Approximately one week before I started this book I read one about the legendary football coach Vince Lombardi. Like Indiana University coach Bobby Knight, Lombardi was known for the vicious tongue lashings and criticisms of his football players. Yet, both were big winners and despite experiencing their temper tantrums, many of their players spoke highly of them. However, defensive tackle Henry Jordan regularly used the phrase, “Lombardi treats us all the same, like dogs.”
Steve Alford played for Bobby Knight at Indiana University for four years, was a member of the U. S. Olympic Gold medal winning team coached by Knight and the Indiana team went on a world tour in an offseason. Alford uses this to justify the “six seasons” phrase in the title.
Alford depicts himself as a straight arrow as a member of the Fellowship of Christian Athletes, which was true when he was a college and early NBA player. Most of the ink is used to describe how Coach Knight constantly belittled the players, making even the faintest of praise so significant. It is clear that most players could not have played for Knight. As Alford states in the book, when Alford and Michael Jordan were on the U. S. Olympic team, Jordan bet Alford $100 that he would not last the full four seasons with Knight.
While Knight was a tyrant, he also ran one of the cleanest programs in the country with one of the highest graduation rates. As Alford states more than once, if a player missed classes or dogged it academically, they were benched first and then kicked off the team if it continued. It is clear that the coaching tactics of Knight and Lombardi are a thing of the past, players and the general public will no longer tolerate it. Given what they did, that is for the better. One wonders if all of the verbal belittlement was really necessary, if not counterproductive. Both Knight and Lombardi were brilliant tacticians in their sports, so they likely would have been successful had they no yelled so much.