Boss-Busters and Sin Hounds: Kansas City and Its Star

by Harry Haskell

      At the turn of the twentieth century, the Kansas City Star was a trust-busting newspaper acclaimed for its crusading progressive spirit; fifty years later it was a busted trust, targeted in the most important antitrust action ever brought against an American daily. Now Harry Haskell tells the tale of the Star ’s rise and decline against the richly textured backdrop of Kansas City—the story of how a newspaper and a city grew together and ultimately grew apart. Boss-Busters and Sin Hounds takes readers into the city room and executive offices of one of the most respected American newspapers, whose influence extended beyond its own community to international affairs. Re-creating life at the Star from the inside, the book traces the shifting fortunes of a great newspaper and the compelling “power of purpose” it exerted from the birth of the progressive movement in the 1880s to the 1950s.             This fascinating tale—with underlying themes of sin and redemption, high-minded ideals and gutter politics—is populated by a cast of larger-than-life characters, ranging from power brokers to presidents and including such Kansas City notables as Tom Pendergast, J. C. Nichols, and Frank Walsh. But at heart this is the story of three men with contrasting personalities and agendas who shaped the newspaper over more than three-quarters of a William Rockhill Nelson, among the last of the great “personal” editors from journalism’s golden age; the scholarly Henry J. Haskell, who led the Star to its peak of influence in the 1930s and ’40s; and Roy A. Roberts, who went on to combine the roles of newspaper publisher and political kingmaker. Along the way, Haskell recounts such milestones as the Star’s role in the City Beautiful movement that helped transform America’s urban centers; the nation’s entry into two global wars; a bold but ill-starred experiment in employee ownership; and the paper’s on-again, off-again battle with Boss Pendergast’s legendary political machine. And he brings into focus issues that remain timely today, from social and political reform to the very role of newspapers in a democracy, while also drawing parallels with recent American history—disillusionment with liberalism, the hijacking of the GOP by the far right, America’s go-it-alone attitude—that are as alarming as they are instructive.  As Haskell shows, the evolution of American journalism from crusading newspapers to pawns of corporate culture was already under way in the early 1900s and was substantially complete by midcentury. Boss-Busters and Sin Hounds chronicles the glory days of an illustrious newspaper as it opens new windows on a city’s history.

464 pages, Hardcover

First published October 5, 2007

Reviews

[Chris Wolff · Rating 4 out of 5]

To enjoy this book one has to know quite a bit about Kansas City history already. I have read more on KC history than most and there were a few names and events described in the book that I didn’t know but that the author took for granted that the reader would know beforehand. That being said, I thorough enjoyed this book. It’s as much a biography of Nelson and Kansas City as it is a history of the Star. But as the author often points out, the Star was Kansas City and Kansas City was the Star. Very sad to see what this newspaper has become today. A shell of its former self.

[Rachel · Rating 1 out of 5]

I wanted to like this book, but it is really boring. I say this as someone who likes to read nonfiction. I had an especially hard time getting through the section about parks. Maybe if I lived in KC I would recognize names and landmarks and have some investment, but none of those things are true and I almost didn't finish.