clear.
The body of the book is the clarification of metascience through mainly an overview of what different philosophical and cultural traditions have classified as ‘wisdom.’ This includes a review of literature from many parts of the world (Europe, India, China, etc), and the scope of the book is commendably broad in places. This leads to the author’s vision of what a ‘unification of knowledge’ might look like. Writing as a Dominican, it is perhaps unsurprising that the ideal seems to have been set by Thomas Aquinas, a thousand years earlier.
By way of conclusion the author argues that current university courses tend to fragment knowledge by imposing distinctions between disciplines. There may be some truth in that, but it is also a fact that no one can learn everything, and so it is inevitable that choices have to be made. Perhaps what the author is getting at, is that there should be an underlying unit in every single course, which addresses what he thinks metascience should be, so that humanity as a whole has a more healthy engagement with the fundamental thinking of metascience (?).
But the problem is that although he himself has a clear view of metascience, as essentially Thomistic -Aristotelian philosophy, there are many thinkers who disagree with that philosophical approach. To some extent the fragmentation which the author laments is simply the reality of philosophical divergence and diversity of view. It is all very well to lament that de facto situation, but it is much less clear how the author thinks matters could be solved to eradicate undesirable divergence. Clearly, even if there were an agreed body of knowledge or thinking skills the fact of deep seated philosophical divergences would mean that it would be impossible for philosophers to accept a single vision of what counts as metascience. So, it is unclear how the author thinks that his vision could ever be achieved.
Some readers may well note how the educational ideal of liberal education seems remarkably similar to the author’s own cultural background of American education. He gives a rational for preferring that approach, but what is the evidence for the claim that a proper education requires engagement with great books and classics. Yes, of course that could constitute a good education, but the question is whether it is the only approach. The same question arises with the author’s commitment to Aristotelianism. Are there really no other ways of thinking about reality?
This is a long book of 600+ pages. It felt overly long in places and I think the core insights could have been transmitted in a book of half the length. The book also felt a little as if it was trying to argue an objective extra-cultural thesis, while nevertheless finding the ideal in the author’s own subjective cultural experiences as a Thomistic American.
Overall, I think I can see what the author was trying to do and say, but I found the wordiness of the book distracting and undermining the reading experience. Its not entirely clear to me who the ideal readership would be.
After having grounded myself—such as with William A. Wallace, O.P.'s The Modeling of Nature: Philosophy of Science and Philosophy of Nature in Synthesis—in the River Forest / Aristotelean-Thomism epistemology that all intellectual knowledge comes through the senses, this book, my first on Metascience (more ambiguously called "metaphysics"), was a natural continuation and excellent introduction. Only via natural science can one come to understand Metascience. Metascience is becoming more necessary today for the unification of knowledge in our interdisciplinary, multicultural world where knowledge has undergone much fragmentation.