The Lady of Bolton Hill

by Elizabeth Camden

When Clara Endicott and Daniel Tremain's worlds collide after twelve years apart, the spark that was once between them immediately reignites into a romance neither of them thought possible.

But time has changed them both.

Daniel is an industrial titan with powerful enemies. Clara is an idealistic journalist determined to defend underprivileged workers.

Can they withstand the cost of their convictions while their hearts--and lives--hang in the balance?

Genres: Historical Fiction, Christian Fiction, Romance, Christian, Historical, Historical Romance, Fiction

336 pages, Paperback

First published April 23, 2011

Reviews

[Heather · Rating 5 out of 5]

THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS I HAVE READ IN A LONG TIME!!! At first it seems it will be too predictable and that the main characters get along a little too well after their 12 year separation. I was looking forward to some tension and anger, especially on Daniel's part toward Clara. The tension and anger comes, but when you least expect it! And, that's where the UNPREDICTABILITY of this book comes in! Nothing ever happens the way you think it's going to! And so much more of the plot goes places you never expect when you first start reading. I chuckled at several parts as my heart constricted just loving the way things were said and how it was all going! Clara has a way of being so sweet and yet fierce and brave when it comes to sticking up for the down-trodden. Usually I can't stand "sweet" heroins. But I was never annoyed with Clara. I really liked her. She tried to help people turn their lives around and turn to God, in a non-annoying or preachy way. Any religious aspects were mellow and beautifully handled. I teared up a couple of times, and I RARELY cry when reading a book! This didn't even really come across as a Christian book, it just had a nice, feel-good message woven in to a wonderfuly, perfect romance/mystery story. There is also a secondary character, Bane, who I cringed about at first and thought I wouldn't care if he did turn his life around, he'd still be a shady character, but I came to LOVE him, and I'd love to see a book written about him! This was just so perfect from beginning to end!! Elizabeth Camden is a new favorite author of mine...I love the way she tells a story! I'll buy anything she writes!

[Lindsey (Books for Christian Girls) · Rating 3 out of 5]

About this book:

“When Clara Endicott and Daniel Tremain's worlds collide after twelve years apart, the spark that was once between them immediately reignites into a romance neither of them thought possible.
But time has changed them both.
Daniel is an industrial titan with powerful enemies. Clara is an idealistic journalist determined to defend underprivileged workers.
Can they withstand the cost of their convictions while their hearts--and lives--hang in the balance?”


Series: Connected to the author’s other book, “Against the Tide”.


Spiritual Content- Scriptures and Biblical events are mentioned, quoted, remembered, & talked about; Prayers; Witnessing; Talks about God, Jesus, Heaven, forgiveness, faiths, salvation, & revenge; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Clara’s father is an influential religious leader; Daniel does not consider himself a Christian *Spoiler* Near the end he starts trying to pray and go to church to do better *End of Spoiler*; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of churches, church going, services, sermons, ministers, & missionaries; Mentions of Heaven; Mentions of a Christian newspaper; Mentions of Christians, faiths, salvation, & believing; Mentions of a Christian committing suicide and theology beliefs; Mentions of blessings, being blessed, & blessed things; Mentions of sins & sinners; A few mentions of thanking God; A couple mentions of Bible reading; A mention of someone being a gift from God; A mention of Easter;
*Note: Mentions of believing there’s a devil & doing evil; A few mentions of a woman looking like a Greek goddess; A mention of evil-minded intentions; A mention of ghosts in a building; A mention of an ungodly amount of something; A mention of a godforsaken place; A mention of something hurting like the devil; A mention of a person’s demons; A mention of someone burning in hell.


Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘dumb’, a ‘shut up’, two ‘sissy’s, five forms of ‘stupid’, and six ‘idiot’s; A mention of a curse (said by Daniel, not written); Some sass & eye rolling; Daniel wants major vengeance and is spiteful to a man because of the past; Being held hostage and at gunpoint & being threatened of being harmed or killed (up to semi-detailed); Fires & Explosions (up to semi-detailed); Pain, Gunfire, Seeing someone shot, Blood/Bleeding, & Injuries (up to semi-detailed); Being drugged & passing out (up to semi-detailed); Being in jail (barely-above-not-detailed); Many mentions of a death (murder, in a way), an explosion, accidents, burns and the smell of flesh, injuries, & wanting vengeance (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of crimes, criminals, drugs, drug users, drug smugglers, & drug trades; Mentions of Daniel’s mother who committed suicide & finding her (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of young child working in unsafe conditions & paying the price with their health (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of explosions, gunfire, & wounds (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of riots, strikes, public disturbances, violence, vandalism, & fires (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of kidnappings & children and adults being drugged (opium); Mentions of blood & injuries; Mentions of jails/prisons, arrests, & cases; Mentions of threats & threats against families (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of hatred; Mentions of manipulation; Mentions of starvation; Mentions of alcohol, drinking, & a tavern; Mentions of gossip; A few mentions of another’s suicide; A few mentions of the possibility of being killed/executed; A few mentions of dismembering someone/something (doesn’t actually happen, used as a cover); A few mentions of wanting to remove someone’s limbs; A few mentions of wars & deaths; A few mentions of stealing; A few mentions of blackmail & bribes; A few mentions of bets & betting; A few mentions of lies & lying; A few mentions of throwing up; A few mentions of gutting fishes; A couple mentions of thugs; A couple mentions of throwing someone overboard a ship; A couple mentions of poison; A couple mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of tobacco; A couple mentions of nightmares;
*Note: A few mentions of books & fictional characters.


Sexual Content- three (barely-above-not-detailed) hand/finger kisses, three (up to barely-above-not-detailed) cheek kisses, three forehead/head kisses, three barely-above-not-detailed kisses, two semi-detailed kisses (one of those including an ear being nipped), and a border-line semi-detailed // detailed kiss; Clara sits in Daniel’s lap (not-detailed); Touches, Nearness, & Smelling (up to semi-detailed); Wanting to touch (barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes; Noticing (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of prostitutes & a mother selling her young daughter to a brothel; A few mentions of kisses & kissing; A few mentions of reputations & chaperones; A few mentions of blushes; A few mentions of crushes; A couple mentions of men being called delicious; A couple mentions of a boyfriend; A mention of a man having a mistress; A mention of a man having the worst of intentions with a girl; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: A mention of a woman dress (not) being ripped off; A mention of kissing up to someone.

-Clara Endicott, age 28
-Daniel Tremain, age 31
P.O.V. switches between them & Bane (5x)
Set in 1879 (Prologue in 1867, Epilogue eight+ years later)
334 pages

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- Two Stars (and a half)
My personal Rating- Two Stars (and a half)
{Add ½ star for those okay with content mentioned above.}
While I first read this book in 2015, when I picked it up to re-read over three years later, it felt like a new book as I truly didn’t remember much if anything but tiny details.
This was Elizabeth Camden’s debut book and I definitely believe that she’s improved her writing skills and historical details since this release.
This re-read though? I have some different thoughts from my original thoughts.
However, some opinions stayed the same.
For one, I personally thought it was strange hearing Clara and her brother refer to their father by his first name.
On the note of Clara, she had a bit of a missionary-dating approach to Daniel in the sense that she wants to help fix the hole in his heart. I personally found myself annoyed with Daniel at this point; he says he loves Clara yet will not try to share something that’s very important to her—her faith. She continues to pray for him, but I won’t lie and say I wasn’t questing his ‘love’ for her at points. Especially when she’s afraid he’s going to hit her with a rolled-up newspaper; he instead throws it at her body (p. 168). Daniel drove me a bit mad at times in both of my readings of this novel.
One last note: To keep of being spoiler-y, I’ll be vague, but I’m still not quite sure why Clara did the action that made Daniel to be upset at her and that she did not pray for it to be received well. Clara seemed like her heart was in the right place at times, but I personally don’t necessarily agree with some Spiritual theology discussed.
The main difference between my first time reading this book and this re-read would be—to be completely honest—the first half of this book struck me as slightly depressing, but when Bane came more into the picture, the plot moved more away from the gloomy parts. While I probably shouldn’t have liked Bane so much, he really was quite cunning and brilliant, so I had hope for his character development.
Overall? It was not the best due to content, a certain male character, and some slight theology problems, but there were a handful of parts I enjoyed and I’m glad this review is now up on this site.


Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...


*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.

[Beth · Rating 4 out of 5]

Lovely story and quite unexpected at times! Full review to come!

I admit, I judged this book by its cover- I’m guilty! Though the cover of the book is quite pretty, it led me to believe that this was going to be the typical inspirational, historical romance – all of the conflict would stem from a big misunderstanding, it would be resolved a few hundred pages later, and they live happily ever after. So you can imagine my pleasant surprise when the main character, Clara, is an investigative journalist, right around the time when there were female journalists, but not many. This particular journalist is intent on bringing the truth to light and using her words to do so. Early in the story, she is in jail, no less! The opening of the story had me hooked from the beginning.

The plot was in no way ho-hum, but rather kept along at a nice pace. It wasn’t just the typical lady meets gentleman story – in fact, Daniel Tremain is not much of a gentleman at all, but rather a big of a roguish character. Being a self-made man, he knows firsthand the hardships of the working poor. The struggles between Clara and Daniel were out in the open and all the more potent because of that. The relationship between them was endearing and rang true for me. I love how they had true, realistic internal conflict within themselves and not just with each other and outside conflict. There were so many aspects to admire - Daniel’s rocky path to forgiveness, Clara’s steadfast loyalty and their conflict over her beliefs.

I also really enjoyed the relationship between Clara and her brother, Clyde – I think he deserves his own story and would love it if one was ever written about him. The other secondary characters, Daniel’s sisters, Kate and Lorna, and especially Alexander Banebridge, were all fleshed out very well and added a lot of depth to the story.

What kept me from giving that fifth star was the fact that at times I didn’t feel a very strong sense of place. I’m a reader who likes description of place and setting and at times, that just wasn’t there for me. Some of the dialogue didn’t seem like it was “back then,” but rather would have suited a more contemporary story. I also felt that some of the decisions Clara made, while they propelled the plot, did not always come across as realistic. The second thing was the spiritual aspect of the story - one reviewer mentioned that Clara suddenly turned into "Super Christian," and I find that I have to agree. It became very in your face at times, versus the other times where it weaves in and out of the story more organically.

Overall, it was a very enjoyable story with a compelling plot, an endearing romance and stand-out characters. I’m really looking forward to reading the rest of Bane’s story in Against the Tide!

[Jess · Rating 3 out of 5]

I have mixed feelings about this book after reading it. Overall I did enjoy the storyline, it was easy to ready, had twists and drama in the right places, and had characters that were vivid, even if they were a little unrealistic at times.

There are two things that bring let this book down for me. The first is that it wasn't until halfway through that I realised it was a Christian book. Now to be fair it wasn't as 'preachy' as it could have potentially been, although there were times towards the end when the same bible quote was repeated over and over again, and that got a little repetitive.

But the main reason the book lost points from me is that the main antagonist in this book changed from being a hardened opium dealer criminal, to a born-again christian in a matter of days and after only a few short conversations with the main heroine he completely changed his life. I have not been in the situation where I have been convinced to change my opinion on religion, but I really doubt it would happen so quickly. To make this story more realistic I would have hinted at Bane's wishes to change his lifestyle rather than him saying how much he enjoyed it and wanted to climb up the criminal ladder.

Overall the story wasn't too bad, but not one I would rave about and highly recommend. There are far better writers out there that I would rather read more from.

[Jennifer · Rating 2 out of 5]

I appreciate what Ms. Camden was trying to do with this book. Honestly, I do. And the engaging storytelling, rich historical details, and compelling MCs made me want to like this book. But I couldn't. The h was way too preachy. What could have been a sweet and natural reunion between the MCs became strange and awkward with the h's insistence on the H becoming a Christian. Please don't mistake what I'm saying. Sharing the good news of Jesus Christ is always a good thing. However, letting the way you live your life be your testimony is a much better way to share it. The problem with this story is that we don't see the h doing that. We just see her badgering him with the message of forgiveness and grace instead of being patient with him.

There were a few things that I liked about this book. The h wasn't a pushover or a doormat. She didn't compromise on her values or beliefs. She was also a hardworking professional who didn't rely on a man for happiness or for money. She also didn't turn into a puddle of hormonal goo whenever the H was around. All of those things were super refreshing. I also liked the H who didn't beat around the bush about his intentions toward the h. There wasn't any long drawn out angst in that regard. There was also not OP drama, which was quite nice as well.

All in all, I didn't hate this book, nor did I love it. The spiritual message was strong but maybe too much so for my liking. The historical aspect of this story was nice, but there was simply something missing in it for me.

[Kate · Rating 4 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this book. I had read "Against the Tide" which features Bane earlier this year, and was intrigued to know that he had appeared in another of Elizabeth Camden's novels. I'm glad I took the opportunity to read this book, and get to know Bane's backstory slightly more, although this book's focus was not on Bane.
I liked both Clara and Daniel and how they each needed to learn some lessons before their relationship could blossom. I liked how, even though Clara was portrayed as a really good Christian woman, she still had some faults that she needed to work through, and how she relied on the Lord to help her do so. I especially appreciated that she knew she would not be able to have a romantic relationship with Daniel unless he were to turn his life over to the Lord, even though she truly loved him. She drew her line in the sand and did not cross it.
I thought the portrayal of Daniel was very well done. I think the prologue was just the right set up so we could understand his desire for revenge against the man whom Daniel believed was the reason for the destruction of family. I liked how he was able to figure out what mattered most and to make changes in his life that reflected that new knowledge.
I loved the very clear Christian message of hope in Christ's salvation. The Gospel is so simple, and I love to see it preached in this way!

[Sarah Grace Grzy · Rating 4 out of 5]

Hmm, not quite my favorite, but SO good! Getting to read Bane's (from Against the Tide) backstory was epic!

[Cassie · Rating 4 out of 5]

This makes me want to reread Bane's story in Against The Tide.

[Kriste · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book should absolutely be listed as book 1 in a series w/ Against the Tide. So good!

[Lynne Stringer · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed The Lady of Bolton Hill very much. I felt it was a little slow to start, and it was certainly quite preachy, although I felt that fitted in with the story.
My biggest complaint was its presentation of the viewpoint that God will always keep you safe. While this may not have been directly what the author was trying to communicate, I think it could be implied by readers, and that is concerning, especially when you consider the many Christians who have died in the service of God over the years. Also, I felt Daniel's change of heart was too abrupt. I think it would have been better if signs of a gradual softening was evident earlier, rather than being led to believe that that much bitterness and ingrained behaviour could be swept away entirely in a week.
In spite of that, it was still a good read.

[Jennifer · Rating 5 out of 5]

What a powerful story! Absolutely fantastic!!! If I had the capability to recommend it to everyone in the world, I would!

My only regret with this book is that I wish I had read it before reading Against the Tide. I didn't realize the two were connected until Bane was mentioned, but it was still fabulous to read his back story. I guess now I'll just have to read Against the Tide again! 😉
I absolutely loved both Clara and Daniel!

Clara has the nerve to go against society and its expectations for what a young society lady *should* be. She is pretty levelheaded, but not afraid to take action when needed. She is not ashamed of her love of, and dependence upon, Jesus Christ as her Savior. She will do most anything to prove to others that she truly lives out her faith and she never passes up an opportunity to point someone towards Christ.

Daniel is strong enough to become a man, rise above his station in life, and work hard to provide for his family. He is a deeply devoted, caring man who puts those he loves far above his self. While I disagree with many of his actions, I admire that he is not afraid to be himself and stand firm in what he feels led to do, even if it means being at the center of gossip and slander.

I would recommend this book to anyone who loves a book with a little suspense, a little romance, and a whole lot of redemption!

[Melanie · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Lady of Bolton Hill is a book I've had on my kindle TBR for a long time, but never took the time to actually read until now. It was such a great story and I can't believe it's taken me this long to read!

I loved the characters. Daniel went through so much and I loved his growth throughout the story. Such a good story of forgiveness.

The ending was great and I loved how it wrapped things up nicely. It even answered something I didn't expect!

I recommend this story if you enjoy historical romances.

[Bess · Rating 2 out of 5]

This is the first book I've read by Elizabeth Camden. However, I have owned this book for neigh 7 years.
Clara is a wealthy woman who happens to also be a journalist. After being kicked out of England, she returns to the U.S. She has a knack for discovering seedy dealings and reporting on topics that affect the lowest class citizens in the hopes to propel change in working environments and living conditions.
Daniel is a self-made rich man having lived his life under extreme poverty. After losing his father in a boiler accident and his mother to suicide, his mission in life is to gain wealth, punish the man responsible for his parents' deaths, and get Clara to marry him.
However, Clara won't marry Daniel until he turns to G-d. Understandable. Daniel is being eating alive by revenge.
I liked the story okay. However, I have real serious issues with drug use. Especially, forcing the drugs onto others either knowingly or unknowingly. And this book contains that, albeit, not in graphic detail. That completely derailed the book for me.
The writing was well done. The story was interesting and kept my attention.
So, if you have triggers that stem from watching movies like "Taken," you might want to steer clear. There is suicide, drug use, kidnapping, selling kids into prostitution, discussions about chopping people into pieces, and other questionable acts.
If this doesn't bother you, then by all means, dig in!
I will try another book by this author in the hopes to find a gem! She comes highly recommended.

[Margaret Metz · Rating 5 out of 5]

First I have to admit to cover love. I am so shallow that I wanted the book before I knew a thing about it other than it had a gorgeous cover. Thankfully the inside didn't let me down.

One of the wonderful things about historical fiction is all the "issues" they can talk and teach you about. This book had so many things going on that it felt like an action movie. What kept it grounded was the relationship between the characters and the characters themselves.

I may be shallow but Clara isn't. She isn't even a caricature of the woman ahead of her time or the strong willed independent type. She resists labeling because she may have some features that resemble those types but she's also terrified of horses and insecure a lot of the time. Daniel is the same way. He's brilliant, fiercely protective, determined, rebellious against society's rules, and so angry at the person who hurt his family that he's willing to hurt the financial security of his company. Yet on some level he's always felt unworthy to love Clara. The complexities in their personalities as well as those of Alex and Clara's father really impressed me.

I'm a romance girl and I thought the relationship was fabulous. It had enough sparks to feel realistic for the time period and I loved the tension between them. I believed in them and wanted it to work out. At the same time, I could almost believe that it wouldn't.

This is a well written, action-packed story with a great romance. I look forward to reading more by this author and I thank Bethany House for providing my copy though it did not influence my review.

[Monique the Book Geek · Rating 4 out of 5]

The story of this book precedes Elizabeth Camden’s Against the Tide , which I ended up reading first not having known about The Lady of Bolton Hill... and although I have to say Against the Tide was my favorite of these two books (possibly one of my favorite books of all time), I enjoyed reading The Lady of Bolton Hill as well.

Like Against the Tide, this book is well written with balanced themes of mystery, suspense, romance, and redemption, and I found its characters to be fascinating and well developed. I love the way Camden gives her characters visible flaws in these books, making them much more relatable as human beings. None of us are without flaw and we are all loved equally by God--a message that comes through beautifully in this story and its characters. I admire how the author blended faith into this story.

Also like Against the Tide, this book is set in the late-1800s, which from what I could tell is historically accurate, and this book is clean with no cursing or sexual situations in it, which I really respect the author for.

Against the Tide and The Lady of Bolton Hill are the first books I have read by this author and I now plan on reading all of her books. I really love Elizabeth Camden's writing style!

I finished reading this book for the first time on May 21st, 2017.

[Joy · Rating 5 out of 5]

Daniel and Clara are childhood friends torn apart before their sparks of romance could ignite. When they cross paths twelve years later the heat between them creates an inferno on the page. The romance in The Lady of Bolton Hill got so steamy- for a minute there, I thought it might be headed in a whole different direction. Rest assured, we don't cross out of Christian fiction territory, but if you are a fan of edgy inspirational you'll enjoy the romance in this one.

There was much for me to love in this book and I finished it in one sitting. The whole labor and union plot line reminded me a little bit of the series North and South and once that image popped into my head, I couldn't help but picture Richard Armitage as Daniel. If I had to cast someone to play the role, he'd soooo be my pick.

If I had one criticism of the novel, it would be that Clara seems to don a Super Christian costume to convert the lost. The reader doesn't actually see spandex, but Clara must have worn it underneath her dress because she wields an unbelievable power of persuasion over the unchurched.

But in my experience a good romance covers a multitude of sticky plot points (or in this case a single sticky plot point). And the romance in The Lady of Bolton Hill was very good. If you're anything like me, you'll still be thinking about the tingling in your tummy long after you put the book down.

Elizabeth Camden, welcome to my must read list.

(Thanks to CFBA and the publisher for my review copy)

[Anna M · Rating 5 out of 5]

Elizabeth Camden has yet to fail me with her undeniable talent for writing a fascinating peek into history.

One of the main reasons I loved this one was for Bane's point of view. I previously read 'Against The Tide', in which Bane is a main character, and in 'The Lady of Bolton Hill', we get to see his main backstory. And it was thrilling. Not to leave the main plot out of this... Clara and Daniel were a fiery couple. They were off to a great start, but time changes them and they both find out that the only way they can be together is if they sort out their differences and build a strong faith first. They learn a lot of lessons as they both experience difficult situations brought on by Daniel's quest for revenge, and Bane's plan to undo him.

There was sort of a reveal at the end, which I loved! I love it when I'm kept in the dark about something, and then at the end it all comes together and makes sense. It's so fun to see the full picture after being in the dark for so long. The element of surprise just hits the spot.

Again, Elizabeth Camden is able to take any part of history and make it intriguing. She's a huge part of the reason I want to pursue history after high school - and writing of course :). It will take a disaster novel to make me cease from recommending her work. Please read this book. It's a true delight.

[Crystal Caudill · Rating 5 out of 5]

I haven't read all of Elizabeth Camden's books yet, but so far, I have to say this one is my favorite. While the hero is a difficult man to love, the profoundness of the spiritual arc, not just for him but for other key characters, just totally blew away. The prologue was a must-read if you are to make it through the rest of the book and understand how Clara and Daniel could like each other, so don't skip it. It's a story of how vengeance destroys and kills and how forgiveness heals--but it's so much more than that. One of the most impactful and complicated characters was Bane--a villain of all people.

The historical details of this story are immaculate, as always. I felt right there in the story while also learning so much. The romance was a true struggle of loving someone who wasn't who they once were and yet fighting for them because you know who they can be. The familial relationships are complicated, broken, and realistic. There are just so many layers to this story that I know I will find new things when I read it again.

Recommended for fans of: Historical romance, friends to more, redemption stories, antiheroes who grow into true heroes, and women in unusual professions (reporter during the 1880s).

[Erika B. (SOS BOOKS) · Rating 2 out of 5]

This would be like a 2.5-3 star rating from me! Three for being somewhat entertaining. I really really wanted to like this book! I tried so dang hard but it was one of those books that just didn't stick with me. I would put it down for weeks at a time and then try again. I think it was because the main character Clara drove me nuts! Seriously she was so annoying! She was VERY preachy and very self-righteous. She is dealing with the villain at one point in the story and he's threatening to kill her and all she can talk about is being born again into Christianity. I just don't find this plausible. If a man was threatening to kill me and dosing me up with opium my first reaction to the situation be something like...AHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!! HELP!!!!!! Then I'd use the S.I.N.G defense move on him! (Solarflex, Instep, Nose, Groin) and run away! I think talking about repentance would actually be one of the last things on my mind! But hey! That's just me! It certainly wasn't that way in this story! I haven't given up hope though! I still will attempt Camden's other books to see if they can redeem this one! :)

[Margaret Chind · Rating 5 out of 5]

Now this is a book that I completely loved beginning to end. Page one had me captivated. I'm always nervous about new authors, but Elizabeth Camden with this one novel has made it to the favorite's keeper shelf and I will desperately await more stories to come! What is so extraordinary about this novel is that it was a perfect setting, but for once (something I do not often find with historicals) I could easily translate this and see it in my head as an everyday occurrence in the current time. It's a sad story, and a real story, but it's a beautiful story and so romantic and perfect. It's a romance of two humans and it's a romance of new beginnings with our Lord Christ. Elizabeth Camden has put so much into this book that it is just plain fabulous. I'm delighted to have read it and truly highly recommend it!

*Thanks to Bethany House Publishers for providing a copy for review through
the Christian Fiction Blog Alliance.*

Originally posted: http://creativemadnessmama.com/blog/2...

[Janet Camilleri · Rating 1 out of 5]

I only got about halfway through this book, then decided I wasn't enjoying it enough to finish it. I just couldn't bring myself to care about the characters and what happened to them, and the "Christian" aspect just annoyed me. There has got to be more to Christian romances than just waiting for one of the starstruck couple to get saved!!!

[Sarah · Rating 4 out of 5]

Age Appropriate For: 15 and up for violence, drug use, and thematic elements
Best for Ages: 15 and up

Can Elizabeth Camden write a bad book? I doubt it. I only have one book of hers left that I haven’t read and if it is anything like all the others I have read, it will be amazingly good.

This book is probably the weakest of Camden’s books I have read, but is still is better than most fiction. Again, Camden made me fall for characters I normally hate and be enraptured by a story line that I typically wouldn’t like. How does she do it? By delving deeper into the characters than most authors.
For those of you who have read Against the Tide, this gives you a glimpse into the beginnings of Bane, and the woman who helped him find the right path. Although he is not the focal point of the story, Bane adds so much.

The setting was wonderful. Camden always manages to wave many historical details seamlessly into her stories. She always makes me feel as if I have been transported back and time. She obviously does her research so well, that she doesn’t have to force it into the story. It just comes out naturally.
Clara was such an endearing character. I love her compassion and willingness to do so much for that compassion. She was a brave, yet very much human in her fears. She works so hard to change the world, but sometimes the consequences are hard. Through everything she goes through, her strong faith, and compassion shines through. She is the type of woman I want to be.

Daniel was the kind of character I normally hate. He is poisoned with bitterness and his quest for revenge seems to be endless. Yet, his love for Clara and his sisters was so touching. His quest to make a better life then the tragic one he endured as a child couldn’t help but tug at my emotions. He was a very flawed hero, but a true hero none the less.

This story kept turning pages way past the time I should have been asleep. It was gripping and an emotional roller-coaster. The ending was stratifying and just… well, it was just so Camden. She has become my standard for amazing fiction.

If you like realistic fiction, amazingly told stories, and deep characters, I highly recommend The Lady of Bolton Hill.

[Dawn · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really don't know what it was that created such an urgent desire to read this particular book. The last time I was so crazy about getting my hands on a book, the book was Julie Lessman's A Passion Most Pure. Instead of blazing through the pages like I usually do, I actually had to set the book down at times just to digest everything. Which is a good thing. It's what I hope for every time I open a new book to read.

And it's what I found myself doing with The Lady of Bolton Hill by Elizabeth Camden.

From the very beginning I noticed Camden's penchant for supplying historical detail. I loved it. I learned so many things about everyday life lived in the year 1879, I found myself taking notes. The plot, at first seemed like it could become predictable... but it didn't. Camden surprised me so many times! I loved Clara Endicott and Daniel Tremain and how they were so devoted to one another after being separated for so many life-defining years. I would have liked to see a little more of the depth of their relationship and never-ending attraction to one another come out, but what there was along the way of telling the story was enough.

Camden's plot took off in a completely different direction than I ever would have thought up. I did love this book. I cannot wait until Elizabeth Camden's next book The Rose of Winslow Street comes out in January.

[Kathy * Bookworm Nation · Rating 4 out of 5]

I wish I would have written this review when I finished the book, instead I’ve waited awhile and it’s harder to put into words what I thought while reading it.

I actually enjoyed this book. I thought the “lost love” angle was interesting. I liked that they pick up practically right where they left off. Twelve years have passed and both have gone through a lot and are different people. I liked how they have to get to know each other all over again, and yet still have a strong connection from when they were younger. While I liked Clara, at times she was a little too preachy for my taste. I also liked Daniel. I could understand his side of things and agree with not doing business with someone who you know is dishonest or purposely ignores their employee’s welfare. There is a side story that is going on that added a little excitement to the overall story.

I guess I wasn’t expecting to read a conversion story or so much preaching. If I had gone into it knowing it was heavy on the Christian elements I may have felt differently about it. I did enjoy the story though and it kept me interested and wanting to read more.

[Caity · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really can't summarize my feelings for, opinions on, or favorite parts of this book without giving something away and revealing too many spoilers, so I'll just keep it short and blunt and hope you go read it for yourself!
The Lady of Bolton Hill has everything a historical romance novel should have...
History, romance, surprise, heartache, a hero with a past, a heroine with a dream, a villain too smart for his own good, thwarted plans, rescue, repentance, misunderstandings, forgiveness, loyalty, fear, courage, ships, abandoned buildings, happiness, London, music, insanity, family, coffee, (yes, coffee), something even blows up! and -to top it all off- an epilogue like no other! Seriously, you can just hear the end credit music crash to life in that tempo that yells "WAIT! There's more!!!"
And there is! So, if you'll excuse me, "Against the Tide" is waiting.

*This book does contain some more mature themes and I would not recommend to a younger audience.*

[Hannah · Rating 4 out of 5]

A friend here on Goodreads posted that this book was available for free, and for some reason I was in just the right mood to try it out. Usually I find Christian fiction too sappy and simplistic for my taste, but this one is good. I couldn't put it down for the final half! It has some suspense and good stakes to strive for in the characters' lives.
There were a few anachronisms, but not very many, and not enough to subtract very badly from the storyline. Most likely people without my history buff ways would not even notice at all.
The relationship between Clara and Daniel is satisfying, and I loved the recap of the epilogue. I look forward to having a chance to read the book about Bane, also!

[Rachel Brand · Rating 4 out of 5]

I've read three of Elizabeth Camden's novels and, so far, I think this is probably my least favourite. Given that it's her debut novel, it makes sense that it isn't quite as strong or well-written as her later books. Her writing voice is quite different and more mature in her later novels.

I honestly think that the opening chapters of this book--involving Clara and Daniel as teenagers, and then Clara imprisoned in London--were the strongest in the whole story. They sucked me in and intrigued me immediately, but the ensuing conflicts weren't quite as intriguing as the opening ones. The suspense and mystery in this book definitely kept me turning the pages, and I won't deny that the story is compelling, but the opening chapters were definitely the strongest out of the entire book.

I definitely enjoyed the details about Clara's work as a journalist and the issues with the labour unions, which I haven't come across much before in other novels from this time period. Female journalists certainly weren't all that common at this time, especially ones who delved into gritty issues like the ones Clara wrote about. Labour unions and child labour might not be the most romantic historical details to discuss in a novel, but they were interesting to read about.

While the villain of the story is disconnected from the other characters for the majority of the plot (which is initially a little confusing), he becomes more prominent towards the end of the story. I actually read the sequel to this book, Against the Tide, first, and I remember wondering how much of Bane's backstory is dealt with in the first book, since I found the details in the sequel to be rather vague. They're still pretty vague here, to be honest, and I think I probably prefer Against the Tide to this book. The second book goes into a lot more details about the opium trade, which I found fascinating.

I think what didn't work for me was the spiritual side of the book. Clara just seemed too pushy towards Daniel (and eventually Bane) to become Christians. I totally understand her concerns about marrying someone who doesn't share your faith (my husband wasn't a Christian when we started dating) but she seemed to approach the issue from a very simplistic manner, almost as if Daniel just needed to be told about Jesus in order to change his mind. It seemed to me that it wasn't that Daniel didn't understand how salvation worked--he just didn't think he needed anyone to save him because he thought he was in control of his life. I guess maybe it's just a personal thing, having been in a similar position to Clara--I would never have been as pushy as her, and probably would have tried to bring about more organic, realistic conversations about faith, rather than just constantly telling Daniel why he needed to become a Christian.

In spite of these complaints, Daniel's eventual conversion to Christianity felt a lot more realistic than Bane's change of heart. Daniel needed time to come to his own decisions about God and the role he would play in his life, and the gradual changes Daniel made over the course of the book felt believable considering his past attitudes. Bane, on the other hand, shows no signs of wanting to escape his criminal lifestyle until Clara challenges him, and his turnaround felt far too quick for me to believe it genuine. Perhaps if there had been some hints that he wanted to escape his life of crime but couldn't, I would have found this part of the story more realistic.

On another note, I would love to read a book about Clara's brother, Clyde, who works as a doctor for various Native American tribes in remote locations. His disconnect from his family's lavish lifestyle and society's treatment of him definitely intrigued me. I think he's more my kind of hero than either Daniel or Bane! I hope Elizabeth Camden decides to give Clyde his own story some day.

Overall, I have mixed feelings about this book and I think I'd give it 3.5*. The storyline was certainly interesting and compelling, especially the suspenseful parts, but the spiritual side didn't feel very realistic and was more in-your-face than I usually like in my Christian Fiction. I'm not sure if I would have been so eager to read more of Elizabeth Camden's work if I'd started with this book. Against the Tide contains much stronger writing, and The Rose of Winslow Street is by far my favourite of her books so far.

[Abby Breuklander · Rating 5 out of 5]

Love love and love this story!! What a much-needed reminder that God is always at work in our lives, even when we can't see it and nothing about our circumstances has changed. If it is His will for something to happen then it's going to happen but in His timing.

[Ruth · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.5 Stars. United by a passion for music, Clara Endicott and Daniel Tremain were the best of friends despite their wildly disparate backgrounds. Clara, the daughter of an influential minister, is a glittering but refreshingly unpretentious child of Baltimore's elite, while Daniel is a native of the tenements, destined for a future in the steel mills but with a drive to escape his upbringing and prove worthy Clara's affection. After a tragic accident derails his youthful dreams, Clara is shipped to England with the hope of discovering her passion and purpose in life, leaving Daniel to transform his family's tragedy into a springboard for advancement, marrying his thirst for vengeance with the drive to exceed his antecedents and prove worthy Clara's world. While in England Clara discovers her passion -- illuminating the darkest struggles of the working classes with the power of her pen -- and when her expose see her unceremoniously sent back to America, she and Daniel are reunited. After more than a decade apart, Daniel and Clara couldn't be more different -- but the connection and passion that simmered between them as teens remains unchanged, flaring to life once again after their first encounter. But as much as Clara would love to rekindle her relationship with her oldest friend, Daniel's stubborn, unrelenting obsession with revenge no matter the cost threatens to derail her most cherished hope. While Clara's passion for justice collides with Daniel's pride, an unseen enemy emerges, ready to strike. Can Daniel relinquish his hunger for revenge before he loses his truest friend, or will the hope of a future with Clara be ripped from his grasp forever?

Perhaps the best way to describe Camden's debut effort is intense. From the heady days of Clara and Daniel's early friendship to Clara's unceremonious deportation from England, Camden hits the ground running from the novel's opening pages. I loved the fact that Clara and Daniel's romance grew out of a childhood friendship. The intensity of their relationship, the way in which they "click" lends their budding romance an intensity and spark rarely seen in fiction of this ilk. Daniel is very much a hero cut from the same cloth as Darcy and Thornton of classic literature fame. Speaking of Thornton, this novel bears a striking resemblance in subject matter and romance to Elizabeth Gaskell's North and South. Much like the mill owner John Thornton, Daniel rises to society's highest levels with a hard-edged grace, consumed with validating his newly-acquired position. And like Thornton, Daniel meets his match in the form of a social-justice minded, independent and unconventional woman who refuses to surrender to a love built on a foundation of vengeance and anger.

Bolton Hill's greatest strength lies in its insistence on pushing the boundaries of historical romance -- this is a novel infused with heated romance, weighty social issues, and high adventure. And therein also lies the novel's biggest weakness. Clocking in at a relatively slim 320-odd pages, there's almost too much going on to do any of the multiple, and equally potentially strong, storylines the justice they deserve. Roughly half the novel focuses on everything from the challenges facing female journalists in the Gilded Age and workers' rights, labor riots, and industrial rivalry while the second half features an expansive opium smuggling operation headed by a sinister Professor Moriarty-type figure whose brilliant, teen-aged lieutenant (think a 19th-century James Bond type) has Daniel's downfall in his sights. Camden has a appealing voice and intelligent, articulate prose that kept me rapidly turning pages. And while I appreciate the novel's reach it simply isn't long enough to do full justice to its characters or the multiple storylines.

Don't let Bolton Hill's gorgeously-rendered cover fool you -- yes, there's a romance (and oh, some of the moments Daniel & Clara share!), but there's adventure, danger, and an organic spiritual thread wrapped up in the pages of Camden's debut. In particular I liked the character of Daniel -- his strength, intensity, loyalty to his family, and whole-hearted adoration of Clara, though his spiritual arc felt a bit truncated (again, due to length limitations). With the promise of a tighter storyline, Camden's crisp prose and fearlessly fast pace mark her as an author to watch. And that teen-aged, villainous protege I mentioned earlier? He makes a most welcome return later this year in Camden's third novel, Against the Tide.

[Yiya · Rating 5 out of 5]

A wonderful read that teach us about love and forgiveness, The Lady of Bolton Hill, is an invitation to enjoy some time with Clara and Daniel. Coming from opposite backgrounds, they enjoy a common passion, music and Chopin. The tie that is made between them at a young age cannot be undone despite time, classes, money, pride or distance. Gripping since the first page, this is an outstanding writing that is constantly changing pace, and does not let the reader put it down.
Clara's father is a renowned minister; his family name is well respected, and all members are expected to live up to it. Clara is not the exception, but Daniel, who is poor and works in a mill with his father, becomes the greatest threat for Clara to honor the Endicott name. Therefore, Clara is sent to England, where she pursues her passion for writing and finds a niche of inspiration in the lives of miners, still children, having to live with injuries and illnesses for the rest of their lives. Of course, Clara's writing is not popular among the elite and has to face the consequences, even when she comes back to Boston. This is the principle that will rule her career - listening to the parties involved, and portraying the facts with the most accuracy possible. She does not realize that in her doing so, she might hurt those whom she loves most.
Daniel has had a rougher life, and he has had to make his way through every day. The owner of a brilliant mind, he is able to use what he has learned of the trade with his father, and create an enterprise that becomes the main source for railing materials. He has a noble and true heart, but is perceived as a cold man. Only Clara knows his true self.
This novel will try their characters, and both of them will have to learn to leave the past behind, and hold the best of each other. In the way, they will learn and remember that true happiness is not in how well we are able to control situations, but in how close we are to God, and in how capable we are able to share this with others, despite the circumstances. We are also reminded that God's love is available for anyone who seeks it, no matter what we have done or how dark our life has been.
A remarkable fact of the novel is the conclusion. It is not rushed, nor does it leave details out, a fact that is rarely seen nowadays. It leaves a great "after taste."
I highly recommend this book. Do not hesitate to spend a wonderful time with The Lady of Bolton Hill!
I received a free copy of this book from Bethany Publishers, in exchange for an honest review. This did not bias my review; the opinion expressed is my own.