I guess I’m a little cynical. I lost faith in the short story? Did I? Is that it? When I read, I’m hopeful. And, despite my faithlessness, I am sometimes surprised.
Let’s see. I bought their books after reading Richard Russo’s “Horseman,” Roy Kesey’s “Wait,” Nathan Englander’s “How We Avenged the Blums,” and William Gay’s, “Where Will You Go When Your Skin Cannot Contain You?” Lorrie Moore has been pretty influential. Kyle Minor gave me a Flannery O’Connor epiphany with “A Day Meant to Do Less.” And I’m still in love with Tim O’Brien’s THE THINGS THEY CARRIED.
Sometimes I hold the stories up to my own fierce literary theories about the redemptive end (see my essay on “Lost,” which is out there somewhere). Sometimes I read stuff and just forget about it. But sometimes I read something and take notes.
Okay, let’s not call me “cynical.” Let’s use “eclectic” instead.
So I just finished Benjamin Percy’s REFRESH, REFRESH.
This is one of the good ones. I’m not sure it really meets my whole redemptive-end-standards, but these are good stories with meaning and resolution. They’re also fairly, hmm, masculine. I can tell a guy wrote them. I hope that’s okay to say. I know I don’t like when people say that I write for women (I don’t!)—but I’m okay if you say I write like a girl. These are stories written by a guy, though they’re not enmeshed in that Hemingway macho stuff. There is, however, a fair amount of hunting and fishing.
But, ultimately, they’re stories for men and women. Perhaps they deal with a universal concern. They ask, if you will, the secularized version of the question posed by theologian Francis Schaeffer, “How shall we then live?” Soldiers return home from Iraq. How shall we then live? Marriages sour. How shall we then live? A car crash kills. How shall we then live? A father abandons his family. How shall we then live?
I liked most of the stories, but my favorites were “The Caves of Oregon,” “Meltdown,” and “Crash.” “The Caves of Oregon” plays a little, maybe, with Plato's “Allegory of the Cave” (okay, I’m probably making this up)—but I like stories about marriages that contain the sweetness and the pitfalls of commitment. Good marriage stories are kinda rare. “Meltdown” reminded me a little of THE ROAD by Cormac McCarthy, and a little of THE ROAD WARRIOR, the movie (Mel Gibson, circa my late childhood). But there were things in this story that weren’t in THE ROAD—and their absence in McCarthy always bugged me! This story had context! A reason for its apocalyptic reality! The protagonist had a history! That is serious cause for celebration! And then “Crash.” (Yeah, I have my own car crash story.) I liked this for a number of reasons. Part of it has to do with marriage again. The protagonist is destroyed over the death of his wife; however, it wasn’t a marriage or a life he dreamed about. He married the high school girlfriend because she was pregnant. He didn’t go out into the world to study international politics. He didn’t live in a big, beautiful house. He lived with his wife and kid in a trailer by his parents’ farm, where he worked too. And, yet, this death—the death of his wife—devastates him. She was his wife nonetheless. I also like the way the protagonist talks to his daughter, and the way he has a moment of shame because his groceries do not include soymilk. But, again, a central theme is a line in the story: “Here is my life.”
Oh, did I mention these stories mostly take place in Oregon? Which is refreshing, pun slightly intended, because most stories these days seem pretty East Coastish—even my own. Unless we’re talking Annie Proulx, but we’re not.
I’ll read more Benjamin Percy. I think they’re making a movie of his novel?