In 2021, I read a couple of "werewolf" novels that left me severely disappointed. One of them was quite terrible, and the other wasn't as bad but the element of horror was completely absent and the werewolf part of the story was merely a plot device in a rather straightforward thriller. As an avid consumer of all things horror with a particular fascination of lycanthropy, I often seek out a good werewolf story, but have yet to find one that's really WOWed me. This one came much closer than the previous two I read (which I'm avoiding naming here, but if you browse through my shelf you'll find them), but still didn't quite hit the mark, for me.
In The Forsaken Boy, our lead character, Brandon, is sort of an outcast, a loner. In the beginning his "parents" kick him out of the house and he has to fend for himself. Having been picked on and bullied his entire life, he doesn't have many friends or anyone he can turn to for help. He carries on, merely surviving, until his path leads him into that of a werewolf, that gives him a choice. Live, or die.
This book had a lot of cool ideas that I liked. It follows in the tradition of a more classical type werewolf story - protagonist is transformed - agonizes over this new alter-ego - bodies turn up - police get involved / mystery is implemented, etc.
However, Mr. Tradup approaches things from a slightly different angle. Instead of our lead character being surprised by the existence of a monster, or trying to flee, he is enticed by it and wonders how he can use this opportunity to his benefit. There are some interesting themes tacked on to this idea involving temptation and its consequences. I liked this idea and exploration of themes, even if it took the backseat during the second half, where the story structure seems to fall more into step with the stereotypical werewolf story (again - body count, police involvement, etc.) These psychological themes could have been opened up a bit more (in my opinion) without it being too heavy-handed.
There is also a bit of commentary on the "bullied" kid in school. What happens when someone is disrespected and violated his entire life and is then given capable and effective means to lash out in bitterness and rage...? This is something that we've unfortunately seen far too often in our society, and this book doesn't skirt around the issue. In fact, I applaud the author for being so bold to include some scenes and instances of this "bullying", and not holding back in regards to language and slurs. Is it terrible? Quite. Is it realistic? Absolutely.
I want to back up a little here and talk about Brandon's character, which had me a bit conflicted and slightly affected my reading experience. The characterization certainly isn't the best, and Brandon feels solely defined by his circumstances. He doesn't have much of a personality and it feels like he is completely the product of his environment - that is, those who have wronged him in one way or another. And don't get me wrong, he really does endure some twisted stuff that is evidently supposed to elicit sympathy for him... but I never really felt like I knew him, and at times I thought of him as sort of a bratty, selfish character, wallowing in self-pity. Of course, I think this all may have been intentional, that there is no simple black-and-white area... but I do think the characters in general here lacked any sort of true layering.
This is the author's, Mr. Tradup's, first book and so I have to be a little bit forgiving for the lack of characterization in some areas, and also (at times) the writing, which seemed a little clunky and awkward in some areas in regards to word choices and sentence structure. The writing wasn't bad (where the hell is my published novel, anyway?!), but it's not exactly anything that grabbed me or had any sort of immersive effect, either. For a debut novel, this was pretty impressive. I do wished we would have got a bit more detail in regards to some of the action later on in the book - for how bold it was earlier on, I was surprised to discover that some of the more "intense" sequences were often alluded to and/or had strongly implied outcomes. I was slightly disappointed with this lack of descriptive violence, only given the direction the story took. Werewolf stories tend to be more psychological than anything, which is what I often appreciate about them, and I have no qualms with subtleties... but I felt a little bit cheated at times with the severe lack of blood and gore. However, there was a bit of a twist earlier in the book involving a priest and a farmer (a shocking twist that I again applaud the author for), and I was glad he didn't go into anymore detail with that one. Some things are better left without too much explanation or description.
This book also took a different direction at the end then I thought it was going to, which I appreciated. I'll admit to not being super invested in the story so it didn't necessarily surprise or impact me, but I was just happy to get something other than what I expected.
Overall, it's a bit hard for me to rate this book. I liked some things about it but there were others that dampened my overall enjoyment. Again, this being a debut novel, I have to remind myself I can't expect the writing quality of King or Koontz. Ironically enough, the two werewolf novels I read last year were both by (somewhat) well-known/established authors... and I can say with confidence this book is better than those two. This feels more like what a werewolf novel should be, while managing to keep things a bit fresh and present some unique twists and turns. I just didn't quite love it.
Trying to find an excellently written, satisfying werewolf novel seems to be like trying to find an actual werewolf. It's damn near impossible. They could exist, somewhere...
But this one is decent, all things considered. I can recommend it if you're a fellow werewolf junkie - but I'll continue to seek (and likely not find) that elusive horror story about a man who changes into a werewolf, and scratches all the right itches and ticks off every box for me.
2.75 / 5 - rounded up to 3.