Grades 3-5.
Motif- jinnee.
In this version of the tale, which is set in China, Aladdin is portrayed as a lazy troublemaker. He was such a troublemaker that his father died of worry. Aladdin and his mother were barely surviving only because she would spin cotton and sell it so they could eat. One day while Aladdin was out, a stranger claiming to be his uncle asked him to accompany him to a “garden of wonder.” When they arrive, he tells Aladdin to retrieve the lamp and not to touch anything else. Aladdin brings back the lamp but asks to be helped out of the garden first. The man turned out to be an evil sorcerer known as the Moor and was enraged that Aladdin did not give him the lamp so he closed up the entrance to the garden and left Aladdin for dead. While in the garden Aladdin had found an iron ring that claimed to be able to help him. In desperation, he rubbed the ring and a dark jinnee came out and commanded him to be set free from the garden. He then returned home and rubbed the lamp and another jinnie came out and Aladdin commanded that he bring food. Later, Aladdin sees the princess and falls in love at first sight. He sends his mother to the sultan with a gold plate of jewels to ask for her hand. The sultan’s royal vizier challenges him and says they would consider the proposal if Aladdin brought forty slaves with a plate of jewels each. He then went to rub the lamp and his command was once again granted. The sultan then said that he could marry his daughter if he could build her a suitable palace. The next day a palace appears and the princess falls in love with Aladdin at first sight. Meanwhile, the Moor still wanted the lamp and he uses magic and sees that Aladdin was still alive and married to the princess. The Moor returns to China and gets a hold of the lamp. He uses it to tear away the palace from China with the princess inside and gets it taken back to his garden in Morocco. The Sultan gives Aladdin twenty-four hours to save the princess so he uses his ring and is taken to Morocco by the jinnee of the ring. In the end he saves the princess and his greed goes unnoticed. Aladdin’s portrayal of a lazy troublemaker getting the girl and all the riches is not a good message to give to children. He did not earn any of it. His only act of heroism was when he actually made the effort to save the princess. This was quickly shattered when he decided to cut off the Moor’s head who was already down from drinking sleeping herbs. A strength of this book was that the author kept the tales original setting. It was strange thought that although he kept this location, the images were clearly not in China. The illustrations were done in layering of chalk pastels. The main colors used in the illustrations were all earthy tones. Violets and reds were used for the villains, greens were used for Aladdin and his mother, and bright oranges were used for the sultan, and the slaves. This book was more text than illustrations. I would not recommend this book. The setting and illustrations do not match and I did not like how Aladdin’s greed went unnoticed. He was also very disrespectful to his mother and his mother was weak because she let him get away with being a troublemaker before he even had the lamp. Furthermore, Aladdin never made wishes he made commands and the commands were not limited.