While I agree to the underlying premise of Ayn Rand's philosophy, I think that she takes it to extremes. That being said, I think Rand's fiction is important for people to read. Being the best that an individual can be is an admirable goal. All of her heroes, while not necessarily virtuous or even all that likable, are the best men that they could possibly be. Rand considers selfishness a virtue and selflessness the ultimate evil. I think that is where she is an extremist. I don't think it's possible to be 100% selfish or selfless. Most people share a common empathy with their fellow man as well as having a strong sense of self worth. That being said, I admire Ayn Rand as a skilled writer and as a person who stood up for what she believed in and shouted it from the rooftops.
The three pieces in "Three Plays" all predate her novels. Night of January 16th is the only one of the three to have been successfully produced on Broadway. Ideal and Think Twice have never been professionally produced. All three plays share a common theme: The selfish man persecuted by the selfless general public.
Night of January 16th is a courtroom drama. Karen Andre is accused of murdering her lover, Bjorn Faulkner. Faulkner is a prime example of Rand's selfish hero. Even though his character is deceased and never appears in the action of the play, his life and subsequent murder are the driving forces behind the drama. Karen is the typical Rand heroine. Firm in her convictions and unwilling to bend, even if it means her demise. The thing about Night of January 16th that makes it so appealing to producers is the novelty of bringing 12 audience members onstage to act as the jury - and as such, there are two endings for the play depending on the verdict.
Ideal concerns a Hollywood actress, Kay Gonda, who is accused of murder and is on the run. Gonda, once again is the typical Rand heroine. She takes 6 of her fan letters and goes to the house of each of them to see if one of them will shelter her for the night. This play is a fascinating character study. Many of the people you see will turn up, in one way or another, in Rand's later fiction. Of the three plays in the book, this is my personal favorite. Ideal is complex on so many levels that, from a theatrical professional's stand point, it would be very difficult to produce. It is, however, a work that is worthy of production as it is the closest of the three plays to Atlas Shrugged, Rand's greatest work of fiction.
Think Twice is a who-done-it murder mystery with an Objectivist twist. Rand's murder mystery weaving is not going to send P.D. James running to hide by any stretch of the imagination. That being said, it is still a very good example of this type of play which was very popular in the early 20th century. The plot twist at the end is atypical of the genre, but it is something to be expected from Rand. Think Twice has never been professionally produced, perhaps because of the plot twist at the end.
If you are a fan of Ayn Rand, by all means, read these plays. If you've never been able to get through The Fountainhead or Atlas Shrugged these plays might be an easier introduction to Rand's style and philosophy. Either way - read them - they're good for you.