Loy Machedo’s Book Review – Six Sigma: The Breakthrough Management Strategy Revolutionizing the World's Top Corporations by Mikel Harry Ph.D. and Richard Schroeder
There are some authors who come out books to educate, to entertain or to express. And then there are those who come out with books disguised as Secret Sales Brochures to do what Rod Tidwell (Cuba Gooding, Jr.) shouts in Jerry Maguire “Show me the Money”. Six Sigma by Mikel Harry and Richard Schroeder book does just that.
This is one book that falls short of stating a strategy or on the nuts & bolts of Six Sigma and goes on an incessant rant on what Six Sigma has done for Motorola, GE and a host of forgettable names. The book is nothing but a 300 paged advertisement designed with a sad intention to generate more business. Oh and by the way I do not know if it was some coincidence to state that Mikel & Schroeder were also the CEO & President of Six Sigma Academy which raked in over $10 Million in consulting and training fees in 1998.
Now, let’s understand this. Every new quality tool that comes out – TQM, Kaizen, the infamous and outdated ISO 9000 – almost all of them beat their hairy chest and shout in the corporate jungle “ We are the next new secret tool which will change the landscape of how business is being done”. And because you will adopt us – you will make a gazillion dollars in profits! But (yes, the big butt) you have to have our own so called certified experts leading and guiding the way, following everything we say and doing whatever we tell you – And then you can live happily ever after. (with the normal clichés of Cutting Costs, Increasing Profits, Improved Productivity and yes, Effective versus Efficiency).
That was the song I heard being sung when I was 18 years old. Nothing changed then and now at 35, I doubt anything will change. Now a days it sounds more like the Flavor of the month when going to an Ice Cream Parlor. In the end – it’s the same thing – just a different taste. Absolutely nothing revolutionary or nothing that can be called Break-through.
Now let’s suppose Six Sigma works – which is seems to be for a few companies. But then what are the drawbacks that will brand this as a fad destined to fail?
Here are my views:
1) Six Sigma will work only when all the employees are in sync or total harmony with the vision, values and variables of the company’s Decision. Can that be assured?
2) What kind of company can afford Six Sigma, along with the Black Belts, the Master Black Belt?
3) How many companies & employees want a team of selected experts to do nothing but keep an eye on the operations, find the faults and report these variations to the management?
4) Can Six Sigma help a failed product succeed? Forget that. Can it assure any product or service or company to survive the unpredictable sickness of the Global recession when companies are looking for ways and means to survive?
5) What point is it to have a Six Sigma process when a product may have a short shelf life? Or for a service when a team may not survive the challenges?
This book does nothing else but keep singing the song of how great and almighty Six Sigma is to the point of total and absolute boredom.
Moment of Truth
From these fancy-pansy titles like Black Belt and Master Black Belt, to the numerical value calculations of 3.45 that state what level the organization is currently at to hoping to reach to the point of greatness, Six Sigma is a glorious fad that is bound to die out very soon. Just as people have learnt how to play around and get the ISO certification – which eventually became a discontinued process as people realized it is nothing but a spiritual name for pea-brained documentation, Six Sigma is another new fad that will bleed itself to death. Slowly and Surely.
Overall Rating
2 out of 10.
The 2 is only because I got introduced to a few fancy terms of what Six Sigma is and to the terminologies of Six Sigma.
Loy Machedo
loymachedo.com | loymachedo.tv