“What we have, sweet Sally, is an ideal love. It’s ideal because it can’t be realized.”
The proposal, ‘Marry me,’ is sweet but only in the right place and at the right time. Here, it is all wrong. As Barry Manilow used to croon, ‘We have the right love at the wrong time.’ Even this does not sound quite right for the pair of married couples in this twisted drama of love gone wrong.
Jerry and Sally (age about 30) seem very much in love and are having an affair. Their respective spouses (Ruth and Richard) are unaware of their betrayal although each must have sensed something is awry. When their infidelity comes to light, all hell breaks loose, and Jerry is compelled to decide what to do. Except that Jerry, a man who does not know his own mind, waits, and hopes that others or circumstance will make the decision for him.
Updike writes about marital breakup like one who knows. The struggles of the foursome are luridly and painfully described. We get to know each of the four characters intimately, more than we care to know, more than enough to get riled and disgusted at their bad behavior. Jerry is a weak and spineless man whose attraction to Sally is only sexual. Sally is a selfish, shallow, and materialistic woman who is greedy to get what pleases her. Richard is a wealthy and brutish man who is disrespectful to women and has his fair share of affairs. Ruth, the sanest of the lot, has had an affair too, is longsuffering and too conciliatory for her own good. Loathsome characters. Half the time, I wish I could reach into the pages and chortle all of them.
Affairs exert a heavy cost on all involved. Jerry has depression, which is caused by a religious guilt he could not swallow. Jerry dreamed of a love that was fruitful, 'being relaxed, and right, and … with a blessing.’ However, this is unattainable because for Jerry, the blessing ‘must come from above.’ He confessed to Sally, “I’ve figured out the bind I’m in. It’s between death and death. To live without you is death to me. On the other hand, to abandon my family is a sin; to do it I’d have to deny God, and by denying God I’d give up all claim on immortality.” As Shakespeare’s Hamlet would have said, Ay, there’s the rub!”
This story is set in 1962 when the ‘old morality’ holds all men (and women) accountable. Even so, should it be any different now? Updike also does not let us forget how the children in both families are affected. Some of his tenderest lines are reserved for the little ones caught haplessly in the mess their parents have made.
I read the last chapter ‘Wyoming’ a few times and think I get it. It is brilliantly crafted. An idealized love like Jerry’s finds a place only in the imagination. I developed a respect for Updike’s impeccable prose that is marked by poetic sensitivity. The sound and fury in the dialogue between fighting couples is deafening. My Goodreads friend, Robin, said it best. “You read Updike to be dazzled and then depressed, but you are so dazzled you forgive him the depression.”
Published in 1976, Marry Me: A Romance is a sordid tale of marital infidelity and an emotionally exhausting read. You can imagine how thankful I am to have shared this journey with my reading buddies: Mark, Diane, Lisa, Candi, Dave, Jennifer, Jeannie, and Ebba.
This is my first full length novel by John Updike. Impressive craftsmanship. Scintillating prose.