Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door

Rate this book
World War II may be over, but Sergeant Davis Wilson feels no peace. Burdened by the loss of his best friend, Patrick, Davis has returned to his small town determined to make sure his friend’s mother and little sister are cared for. But the fiery young woman who greets him isn’t the “little sister” he remembers.

Faith Penwilliger lost both her brother and father during the war and had to grow up fast. The last four years molded her into a strong woman who runs the family business, cares for her widowed mother, and loves going out dancing with her boyfriend, Freddy. And she doesn’t need anyone else in her life, especially not Davis―the boy she idolized until the night he enlisted and the subsequent humiliating argument she had with him that she would rather forget.

Davis is puzzled and frustrated by the new version of Faith. Even more disconcerting are the unexpected feelings he’s developing for the girl next door. As Faith plots revenge and shows Davis what it feels like to be meddled with, it doesn’t take long for the line between love and dislike to blur. Now only the truth of the past can unlock the possibility of building a future together.

239 pages, Kindle Edition

Published April 4, 2023

14 people are currently reading
184 people want to read

About the author

Laura Rupper

10 books34 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
89 (31%)
4 stars
137 (47%)
3 stars
51 (17%)
2 stars
6 (2%)
1 star
3 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 92 reviews
Profile Image for theliterateleprechaun .
2,468 reviews216 followers
February 8, 2023
“Hindsight is the best insight to foresight.”

This was a beautifully written and emotional novel highlighting how difficult it was for soldiers to return to civilian life despite being welcomed home as heroes. Rupper points out all the adjustments necessary both for those returning and for those left at home. Her attention to era-specific detail was amazing and I appreciated how she doled out her important facts slowly so that I felt compelled to carry on. Rupper had me hooked with the discussion between the two soldiers on the train and the three pieces of advice. I had to find out if Davis was able to take the old man’s hindsight and use it as insight for his own foresight.

It was good to be reminded that wartime attitudes were all about rising to the challenges and that despite the war taking so much from everyone, each saw the importance of digging deep to find out what the war couldn’t take from them. I see so much of this attitude missing in modern life. My heart ached at realizing how lost Davis was when he returned and the things he did to find his way again and was softened by the subtle faith messages.

“Just get on with your life.”

Easier said than done. I appreciated this easy, clean read with alternating POVs that focused on what it takes to make the next step after one’s given everything for one’s country.

I was gifted this copy by Covenant Communications and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
Profile Image for TJ.
3,292 reviews282 followers
April 24, 2023
3.5/5.0

A lovely WWII era story/romance. It does a wonderful job of immersing the reader in that era, I just had a terribly hard time liking the heroine. She comes across so self-centered and treats the hero so nasty that it made it hard for me to enjoy the book like I truly wanted to. That might be just a personal thing, though, so I hate to punish the rating because of it.
Profile Image for Jennifer.
1,442 reviews98 followers
February 17, 2023
The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door
by Laura Rupper was a WW11 novel about after the war. It effected every one and they were living with the fallout. I loved the story and the main characters. It was a clean romance and I didn’t want to stop reading. I got my HEA. This isn’t a heavy reading about the war, it was light, heartfelt and enjoyable! And as a side note, I loved the Irish proverbs!
I definitely recommend it.
Thanks Covenant Communications via NetGalley.
Profile Image for Melissa’s Bookshelf.
2,545 reviews177 followers
April 13, 2023
4 1/2 stars

I thoroughly enjoyed The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door. This is the first book I’ve read by Laura Rupper and certainly won’t be my last. Usually romances I’ve read around WWII happen before and/or during the war. This unique, heartfelt story happens after the soldier comes home. It was a realistic look at the struggles inherent in coming home: dealing with the loss of friends, PTSD, trying to find your place, and other changes on the home front. The romance was a bit of enemies/friends to lovers, grumpy/sunshine, second chance, and best friend’s little sister. Along with the sweet romance was a well rounded story of one small town post war with endearing characters, that really pulled me in.

Davis aka Davey has mixed emotions as he returns home. He keenly feels the loss of his best friend and the weight of his family’s expectations. He used to be the fun, funny, spontaneous Davey, but comes home more world weary and serious. His best friend’s little sister Faith is all grown up. She’s running her family’s business and gone through her own pain with losing her brother and also her father. She blames Davis for her brother’s loss and wants nothing to do with the man she used to have a crush on. But, the more she’s around him, the more the old spark seems to be there. As they work together, she devises fun ways to help him find “Davey” again.

Loved Davis and Faith! There’s so much packed into this one story. It really gives a fantastic snapshot of this postwar time period. The characters are well written and I loved the variety of people and experiences. When Faith lost her brother, one of things that helps her with the grief is dance. It was fun reading about her competitions with Freddy and the way it makes Davis jealous. The harmless pranks Faith plays on Davis turn out to be really helpful to him personally. I love the way they are able to work out their issues and help each other with their grief.

Highly recommend this lovely historical romance! In addition to reading, I listened to the audiobook & enjoyed the narrator and the emotion she put into the story. She really captured the characters well and it was easy to listen to. Thanks to the publisher for the advanced complimentary copy. All opinions are completely my own and voluntarily left.
Profile Image for Morgan Giesbrecht.
Author 2 books191 followers
February 12, 2023
3.5⭐️

WW2 is over & America’s boys are coming home.

I really loved the plot concept of this story. There are plenty of books on WW2 but fewer dealing with returning soldiers trying to reintegrate into civilian life. This story handled it well.

As for the characters, I loved most of them. Davis, our returning sergeant, is both sweet & serious, along with struggling with PTSD. His relationship with Faith’s mum is my favourite. Faith, the girl next door, is a contradiction—being both immature & yet super responsible at times. I’m torn about how I feel about her, as I think she was too hard on Davis & insensitive about certain things. That aside, there were a whole passel of wonderful side characters that rounded out the cast beautifully—Frank, Juan, Faith’s mum, and Robert being my favourites!

When it comes to what I wasn’t crazy about, it’s merely personal preference. There are love triangles & miscommunications / jumping to conclusions & a bunch of petty back-and-forth “payback.” There were a few parts of the story where I wished there was a bit more detail, particularly with the fundraising event because I really loved Davis & Robert’s dynamic.

The romance itself was very sweet once everything got sorted out & characters actually talked instead of holding grudges. And that epilogue was beautiful!



Content: solider deals with PTSD; non-graphic mentions of the horrors of war; kissing; grief over the loss of family meme era; young woman getting a divorce from her alcoholic husband; a side character gets drunk


*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.
Profile Image for Janalyn, the blind reviewer.
4,638 reviews140 followers
April 4, 2023
Win phase neighbor Mrs. Wilson comes over telegram in hand exuding happiness saying her son David Wilson is coming home from the war she doesn’t give a second thought to the fact that she is bragging to her neighbors whose son Patrick isn’t coming home. True to phase mom Martha’s kind nature she is happy for their neighbor and even helps her get ready for the welcome home celebration. Faye hasn’t seen David Wilson since I got in an argument about him encouraging Patrick to join the war effort and although she was just a little girl then she has grown into a beautiful 19-year-old woman with lots of responsibilities. Ever since the death of her dad and dearly beloved brother Patrick she has taken on the responsibility of running the hardware store but that’s not to say she doesn’t have fun the last two years she has been entering dance contest with her partner Freddy and then everyone in town thinks it’s her boyfriend but she will be the first to tell you he isn’t. After Davie who now wants to be called Davis returns home her mom tells Faye he will start working at the hardware store something Faye isn’t happy about but since business is picking up it is sorely needed. Davis starts seeing Faith as the woman she is and his affection for her only grows but Faye seems to be in denial. This was such a good book and so funny at the end of the book when Davy was dancing with Eleanor trying to keep up with Freddy and Faye I couldn’t stop laughing that just sounded so funny I also thought the side story with Rose and did nicely and although not a happy ending but a good one. This whole book was great I read it all in one night I love this authors books and will definitely read more in the future as I have in the past. I loved face relationship with her mother Martha but then again I love the whole book it is definitely a five story and one I highly recommend. I received this book from NetGalley and publisher but I am leaving this review voluntarily please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.
Profile Image for Mara.
1,472 reviews113 followers
May 13, 2023
This book takes place right after WWII. Soldiers coming home had to adjust and so did the families they came home to. Faith's brother died in the war and her father died shortly after her brother's death so now she's running the family business while her mom takes care of their home. Faith harbors some resentment/ill feelings towards Davis, the next door neighbor, as she blames him for her brother enlisting, and that Davis came home but her brother didn't.

Davis/Davey's family (mostly his mother and younger sisters) treat him as if he's the same young man who left home several years ago, but he isn't. He's having trouble sleeping and doesn't quite know what to do with his life now that the war is over.

I liked that this book tackles subjects such as women in the workplace in the 40's and PTSD in the soldiers returning and their struggles to return to a "normal" life. I really liked Davis' friendship with Faith's mother. She listened to him, didn't pressure him or have any expectations as to what he should be doing now that he was back home. I didn't care for Faith for a good portion of the book--I admired that she took on the responsibility of running the family business but then she'd act immature or act as if she were in charge of Davis' life telling him what he should and shouldn't be doing. I admit those things were good for him but I didn't like how she went about doing it. I enjoyed the sweet romance between Faith and Davis once they got all the misunderstandings out of the way.

This is my first book by Laura Rupper and I'll definitely read another book by her. I received a complimentary copy from the publisher via NetGalley. All thoughts expressed in this review are my own.
Profile Image for Sandra.
Author 3 books29 followers
April 20, 2023
The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door shares the story of a WWII vet that struggles with coming back home from war, and his best friend's sister who had to step up to support her family after the death of her brother and father. This story reminds me of the stories that my grandparents used to tell of going out dancing for entertainment, listening to big band music, and neighbors often stopping by and chatting. There were a lot of realistic elements that made the story seem appropriate for that time. The characters felt real and well-rounded...they made mistakes, learned, and tried to figure out their lives. The story is entertaining to read, and I felt like it was a good, clean romance that readers would enjoy reading again and again. It's different from the other WWII books that I've read. Most of the books from WWII seem to focus on overseas and not what happened after the war in America. I don't think I've ever encountered a book during that time period that seemed like it matched some of the stories that my grandparents used to share and I think that may ring true for other readers as well. The story was well written and it's something teens from Adults would enjoy reading.
Please note that I received a free ebook to review, however, I shared my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Kylaslittlelibrary.
587 reviews30 followers
May 9, 2023
The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door

I wasn’t sure what to expect going into this one. I went in completely blind and ended up LOVING it.

Faith and Davis have a lot history together. They grew up next door to each other in a small town where everyone knows everything.

Davis is back home after the end of the war (WW2). As he is learning to adjust he finds it easier to be at his best friends house than his own. It can’t help but notice that pesky little sister isn’t so little anymore.

I love how the relationship builds in this story and their interference in each others lives. The pacing was great and the ending so sweet.

Read if you like:
Brothers best friend
Redemption
Christian fiction
Small town
Forced proximity
Childhood crush
Solider learning to adjust

Content: kisses, loss of loved ones
Profile Image for Kaye.
4,361 reviews72 followers
May 13, 2023
I really enjoyed this sweet historical romance. I’ve ready so many WWII books but not many that focus on a soldier coming home. This is a gentle romance so the PTSD symptoms are mild, having a hard time sleeping and the need to stay busy all the time. Sergeant Davis Wilson is returning after four years in the European theater. His small Ohio town and loving family welcome him with open arms but the feeling isn’t shared by the girl next door. The war has been hard on Faith Penwilliger. Her brother died overseas and her father passed away shortly afterwards. At 18 she had to make the choice to postpone her college plans and take over her family brick business. She blames Davis for her losses. Her brother as an only son wasn’t drafted but Faith feels Davis, as his best friend, encouraged him to enlist.

This is a genuinely lovely story. It isn’t in a rush and takes it time. You can see the characters go from provoking to understanding and forgiveness. I like that Faith's mom has an Irish proverb for everything. (It was a lucky coincidence that I read this on St. Patrick’s Day.) There is trickling amount of history thrown in like hiring a Mexican worker through a national program and some political news of the time. A cousin who marries unwisely is also brought into the story mix as well as a dancing partner that brought escapism to Faith. This also brings in religion (non identified denomination) in a soft way.

I did have some minimal unanswered questions. A lot was made about Faith running the business. But other than office work and inventory nothing else is mentioned. Did she actively bid jobs? Work with contractors? etc. Also couldn’t her mother also have helped in the store? I got all kinds of details about dancing but not about the business itself. And did she continue on working after marriage?

I’m new to the author but will look forward to future books. This is for readers who prefer clean romances. Thank you to NetGalley and Covenant Communications for the ARC and I am leaving a voluntary review. (4.5 Stars)
Profile Image for Sheila (sheilasbookreviewer).
1,471 reviews57 followers
June 4, 2023
The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door tells the story of two families after World War two has ended. Readers get insight into what life was like for the soldiers returning and the families whose sons didn't return from the war.

I really liked the main character Davis Wilson, a returning soldier whose life would never be the same. His best friend and neighbor, Patrick, was killed during the war. Now he feels the need to help out Patrick's mom and sister, Faith. The main problem is that Faith blames Davis for Patrick's death and enlisting in the first place. They have a past history that muddies the water. This causes so many problems in the story. As Davis is dealing with PTSD, Faith's anger, and pressure to "return to normal" he struggles through much of the story. Faith has had to postpone college to run the family business after her father's death. Her immaturity shows as she does things to get back at Davis but on the other hand, she is a smart young lady able to run a business in the mid-1940s. She grows and changes a lot in this novel.

There is a love triangle between Davis, Faith, and Freddy in this small hometown novel. Davis and Faith try to reconcile their differences and at times I became frustrated with some of the games they played with each other. Funny enough, some of the games turned into good things that eventually bring the twosome together.

I did like the awareness brought to readers about forgiveness, letting go, and new starts. This slow-burn novel is an easy read, with likable characters that history lovers will enjoy as they remember the sacrifices that soldiers made for our country.
Profile Image for Crystal (Books Are Sanity!!!).
795 reviews38 followers
July 7, 2023
I love historical fiction novels and this one set right at the end of WWII did not disappoint. Rupper easily engages the reader into Davis’ life. From his train ride home from the war to his homecoming with his family and friends, I could really feel his trepidation and his unsurety of his place now that the war was over. Faith, Davis’ neighbor, was a complete firecracker. No one was going to push her around or tell her what to do. As a reader, I wondered if she would ever forgive and move past her hurt and anger. Rupper does an amazing job bringing the emotions and heartrending experiences of life post war straight into the reader’s heart. The weave of faith into the story was just the right touch as you watch the characters learn to lean on the Lord and their faith. A fantastic historical Christian fiction novel, The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door is a must read for fans of the genre! I received a copy of this book for free; all thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Holly Bleggi.
1,364 reviews26 followers
July 24, 2023
I enjoyed this book. I liked how the author told a sweet romance set after WWII. I liked how she tried to show how people and their lives had changed from before the war to after. I liked seeing Davis and Faith learn to live life again after all the things that had happened. I thought this was a well written story and the characters were very lovable. I thought the story was also believable and I loved seeing the healing that took place through out the story. I will definitely read more by this author.

I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors.  A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.
Profile Image for Happy Reading Watching.
1,106 reviews42 followers
Read
March 14, 2024
PROS:
◇The book cover
◇The plot
◇Sweet Romance

CONS:
◇The Love Triangle

Overall, I'm glad I picked it up ♡
Profile Image for Jessica Anderson.
103 reviews4 followers
July 11, 2025
I absolutely loved this book! I need a sequel. Maybe Rose or one of the Wilson sisters stories?
It was written absolutely perfect. It truly felt like I'd stepped into the 40's. I think I enjoyed it so much because I felt like I could truly understand where Faith was coming from with her partnership. Her reasoning why....I've been there for the exact same reason.
It was well written, had great characters and just adorable. I've already recommended it to multiple people.
Honestly, this has been one of my favorite 2025 reads.
Profile Image for Madison Warner.
11 reviews2 followers
April 1, 2025
This book was super light hearted and cute but it struggled to keep me wanting to know what would happen next.
1,164 reviews
May 4, 2023
I really enjoyed this unique book. It takes place right after ww2 and focuses on the life of a soldier post war. It focuses on his struggle to come back to regular civilian life. It shows the struggles of those women that were left after their husband/brother died. It showed how women had to step up and run businesses during the war. It shows the consequences of those who seized the day during the war (so made rash decisions) and married complete strangers. It was a unique time. I loved the time period of the 1940s. The fashions, the dancing, and cars! Both characters (duel perspective) were fun to read about. They both had great character arcs. They had to forgive, grow, and heal. And learn to be happy even after so many trials! Even with all this going on, it was still a light hearted book with plenty of funny moments and funny side characters. The author did a great job writing a variety of quirky characters. There wasn’t really a true villain in this story which was interesting. It was a story about figuring out life. This book had a lot of my favorite tropes too: Brothers best friend, next door neighbors (I loved both their families dynamics and relationships), enemies to lovers. The narrator did a great job too.

SPOILERS book notes and fav quotes:
The year was Just after ww2. April 1946. I love the name Davis and his nickname Davey. I feel like it’s perfect for this time period. Davis had a Ford Buick that he named Betsy. Such a classic!!! It’s interesting to hear Daveys perspective coming home from the war. To see how lavishly his family and he lived. The war gave him great perspective and made him grateful for even the simplest things like soft apostoerly on the seat of his car and apple pie. Or a smile from his sister. Kind of like when LDS missionaries come home after they complete their missions. After their neighbor came into faiths house (she and her mom lost her brother and dad to the war) and was super excited about her son returning her mom said this wisdom: “She doesn’t mean to be hurtful. I find that goes a long way, and as my granny used to say, ‘A great person grows fat on others’ happiness.’” That is so great! It is what is in peoples hearts that matters! Their intentions! And it is a great skill to be able to be happy for others fortunes! “Hyper-groomed” is the way davey described Freddy haha. It’s so hard watching davey go through ptsd and adjusting to post war life. I feel so bad! I love “operation sledding in the moonlight”. Haha it’s faiths way to get Davis to lighten up. They keep interfering in each others lives and it’s hilarious. I laughed out loud when she gave his mom a letter at the party pretending it’s from him saying he would quit smoking. Talking about this newspaper article and daveys response: “ the Dodgers’ manager, pointed to the Giants’ dugout and said something about the Giants’ team being too nice and that because of that, they wouldn’t win.” If he meant good guys always stay the safest or get the prettiest girl or end up making the most money, then they probably don’t win. If he meant they’re the happiest long term, then I still think things work out for them.” Faith was difficult to me most of the book. Just bc I like quick forgiveness. But she had been through so much so I understand that she needed time. And when she finally did forgive and admit her feelings the moment was so beautiful. I love a good 1940s make out sesh in an office chair. All super clean of course haha. And then the dedication of the monument: “I knew many of them. They were typical boys. They had their strengths and they had their weaknesses. They had triumphs and they made mistakes. What made them heroes? When the time to fight evil came, they rose to the occasion—they answered the call. “And so, we honor them, not because they were perfect but because they gave the greatest gift any man can give for another—their lives.”
Profile Image for Ru4repeat.
536 reviews
September 14, 2025
I need to listen to this book again so I can take note of the many wonderful little phrases and Irish blessing sprinkled throughout.
The narration for the audio book was absolutely fantastic!

***Update. I relistened. It was worthy of a repeat read!
Great quotes from the book:
“As pretty as a picture and as shallow as the canvas it’s painted on.”
“He who keeps his tongue keeps his friend.”
“May Neighbors respect you, trouble neglect you, the angels protect you and heaven accept you.”
“Here’s to Hades, may the stay there be as fun as the way there!”
--“Abbot and Costello. Faith named our trucks….their names suit.”
--“She was always giving cats ridiculous names when we were kids.” “Gumyum, Popkins, and Angel Fluff were fine names.”
“No news gives your imagination stoke to run wild, like children just let out of school.”
“When the drop is inside, the sense is outside.” – Great reference to someone drinking alcohol.
“A kind word, never broke anyone’s mouth.”
“A little pebble in your shoe can cause constant irritation.”
“To smile is to dress your face in its finest gown.”
--“Look for your own examples of God’s justice and mercy in the world.”
“…Helping your brother’s boat across the river and finding that your own boat had crossed.”
“Never bolt your door with a boiled carrot.”
“Here’s health to your enemy’s enemies.”
“May the enemies of Ireland never find a friend.”
“Marry in haste, repent at leisure.”
--“From my view it looks like pride on your part. Swallow it. There’s no room for pride in smart decisions.”
“As light to the eye, as joy to the heart, as bread to the hungry, may my presence be with thee.”
“May the road rise up to meet you.”
--“Working with Lester is like sucking a sour pickle. You get use to it, but it doesn’t mean you don’t wish it weren’t sweeter.”
“Nodding the head doesn’t row the boat.”
--“Are you going to paint in that dress?” “Of course not. But I had to dress up to go buy the paint. My mother would be mortified if I went to town in jeans.”
--“That’s what we always said during the war when we were miserable; that we were fighting for our tomorrows.” “Here’s to tomorrow...” “May it be bright.”
“Men are like bag pipes; no sound comes from them until they are full.”
“May the rain drops fall lightly on your brow. May the soft wind freshen your spirit. May the sunshine brighten your heart. May the burdens of the day rest lightly upon you, and may God enfold you in the mantle of his love.”
“Pains and patience will bring a snail to America.”
“It’s a long road that has no turning.”
“The longest road out, is the shortest road home.”
“When a well is dry, we know the worth of water.”
“When the apple is ripe, it will fall.”
“You must crack the nut before you eat the kernel.”
“God’s help is nearer than the door.”
“A mother’s eye is a good mirror.”
“You’ll never plow a field by turning it over in your mind.”
“A relationship isn’t about gazing into each other’s eyes with adoration, it’s about looking to the same goals.”
“If it’s drowning you’re after, don’t do it in shallow waters.”
--“Tomorrow is worth fighting for.”
“Hindsight is the best insight to foresight.”
“Forgetting your debt, doesn’t mean it was paid.”
--“The debt we owe our boys is certainly one we can’t forget.”
Profile Image for Se....
225 reviews6 followers
February 27, 2023
This book was really appeasing.
I am not a fan a World War II settings, I like my clichés with a bit of drama and a lot of swoon. World War II stories can get quite intense: they are great stories, but not my getaway, usually.
I loved this story as it succeeded in being true to its post-World War II melancholic context, and keeping a feather touch on the characters emotions and development. Nicely graceful.

The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door... the title is self-explanatory, maybe the story could have earned something more original? Also considering that Davis does not pull the Sergeant card that often, after all.
Anyways, the Sergeant and the Girl Next Door is the story of Davis Wilson and Faith Penwilliger. Davis left to fight the war with Faith's brother Patrick, and only Davis returns home. Also Faith's dad died during the war years, so it's just her and her mum. Faith had to step up to take care of the family's bricklaying business, postponing her dreams of college.
Davis comes back home, not sure what he will do next, but wanting to keep an eye on Faith and her mother, as a tribute to his best friend Patrick. But Faith, having endured the war years with more responsibility than her age and gender would have usually attributed her, does not appreciate Davis's meddling, and drafts a plan of her own to payback his undesired interferences.

I definitely liked the writing style, it was smooth and engaging.
I loved the characters: I liked how Faith was so responsible, yet still making room for her carefree moments, without getting too wild.
I valued Davis's character evolution: coming back without a plan for the future and figuring it out gradually.
I also loved the side characters: Faith's and Davis's mums and cousin Rose, most of all.
I am always happy when a book has great female characters, who might have some disagreements, but make a common front to whatever happens.

I would have liked to know more about Faith's business woman side. We mostly see her at her desk, doing some accounting, and interacting with her employees. We learn at the end of the day that she dealt with some customers or did inventories, but I couldn't quite picture her at work. Was she happy when closing a deal? Did she feel a sense of accomplishment at the end of the day? I perceived this sense of tiredness all along, which made sense with her conflict about giving up college, so I did not quite understand if, by the end, she was really into it or more out of a sense of legacy to her family.
I had this nagging feeling of "but is she really happy or will she regret her choices?". But maybe that's just how life is: you make your choices and you never really know if they will always fit, but if you have the right person at your side, you will figure it all out together.

I am curious to read Laura Rupper's next books and find out the lovely characters she will be able to weave next.
Profile Image for Vicky.
459 reviews24 followers
February 13, 2023
It’s nice to see a historical romance that’s set in the 20th century.

Faith has been forced to grow up fast, as her father died shortly after learning of the death of her brother in WWII, leaving Faith and her mother with a business to run. Faith had to sacrifice her dream of college in order to support her mother. She has also had to deal with people who believe she isn’t capable of running a business—she’s a woman, and a young one at that. The one indulgence she has is her dance dates with Freddy. She knows he’s not perfect, and doesn’t think of the relationship as serious, but it’s comfortable.

Davis returns home to his attorney father’s expectation that he’ll go to law school. But Davis would much rather work with his hands. His experiences during the war have left him with a couple of problems—smoking, and nightmares. He’d like to make up with Faith for an argument they had the night before he and her brother left to join the Army, but she’s not having it. She blames him for her brother’s death, saying that her brother, a promising musician, would never have joined up if it hadn’t been for Davis.

The author does a good job of presenting post-war life and the struggles faced both by those who stayed behind and those who went and served. I really didn’t like Freddy, but I don’t think I was meant to.

What I did like is the way the relationship between Davis and Faith develops. Once they decide they like each other—independently, after annoying the heck out of each other and some really awesome scheming on Faith’s part—the road doesn’t suddenly become easy. They both have baggage to deal with, and it’s that journey that makes things particularly satisfying.

Of course, being the swing dancer that I am, I also loved the references to the great old standards of the time!

Possible Objectionable Material:
Drinking, smoking, possible domestic violence, divorce. Mention of war and its effects on those who served.

Who Might Like This Book:
Those who like the WWII era. If you like watching someone figure out who they are and what they want, this is a good choice.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

This book is also reviewed at https://biblioquacious.blogspot.com/2...
Profile Image for Kimberly Sims.
114 reviews9 followers
June 27, 2023
The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door by Laura Rupper is a historical romance set in the 1940’s just after the end of WWII. It has brother’s best friend and enemies to lovers tropes!

This was such a fun story! I’ve always had some interest in this time period but haven’t had a ton of exposure to it so I loved being able to step into this time in history. The descriptions of the clothing, music, dancing, food and every day life really helped immerse me in the era.

I loved the characters, Faith and Davis, and their friends and family members. I loved that they have a long history together with lots of ups and downs. Faith and Davis definitely had challenges to overcome in their relationship, but I loved seeing them support each other and help one another understand the reasons behind their decisions.

I love that Faith helped Davis transition to home life by essentially forcing him to learn how to have fun and get involved in the community. She may have been trying to torture him, but I think those activities ended up being the best things to help him start to move on with life. I also love that Davis returned the favor and supported Faith in ways no one else could. He was compassionate and protective and always willing to lend a hand for Faith and her mom. They really do work so well together!

I also love that David was able to help Faith grow her family company. He never tried to take over her business or do things for her, he did things with her and helped her see opportunities that would benefit them both. I think that dynamic truly showed just how well matched Faith and Davis are.

Lastly I loved all the side stories that helped communicate the overall theme of forgiveness, service, and community. It was interesting to see how the same war impacted each character so differently and how every single person was impacted by the war, some for better and some for worse. I loved that they were able to come together to help one another cope and continue on with life without forgetting the sacrifice made by so many.

Overall I loved this story! The romance was slow burn but the characters were so fun! The time period was unique and helped me better understand what life was like during those years. I loved the underlying themes and life lessons. This is a well balanced book and I thoroughly enjoyed it!
Profile Image for Vanessa.
842 reviews60 followers
February 1, 2024
This was a delightful journey into the aftermath of World War II. In this charming historical romance, Rupper takes a unique approach, exploring the challenges faced by soldiers returning home—a perspective often overshadowed by wartime narratives.

As a newcomer to Rupper's work, I was pleasantly surprised by the depth and authenticity she brought to the story. Unlike many WWII romances that focus on the wartime experiences, this novel delves into the complexities of life after the battles have ceased. The protagonist, Sergeant Davis Wilson, grapples with the loss of his best friend, Patrick, and the weight of familial expectations. Rupper skillfully portrays Davis's struggle to rediscover his pre-war self, capturing the poignant essence of post-traumatic growth.

The narrative unfolds in a small town, offering a vivid snapshot of postwar America. The characters, especially Faith Penwilliger, are well-drawn and endearing. Faith, having faced her own share of loss and responsibilities, emerges as a strong and independent woman. The dynamic between Davis and Faith, evolving from animosity to a second chance at love, adds layers to the story, incorporating elements of enemies-to-lovers and friends-to-lovers tropes.

One aspect I particularly enjoyed was the incorporation of Faith's passion for dance as a coping mechanism for grief. The dance competitions and her interactions with Freddy provided a delightful backdrop, infusing the story with moments of joy and jealousy.

"The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door" is a captivating historical romance that goes beyond the traditional wartime setting. The sweet romance between Davis and Faith, coupled with the exploration of grief and self-discovery, makes this a poignant and engaging read. Rupper's attention to detail and the well-crafted small-town atmosphere enriched the overall reading experience. I highly recommend this lovely historical romance to readers seeking a heartfelt story set against the backdrop of post-war America.
Profile Image for Briana Gagnon.
280 reviews5 followers
March 18, 2023
Thank you Netgalley for this arc!

wow wow wow I loved this. Faith runs her family business and dances her nights away to forget about the pain left in the wake of the second world war. Davis, once lighthearted Davy, comes home without his best friend (Faith's brother) at his side. He deals with the struggles of adjusting to post war life as a veteran.

This was probably the slowest slow burn I've read, but it was worth it. I liked that we got to see what post war life was like because I feel like most of the ww two era historical fiction books don't deal with the aftermath.

Faith is not your typical 40's gal. She isn't in a committed relationship and she runs a male dominated business. She is also involved in her church which I thought was cool. I liked how hard working Davis was and watching him adapt to life as a civilian. It's not easy and we see these struggles as he deals with ptsd, insomnia, and a bad smoking habit.

Did I like all the religious talk? Not really. I will say, I'm glad divorce was talked about and accepted, heck even proposed by one of the characters (I won't spoil when or why). It's so taboo even today and I liked how the topic was tackled in this book.

I will be recommending my library purchase this because it was so well done.
Profile Image for Shauna Jones.
721 reviews15 followers
February 8, 2023
A wonderful story with feeling from anger to heartache to sadness to love
This story’s characters feel so real and true that you soon find yourself laughing, sighing, crying, and rooting for them as they try to navigate the complexity of life after war. Davis has just returned from Europe after WWII and knows he will never be the same, in part because he returned and his best friend and neighbor, Patrick, didn’t. Davis knows Patrick would want him to watch over the family he left behind, especially now that Patrick’s father had also died. But Patrick’s little sister, Faith, is no longer the cute teenager they left behind. Faith is now a beautiful, independent woman running the family business and doing it very successfully. Her one outlet is participating in dance competitions with her partner, Freddy. Davis is drawn to Faith and finds himself determined to break up the pair but his attempts fail and Faith institutes her own plan to teach Davis to mind his own business and stay out of hers. This is a truly enjoyable read that just kept pulling me in. Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the copy. This is my review and all thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for Emily Cronk.
338 reviews18 followers
May 1, 2023
I liked how unique the story was in that it takes place at the end of WWII with a soldier coming home and trying to find his place in the world again. While there were some bigger topics handled in the story (like overcoming the grief of losing a friend and brother to the war), it was very well written and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

I loved the cast of characters in this book as well! Davis and Faith were such a cute couple. They really were the perfect fit for each other, as they brought out the best in each other. I loved seeing their growth throughout the story. Frank and Juan were awesome side characters! They deserve some kind of award for their awesomeness (or a high-five at least). Freddy, on the other hand, deserves a kick to the shins. That guy is trouble. Lester probably deserves a kick to the shins too, let's be real.

Moral of the story here is that you need this book in your life, especially if you like WWII stories with a brother's best friend/second chance romance mixed in. I have spoken.

Many thanks to the publisher for the copy of the book; all thoughts are my own :)
Profile Image for Kylie Bingham.
163 reviews7 followers
April 4, 2023
Book review: The Sergeant and the Girl Next Door by Laura Rupper
.
Oh boy was this book a roller coaster. So many emotions! I laughed, I teared up, I was frustrated, and I was content. I think this book did a good job of acknowledging the changes that happened to people post world war 2 without being too heavy. The focus on relationships and growth made the book more light. The characters were well developed and grew more throughout the book. I enjoyed how the romance also grew in maturity along with the main characters. This story also had so many wonderful supporting characters that I couldn’t help but love. The Irish proverbs were an added bonus that I thoroughly enjoyed. This story was captivating and had me coming back to read more any chance I had. I will definitely be looking for more from this author!
.
Content: loss due to war, grieving loved ones, mild descriptions of concentration camps and war

Thank you to NetGally and Covenant Communications for the opportunity to read an advanced copy!
Profile Image for Becky.
976 reviews5 followers
April 7, 2023
This book starts shortly before Davis Wilson returns home from fighting overseas in WWII. He is dealing with PTSD from things he experienced and grieving those who didn’t survive, especially his best friend and next door neighbor Patrick who died at war. Faith Penwilliger thinks Davis is the reason Patrick enlisted and blames him for her older brother’s death. Life has been difficult for her trying to run the family business after losing her brother and then her dad.

I enjoyed reading this unique perspective on WWII and getting a glimpse into life in the 1940s. Rather than going into detail about the horrors of the war and the treatment of the Jewish people, the focus is mostly on how hard it was for soldiers to integrate back into regular life after WWII ended. I think it’s easy to forget that most of the men who fought were very young and just regular people who loved their country. They didn’t consider themselves heroes and often didn’t even want to talk about their experience for many years.
1,289 reviews13 followers
April 26, 2023
A sweet post World War II love story. This is my first time reading a book by this author. I thought it was a good look at the period of time. Faith had stepped in to run the family business after her brother was killed in service, and her father had a heart attack a week later. They owned a masonry business. She put off going to college to stay home to take care of her mother and run the business. Davis is the boy next door, who was best friends with her brother Patrick. They had enlisted together and Faith blamed Davis for her brothers death. The story flowed well and hold my attention throughout. I like the characters of Davis and Faith, their struggles that held them together and their bonds that pulled them apart, was also interesting, and held my attention throughout. The side stories of Faith dancing with Freddy and Faith’s cousin Rose’s circumstances were very realistic that could’ve happened during that time..Faith, hope and charity always make for a good story. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Profile Image for Julie.
784 reviews6 followers
February 25, 2023
I have always been fascinated by WWII and the surrounding time period. Davis is coming home at the end of the war having survived when so many of his friends didn't. Patrick, Davis' best friend and neighbor, didn't survive and his younger sister Faith, blames Davis for Patrick enlisting. Davis has a long road back to 'normalacy' . The war has changed him.
Faith has also changed since the war. She has had to grow up fast with the responsibility of running the family business after her father died of a heart attack a week after receiving notice that Patrick had died during his service. Her Mom, Marcia, is a huge help and support. She is navigating the changes that war has brought into her life.
I love how this book is a snapshot of how wars affect not only those who serve but those left behind. It affects the whole town in some way.
I would highly recommend this book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 92 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.