Witch's Brew

The Spellspinners of Melas County #1

by Heidi R. Kling

Once soulmates, the witch and warlock covens of the California coast have been estranged for a century. Raised to hate each other, their teenagers meet in the Solstice Stones, a magical battleground where they draw energy from each other to maintain their balance. 16 year olds Logan and Lily have spent years training for their first Stones…only to discover just days before that the enemy may not be what either of them had thought.

In Witch’s Brew, Lily is torn between her feelings for Logan and her coven’s need to know who—or what—he is. The young lovers race against time, their distrust for each other, and the powerful influence of their elders, to unravel the mystery of their pasts before their future is destroyed.

Genres: Fantasy, Witches, Young Adult, Paranormal, Romance, Ebooks, Paranormal Romance

342 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 11, 2012

About the author

Heidi R. Kling writes books about normal girls in fantastic situations.

Her debut novel SEA (Penguin/Putnam) was a finalist for Northern California Book of the Year," an IndieNext Summer Pick, Goodreads “Mover and Shaker," Scholastic Reading Pick, and Gateway Reader’s Award Finalist among other generous accolades. SEA, which launched June, 2010, is a bittersweet love story set in the aftermath of the devastating 2004 Indonesian tsunami, and is set to relaunch with Entangled Teen December 4 as WHERE I FOUND YOU (Sea series #1) with its sequel WHERE THE SEA TAKES ME out April, 2018!


After earning her MFA in Writing for Children from the New School in New York, Heidi returned to the Bay Area where she lives with her family in a tiny seaside village like the towns in her books.

She's also the author of the acclaimed PAINT MY BODY RED (for fans of Speak and 13 Reasons Why), bestselling romantic comedy NOT OKAY, CUPID and the Spellspinners of Melas County series about feuding witches and warlocks.

Please visit her on twitter (Heidi R. Kling) where she loves to live-tweet TV shows, overuse gifs and chat with her readers about books, love and travel. She's very fortunate to write stories for a living and is grateful to you for reading them!
http://heidirkling.com

Reviews

[Heidi · Rating 5 out of 5]

Turns out the ol' #sexahmagicbook took its nickname too far and hath blossomed into a 10-book series!
Least I could do is give myself a half-star per book, no? ;-)

Can't wait to share book one, WITCH'S BREW, with everyone today!

[Jen · Rating 5 out of 5]

Heidi R. Kling's Witch's Brew is one of those novels that completely takes you by surprise. From the synopsis, it sounds like your typical witch story with a hot guy in it, but Heidi is able to make it her own, and therefore unique. (And the hot guy isn't just a hot guy, he's a smokin' hot guy). With the completely different style of reading the novel, an exciting and well explained world, and relatable characters, Witch's Brew has enchanted itself onto my favorite witch-books list.

In case you didn't already know, the format for Witch's Brew is unlike any other book I've read before; the story gives you options as to where the story should go--kind of like alternate stories within one story. I myself have only read one option, but I'll definitely be reading the other option in the near future. For me, the fact that this novel is formatted this way, just stands out to me. It's different, unique, and totally memorable. I definitely recommend that all readers try it out.

Another factor that I absolutely loved about Witch's Brew is the world-building, and explanations. Kling brings the reader into the world of witches and warlocks very smoothly, and leaves the reader far from confused. I'm that type of person who needs a clear explanation on how a world works, or I won't be satisfied. To me, if I still have questions about an author's world, it means that they didn't do their job very well. I can happily say that Kling certainly exceeded my expectations with her description of the Spellspinner world and the Gleaning. Not only does the description carry out well, it also keeps the reader interested and wanting to know more. This also ties in with the plot. It's mysterious, alluring, and just plain engaging. I usually don't like it when a problem addressed in the beginning isn't resolved until the end, but it works in Witch's Brew. It works very well indeed (there's a clifffhanger!).

Last but not least, are the oh-so-amazing characters! Lily, the main character, was totally spunky, curious, and really smart. She's modest and hesitant at first about being chosen as the Leader of the Daughters of Light, but it's clear that she is meant to be the leader after the events that progress in the novel. Her relationship with Logan, the love interest (and also a warlock) is totally swoon-worthy and hot. Logan is caring, protective, and clever as well (have I mentioned smexy?). I have to admit, their love is kind of a love-at-first sight type of deal, but not exactly, which is why I like it. I'll leave it for you to find out how exactly they fall in love. ;)

That said, I definitely recommend Witch's Brew, whether you like witches or not. The format itself of the novel is just plain awesome and I think everyone should give it a try. I fell under Witch's Brew's spell with the captivating world and perfect characters. Heidi R. Kling's novel certainly did not disappoint and I can't wait to read more of her work.

4.5 Teacups for Witch's Brew!

*Much thanks goes to the publisher for providing me with a copy in exchange for an honest review!*

THIS REVIEW WAS ORIGINALLY POSTED ON A Reading Daydreamer:
http://a-reading-daydreamer.blogspot....

For more of my reviews, check out the blog:

[Siobhan · Rating 1 out of 5]

I really feel as though I’m part of the minority with this one. A lot of people seem to enjoy this book, yet I couldn’t really get into it. I tried – oh, I tried so hard – but in the end, I couldn’t finish it.

I admit that such a thing is rare for me, but it does occasionally happen. I’m also trying to force a new rule onto myself: to stop reading books I’m not enjoying. Since joining BookBub the number of books on my Kindle has boomed. There are now over a thousand books sitting on there, simply because I cannot ignore the word ‘free’. I’ve forced my way through a number I’ve not enjoyed, and that needs to end. If I’m not enjoying it, I need to move on to something else.

Thus, Witch’s Brew became the first book to experience the new rule.

I cannot really place my finger on the specific thing that prevented me from enjoying the story. What I read felt far too much like every other young adult book on the market – you know what I mean, the whole special snowflake and forbidden love interest shebang. I can deal with this, though. However, to want to continue the story needs something that really shines. I worked through a decent percentage of the story, but nothing overly wonderful was appearing. There wasn’t that extra ‘wow’ factor. Moreover, I never really came to enjoy the voice of the story.

Sadly, this one was not for me. I’m sure it appeals to many others, yet I couldn’t bring myself to finish this one.

[Sharon L · Rating 2 out of 5]

EDIT: after some thoughts I lower the rating down to 2 stars. the fact that a book resembles every other cliché on the genre does not mean I need to spare it. this is the right thing to do as sad as it is.

I ran into this book while searching for something new, different, unique.

I found it (though not in this book).

I also wanted to read a book about witches, it has been a long time since I read one. which leads me to admitting that the latest witched book I read and remember quite well is a HP book. regardless of the many problems I might have with the HP series, I found the world building and the magic to be...well...amazing. just like the majority of people who read the series and dreamed of attending Hogwarts. in comparison to that book, this book falls short.

In compared to other books I read the contained magic to some degree or another (Like most books Ilona Andrews) this book is found lacking for my tastes. Considering I was in a reading slump lately, this book has an extremely bad luck with me. but the thing is the each book should (most of the time) be given a chance and examined and rated in it's own merits. Of course, rationally speaking that is not possible. for every book is read through the eyes of the one who reads it, and the reading process is very much influenced by the experience and feelings of the reader as well as the books he read before.

This review very much expresses my opinion of the book.

So while I read this book, and while I didn't suffer completely I kept thinking of other things I had to do. I wasn't hooked (far from it, truth be told).

I found the characters lacking in depth and their voice average just like any other formulated YA book, and we've got plenty of those. the story is told through 2 POV's one of Lily (aka the MC) and the other of Logan (aka, "sexy dude"/love interest). While Lily's POV is told in the first person, Logan's is told in the third person.

I found the constant exchange to be mildly annoying. Also, I didn't find the explanation of the magic system, the rivalries or most things regarding Lily's and Logan's world satisfying. I am very much aware that most people will not have a problem with such thing, I wouldn't either if I read this book 2 years ago. Since then, I learned that I want a good enough explanation in the magical system, rules, limits options (not only on magical system but on every world created by an author). this book is once again found lacking.

And even though I am not grammar fanatic, there were some inconsistencies in the whole tense in which the book was written, one minute it was past tense and then all of sudden a sentence was told in present tense and I'm not talking about dialogues.

what else? *looking at my notes* the writing, yup the writing. All in all I'd say the writing is average like in most books I read not bad but not good, not lyrical or evoking but not eye-bleeding. but sometimes the writing was more on the "talking" side then the "writing" side. I'll try to explain. Lily tells are something, and she does it well enough for me to picture it, and then she goes saying "In conclusion" maybe it's just me but I didn't like the way it came out. you are telling a story Lily, and while you tell your story you do not address the reader directly and all of sudden you do? I call that being inconsistent.

It's not only the MCs that were lacking in depth, the supporting cycle was very much stereotypical as well, some of the dialogues felt dull. We have a bestie that is supposedly more beautiful, leader like and talented than the MC, we have the leader of the coven that is all about "the goal" and even when we get to know more about the warlocks, after being told they are "the bad guys", we learn that all in all most of them aren't very sympathetic dudes, especially not Jacob (aka, Logan's father and leader of warlocks) who falls quite well to the stereotypical bad guy criteria.

The book is very formulated with:

Super Speshul Snow Cornflake Syndrom:
Both Lily and Logan can breath under water which makes the the only living magical beings that can do that, Lily is the leader of The Daughters of the Light and Logan is the leader of The Sons of Darkness (may I say stupid names? obviously light is good, dark is bad, and I'm sick of that bullshit)
Also they are beautiful- Logan is tall, broad shouldered dark and brooding, with inks.
Lily is blonde, tall, long legs, smells good, into yoga (like all of her coven).

MC not sure of her looks syndrome:
So yeah, Lily is beautiful, but she doesn't think she's beautiful. in fact she thinks her bestie is he beautiful one. insecure much? I don't get it. the fact that you are beautiful doesn't mean that your friend isn't and vise versa. Also, I know that using that formula is all about making girls reading the book to sympathize with the MC, but is all that insecurity really needed? maybe it's better to give message of "your are beautiful" or "everyone is beautiful" or "everyone has something beautiful about them"? but this is not a discussion for this review.

TSTL syndrome (aka too stupid to live):
As is well known most MCs in YA books has tendency to act stupidly one way or another saying how much they need to do it or what ever. Our dear Lily is not different- pretty much and the beginning of the book she goes and does something stupid and dangerous. Luckily, she meets Logan, but the fact that she was lucky does not mean that she wasn't stupid and that what she did couldn't cost her gravely. she says herself- "No rational human, or witch, would dare hike up here unaccompanied, especially this close to twilight. But I was on a mission and not easily deterred. Besides, I was no average rational
creature."
you are right, ducky, you are not rational to be doing that, but hey, admitting the problem is first step to solving it.

The big insta-L:
Once again we have insta love- Logan and Lily (aka LiLo) meet and are instantly attracted to each other, he's smoking hot like a tree on fire and she's beautiful like the moon and they want to touch, they want to be together, they never found another human being this attractive they are destined. seriously? what's wrong with human boys/girls? I think nothing, LiLo just don't find them attractive, because when you are super speshul cornflake you can't help but wanting to pair with a super speshul cornflake of your caliber. "US SUPER SEPSHUL CORNFLAKES MUST STICK TOGETHER"

their flirtation and conversations are plain. sorry no spark in here- move on!

star crossed lovers:
Once again, I can't help but wonder what is it with YA books (and other books) and the star crossed lovers theme? Romeo and Juliette died in the end, that wasn't sexy, good, funny or happy. yes, going through obstacles is important in a relationship, but you know what? It's the little things that can tear people apart just as much as the big things. and I know you want adventure and excitement, but there are other ways to bring excitement. you can do it perfectly well with the MCs capable of being together.

the war between the sexes the witches are girls the warlocks are boys and they are in war because of...well...a curse. they glean each others magic like parasites. but can I just say the whole boys against girls is soooo cliche?

last but not least- there's a chastity vow (on both sides) which gave me the whole "WTF" thought. and I found the plot to be slow, as well as the dialogues and some of the writing to be a little like a list. the banter and the snark and big wanna be but nothing real behind it. And girl doesn't play spy that well, sorry.

But enough ranting, I'm tired of ranting and that's all I've done till now. with all the ranting the rating might be somewhat surprising. because seems like I didn't like that one, and I guess all in all I didn't. But I'll get to the rating in a little.

What I did like about this book was that that it seemed like Lily was a good older sister and that Logan wasn't a jerk. So on that side we don't have full formula, and I liked that.
The idea in itself though not highly original was a good idea, it's just the execution could be better is all.

Also this is an interactive book which I found to be really interesting and surprising, it didn't save the book much here, but it is a good experience and something many reader will enjoy. :D

as for the rating- I complained about many things, but I could apply these complaints to most YA books in this modern day (especially since Twilight). it is not the book's fault that it follows a trend and a formula that proved to be selling. If I give this book less then 3 stars, which it might be deserving, there are many other books I'll have to give them less too. Also, even though it was formulated it wasn't bad, so I find it to stand in the middle, just like the average.

I guess what I'm trying to say is this whole thing is formulated and I'm getting tired of it. it is not bad, just not great or different or unique. sad as it is to admit.

this reading copy was provided to me by the author in R4R program in exchange for an honest review.

this reviwe can also be found on The Accidental Reader

[Erica · Rating 5 out of 5]

Fantasy has always been my favorite genre, so when I learned Heidi R Kling was writing a fantasy book, I was beyond ecstatic. For those of you that have read my blog at any point before, you will know of my love for Heidi R Kling’s debut, Sea, and how I harbor this immense crazy love for it. Something I didn’t think was possible happened with Witch’s Brew – I loved it even more. I should learn to never doubt Heidi R Kling, as she is simply a mastermind with words and can write the most beautiful stories.

Witch’s Brew is told in split point of view between Lily and Logan. First off, I just loved this – Split point of view is one of my favorite things for an author to do, and Heidi R Kling rocked it. Lily and Logan both had great voices and I found them to be great narrators – I really liked both of their voices.

Another really neat aspect to Witch’s Brew is that there are two different options for the story to go You reach a point a little ways into the book and are given two paths, like a choose your own adventure. That means you get double the characters (specifically double the Logan) and double the story! I loved both options – both were super intense and I loved them for different reasons.

The world Heidi R Kling has spun is wonderful. Her take on witches is fresh and new – which made reading so much fun. I never knew what the rules of the witches and the warlocks were or how they lived. It was a completely new experience. I also just love Kling’s prose – it is so whimsical and has a musicality about it. My emotions were running high the entire time I was reading – I found myself cheering with the characters or get upset when things weren’t going the way I wanted or well for the characters. That is my favorite type of book to read, one where I can get so into the story!

The originality of the witches in Kling’s world really helped make the plot that much more interesting. I had no expectations for what would happen, so I just loved walking through Lily and Logan’s world to figure out what would happen next. There were elements of mystery in the cases of both the witches and the warlocks, and I’m very curious how that will all pan out.

The characters of Witch’s Brew were so much fun. Logan will be sure to catch every girl’s attention – I know he has definitely made the top to my list of hot YA boys. He is just so nice and so pure hearted I felt like. I loved Lily – she is a great main character and another great soul. Daisy was a character who was so fun any scene she was in – I hope to hear a lot more from her in future books! Orchid had so much spunk – She’s another character I’m looking forward to see more of. Maggie only appears in one scene, but she’s yet another character to hear more from in the future.

I simply cannot wait for the second Spellspinners of Melas County book. Kling has built the perfect structure for the series with this book and it will simply take off from here. The last pages of Witch’s Brew built with an immense amount of intensity to just the perfect point, then breaks off in quite the cliffhanger. It is a cruel ending, yet definitely peaked my interest beyond belief for the next book.

Witch’s Brew is the book I have been waiting for since the day I finished the last page of Sea. There’s something about Heidi R Kling’s books that is so magical. The stories she tells and the characters she chooses, they all are just so wonderful and worthy of being told. The cast of characters in this series definitely have a story worth telling, so the wait until book 2 begins now.

[Zed Whisper · Rating 5 out of 5]

‎From the first few chapters I was drawn into Witches brew. I've read many books about witches, about warlocks, about witches and warlocks, but never a story about witches versus warlocks.

Lily is the leader of her coven and is preparing for the upcoming battle; also known as gleaning, where she will have to fight a warlock and from my understanding, only one can survive. But how can she win this fight when even her most basic spells are failing her? And not just Lily, her bestfriend is also feeling a reduced magical vibe... but they must overcome it and practice harder, because there is no way the 'evil' warlocks can be allowed to win.

Unexpectedly lily comes across a warlock, and despite her attempts to stay cautious and alert just in case he attempts to trick her, she feels at ease with him, almost safe. In fact she feels more than that, their energies react and theirs a pull that neither Lily nor Logan can explain.

Soon after Lily discovers that theirs a curse that the elders have kept from the young witches, which is causing their powers to wane. And if the hundred year old curse isn't broken then the witches will lose their powers and become human again.

I really enjoyed this story, and the way the warlocks were described as evil and the witches good, but we could see both sides having traits of light and darkness. I'm a bit afraid of Logan's 'father' as he seems to be too power hungry, trying to take away Logan's power in an attempt to reverse his ageing process. I suspect he's responsible for the voodoo doll too!

I look forward to reading book 2 to find out more about this curse, and who Logan's real parents are and why is it that only Lily and Logan can breathe underwater; an uncanny ability that only they possess.

Favourite Quotes:

She'd said, "I don't want you to think about what happens after, only to concentrate on what you can do before, to train, so that you will come home safely. Focus on strength, courage, and the greater good, which will come from doing your personal best. The rest will follow."
"I don't want to die," I'd said, swallowing back tears.
"Then don't," was her reply.

"I suppose this is goodbye," Logan said.
"I guess so," I said. "Thanks for not trying to kill me."
"It was my pleasure," he said, "not to try and kill you."
I surprised myself by raising a palm to Logan, a gesture of peace.
He held his own palm up to mine, taking the gesture further. Friendship.

"I've worked hard to get where I am. Besides, magic is all I've ever known. I see how humans live. I was there during Katrina, remember? It was a tragic mess- the worst of the human condition. I can transcend al that now. The inevitable death and dying. The rot. The struggle to work, reproduce, just to start heading downhill toward death? No thanks."

Orchid shrugged. "Look, we've been living in Melas for generations and generations. Not all humans are stupid. Most, sure. But not all. If that cotton-candy-head barista knows something I mean, who would believe him if he told? And who would he tell? The key to survival, Lily, is making sure the people who cold take you down never find out your secrets."

I avoided her eyes. "I don't want to feel anything for him."
I felt the weight of her words in the air, strong as her perfume. "I know it's scary. Feelings aren't something you want or don't want- they are something you have or don't. Every feeling is a gift. It means you are real."

A guy that could sport pink hair AND drive a pink car around town must be hugely firm in his masculinity. I told him so.
"What is pink if not a softer shade of red, right?"

"Perhaps out amulets were switched at birth."
Logan half-grinned, but his brow was still furrowed in thought. "If we're related, I'm going to kill someone." He laughed then. An honest, real, laugh. Then felt his fingers on my cheek, tipping my face to look into his eyes.
"If we're related, the universe has a seriously twisted sense of humour."

[Anna McC · Rating 5 out of 5]

Thank you to Heidi R.Kling for allowing me to read this book on a read for review basis.

Wow this book was amazing. From the very first sentence I was hooked. This isn't just any witch book with the same old storyline. Heidi R.Kling has a way of taking a simple thing and making it brand new and completely original. It was like no other witch book I have ever read and it made it stand out and keep my attention throughout the book. The author not only wrote a brilliant book but she also tried a new way of writing to interact more with the reader and I believe it worked fantastically. Giving the reader multiple options on what may happen throughout the book with the characters making different decisions or following different paths aloud the reader to feel even more involved with the story. I personally loved this new way of writing and read all of the options within the book to see how simple decisions could change the whole outcome of something. I have to say I think all of the options were amazing there wasn't one that I was disappointed with.

On top of her exciting and new way interacting with the reader Heidi R.Kling also created a fantastic plot and well developed characters. Witches and warlocks are enemies but with the possibility of them all losing their magic the witches may have to consider trusting one of the very creatures the despise. As the romance between the witch Lily and warlock Logan blossoms the reader becomes more and more attached to these wonderful characters. Lily is a curious energetic girl who falls for the wrong guy or the right guy since Logan is protective, caring and don't forget very hot.

Another thing that the author does brilliantly is creating her version of the world of witches. She has created a very exciting world without leaving the reader confused as to what is happening. By adding the prophecy to the book she has allowed lots of drama and problems for the teenage couple to face.

Overall I thought this was a very unique and attention grabbing book that I could not put down. By using her wonderful descriptions and keeping the drama going throughout the book the reader is on the edge of their seats hoping that these two teenagers can find a way to be together. I would recommend that people try this book but be warned it ends on a tormenting cliff hanger.

[JeanBookNerd · Rating 5 out of 5]

Heidi R. Kling’s first book in The Spellspinners of Melas County, Witch’s Brew, is an amazing story about a complex barred love between a witch and a warlock. Sixteen-year-olds Lily and Logan, who were once soulmates and now strangers for a hundred years, they meet again in a magical battleground called the Solstice Stones. They spent years of training for their first Stones only to realize that the enemy in the Solstice Stones is not what they have been preparing for.

This magical world that author Heidi has created is wonderfully unique. Her take on witches and their lives is refreshingly new and readers will enjoy learning all of the fascinating witch facts. It is a perfect setting for this kind of fantasy romance. The characters are complex and full of life. The pairing of Lily and Logan is delightfully charming.

Told in split perspectives between the two main protagonists, it produces the perfect avenue for readers to fully grasp the characters’ intentions. Multiple perspectives is not easy to write as it can make things complicated but Heidi manages to keep it smooth. Her writing style is hauntingly gripping as readers will find themselves having a difficult time putting the book down.

Whether you enjoy reading about witches or not, there is something for everyone in this book. The format that Heidi has produced for this novel is amazing as it creates a spellbinding addiction for readers to soak up everything she has to offer. Witch’s Brew is highly captivating and it will certainly not disappoint. It is the perfect way to emanate this awesome series as I am already itching for the next book.

[Kate (VerbVixen) · Rating 5 out of 5]

SEXY MAGIC BOOK. That's what twitter has been calling Witch's Brew for months now, and its an apt name. Witchy girls, warlock boys, a feud, mystery, drama, and an intense romance: this book has it all. I love Logan and Lily. Love love love love love. Witch's Brew has so many brilliant moments- of vulnerability, passion, anger, fragility. I will warn you though, be prepared for a heart-stopping, cliff-hanging ending that will leave you screaming. No really there was actual shrieking involved. Kling has some magic of her own I think; all of her books take me on an emotional rollercoaster with characters of true depth. I can't wait for Spellspinners 2, so here's hoping Heidi is hard at work!

Adding to my excitement is the fact that Witch's Brew is one of the first Coliloquy published books. Coliloquy takes the "choose your own adventure" premise of books we read as kids and brings it into the digital age. Specifically made for Kindle, we make choices while reading which in turn go back to the author to incorporate into the series and help them determine where to take the characters next. SO COOL!

Overall: A

[Pam Pho · Rating 5 out of 5]

Big review closer to release date, but I LOVED everything about this book. In fact I am reading it over right now, because it has CHOICES! It feels like one of those choose your own adventure books we all read when we were young, but less childish and with higher stakes. The story of the witches was well thought out and great research went into the book about celtic paganism. I can't wait for more.

[Misty Baker · Rating 4 out of 5]

When I was about 11 years old I discovered the wonderful world of “choose your own adventure” books. My teacher was thrilled. It kept me in the classroom much longer and out of the library exchanging books every other day. Me? I was just thrilled (the stubborn child that I was) to be offered the chance to make up my own mind. See, I am the girl who screams at the TV when the dumb blonde (who will eventually be the heroin of the movie) runs UP the stairs when the big bad wolf is after her vs hauling her skinny ass out the door. With “choose your own adventure” books I finally had that opportunity to throw my two cents into the pot (unlike with with the super bimbo) and tell the characters which way I wanted them to go. The ending is going to be the same (or course) that is an inevitability that never changes, but I (the READER) got to decide which road to travel down on the way there. (Aka…Barbie hoofs it out the back door.) Witch’s Brew by Heidi R Kling is the next generation of “choose your adventure” literature (or as Heidi prefers to call it “Choose your own destiny”) She sets the story and we get to “help” decide the path the characters take.

Once soulmates, the witch & warlock covens have been estranged for a century. Twice a year, their teens meet in the Solstice Stones, a magical battleground, to draw energy from each other. Logan & Lily have trained their whole lives for the Stones. In Witch’s Brew, Lily is torn between her feelings for Logan & her loyalty to her coven. The lovers race against time, their distrust for each other & their powerful elders to unravel the mystery of the past before their future is destroyed.

So let me give you the semantics to this new style of novel (or episode) first so you get an idea of what exactly it is you are getting yourself into. Spellspinners (which is the title of this series) is an “Active Fiction” title, a new type of e-book from Coliloquy that actually runs like an app as apposed to a book (aka you can’t highlight passages or use the dictionary if you find yourself stumbling over a word.) In this particular Active Fiction series, your input influences future books from this author. (Like I said above…this is only episode 1) In Spellspinners, your input influences what happens to star-crossed lovers Logan & Lily.

Now, on to the actual story. (Cause that’s what we really care about right?!)

I really enjoyed it.

What? I can’t leave it at that? Dang. (Can’t fault a girl for trying.)

Normally I’d take this opportunity to go on and on (in exhausting detail) about the characters and their development in the story. Well phooey on that. I’m not gonna do it. In short they were great. Well establish. Nicely detailed and engaging. But that’s not what held my interest in “Witch’s Brew.” The story was. Yay story!! *throws confetti*

“Oh but Misty! This is a forbidden love story, how can it not be about the characters?”

Now, now…calm down. I didn’t say it wasn’t ABOUT the characters, I just don’t want to talk about them. I want to talk about the Hatfield and McCoy type fued between the Witches and the Warlocks. The witch apoclypse that seems to be lurking around the corner, and the creepy eel like things that have apparently lost all of their good sense.

There was action when I didn’t expect it. Deciet when there should have been desire and because of these I was enamored (aka I stayed up until 4am reading.) Which leads me to the characters. (Sorry…I just can’t help myself. It’s like a tick. *smacks head*)

For a story that was chocked full of love, lust and compassion it was suprisingly complex. We are introduced to a large cast; friends, mentors, family and foes, all of which have their own ups and downs, not just Logan and Lily (whom the story is centered around.) The inclusion of such a large cast (even though they aren’t narrative) adds a fullness to the story that I think was necessary to make it truly interesting. Without the influences of the supporting cast (anger from the Master Warlock, jealously from the local barista) the actions of the leads would have felt flat. Less forbidden and more straight forward.

Add this to the aforementioned plot points and what you get is a down right interesting read gosh darnit! (Holy crow, my Texas is showing.)

I was sad when I was left hanging.

I felt a connection to the characters and the excruciating trials they were facing.

And I loved that I got to go back and read it in a different light once I was done.

Overall…I really enjoyed it. (Hmmm… I think I’ve already said that once.)

Great for fans of YA and anything magical.

Happy reading my fellow Kindle-ites and remember: 2 for the price of 1 is always better!

[The Fairytale Nerd · Rating 3 out of 5]

Read full review at The Fairytale Nerd.

LOVE:
I like the way the history was completely laid down right at the beginning of the story for the reader's better understanding. I did appreciate the story better and enjoyed the book so much more because of this. I also loved the writing. Heidi Kling's writing is sensual and enticing. While the writing is lyrical, it is not difficult to read or overly flowery. And the world she created is just amazing. Magic and fantasy are beautifully tied up in this special book. Most of all, I love the STRONG connection and the SIZZLING chemistry between Logan and Lily. The reader will be able to feel the oozing hormones from these two. Plus, Logan can read Lily's mind. I just love stories with a mind reading element. It shows intimacy between the characters. Let me show you just how intimate and connected Logan and Lily are with this scene from the book:

Logan and I immediately stepped into each other’s orbit as if we were a planet and a moon with no other choice. Our arms were swinging together like two pendulums in sync. When my fingers accidentally grazed his, I felt his whole body–all tense energy–snap like a rubber band. Logan quickly stuffed his hands in his pockets, leaving me offended and nonsensically disappointed.
I stepped out of his orbit. I don’t like you, either.
“Untrue,” he said aloud with an eyebrow raised.
He was Reading me again.
“Well, I wish it were true.”
“No, you don’t. Remember, Lily”–he leaned into me–“I can Hear your every thought. Even when you try to block me.”
“No, you can’t.”
“Yes. I can.”

NO LOVE:
I LOVED every word, every sentence, but I do have one major complaint. I did not like the way the story ended. This book has one of the worst cliffhangers ever. The ending literally popped out of nowhere, and the story stopped just when things are getting really interesting and hot. Also, while I fully appreciate man chests, I don't see the point in Logan having to take off his shirt every now and then. Don't get me wrong, I'm NOT complaining! But I fail to see any logical connection between taking off one's shirt to hold hot things when you can grab something else.

FAVORITE CHARACTER:
I don't know. While I did like most, if not all of the characters, I feel that I haven't had the chance to get to know each one of them as much as I wanted to.

MUSINGS:
In this book, love is portrayed like a sugar rush. I especially loved the part where Logan and Lily were just being silly and enjoying each other's company and falling in love. I think that part was truly beautiful. The author captured the feeling of falling in love with someone, and I applaud her for weaving it to a story.

This is actually the first book with active content that I have read and it did not disappoint. For those who do not know, it's a choose your own story type of book. It used to be available only on Kindle in the US, but it can now be purchased in Google Play from Android devices and the Nook.

I really enjoyed Witch's brew. It's a very romantic witch-warlock story because it kind of has a paranormal Romeo and Juliet feel to it - opposing coven, and all that. But then again, I didn't like the ending. There was no resolution to anything at all. It's as if there were missing chapters at the end of the book. This really annoyed me. I would have to wait for the next installment to find out what happens to Lily and Logan.

Nevertheless, Witch's brew is an amazing read, not only because of its active content, but also with respect to the story. And it's wonderfully sexy! The readers will surely want, no... they will NEED more, especially after that annoying ending. I can't wait for the second installment!

[Lindsay · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars
Okay, so this actually turned out to be a remarkably sweet story. I was worried that there would be an insta-love connection (which nobody ever seems to enjoy), but instead there was more of an instant connection that invoked guilt and confusion. I loved the way the relationship was sparked, and was built on. Love is far from simple, and Kling showed this perfectly.

The main characters are likeable, and the villains are not, just as they should be. Not everyone can be categorized so easily though. I love when there are a few characters with ambiguous allegiance. Are they grouchy good guys, or do they have an ulterior motives? Are the bad guys actually bad, or are they just misunderstood? It makes me start to guess and second guess, which makes the journey so much more fun! I love not being able to figure the whole story out!

I was a little overwhelmed by the complex details in the beginning. First off, I had to work out how the magic works. All “witch” books are going to have their own spin to how magic works, so I made sure to take a few pages to get my feet under me. Then, there are the characters, and the backstory and history. Add to that the set up for the future of the series, and it’s a lot for a reader to absorb. Once I got my bearings, though, I really enjoyed this! The first time anyway… This brings me to the twist: you get to select your pathway through the story, through a series of links, to decide how the characters will get to the finish. I was curious to see how this would affect the ending, since there are sequels. How can you possibly read a second book, when you’re not even sure if you picked the right ending?! It is, however, just their path that you get to choose. The ending is stable when you finally get there.

While the “choose your own adventure” style is fun and quirky, I could have done without it. I felt compelled to read it again (because I can’t leave a book half read like that). My first pass over the book was actually much better than the second, the story coming together in a more solid way the first time. I felt like the chemistry between Lily and Logan was more heated and believable. A reader’s enjoyment could easily differ depending on what choices they make for the story. It also makes it near impossible for me to give a rating to it. I can definitely recommend it though, if you’re in the mood for a light, PNR. I look forward to seeing where the story takes me in The Gleaning!

A copy of this book was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

[Alex Bennett]

Review from Electrifying Reviews: http://www.electrifyingreviews.com/20...

Surprisingly, Witch’s Brew is the only book by Heidi R. Kling that I’ve read. Now, I know she only has two, but when her first book, Sea, came out, I heard nothing but good things about it. Judging by the love that book had gotten, I knew I was probably going to like Witch’s Brew. I’m happy to say that I judged correctly.

I love books about witches, and Witch’s Brew had everything I was looking for. It’s just so… magical, yet it doesn’t seem out of place. The characters’ whole lives are consumed by their magic, and I loved reading about the way Kling wrote her witches. Everything about her mythology and history of her witches was brilliant, and I can’t wait to find out more about them in future Spellspinners of Melas County books.

I had heard that Heidi R. Kling was a great writer, but I was so not expecting her to be this good! Her writing has such a… not to be redundant, but magical quality to it. It’s almost as if you’re getting the same experience as when you listen to a beautiful song. If that makes sense. Her words flow naturally, and I am extremely excited to read more from her.

Lily and Logan were great protagonists. Both do what they believe in, even if that means defying everything they’ve ever known. The dichotomy between the two of them fits so well together, even throughout all of the ups and downs in their relationship. The supporting characters were all so well written, and they really help the story. I felt like I could connect to almost every character in Witch’s Brew.

Another awesome thing about Witch’s Brew is the choices! As Witch’s Brew is sold exclusively in the Kindle store, the ebook experience allows you to choose different paths as the story goes along. I read all of the paths available, and got to read a different—still awesome—story each time.

If you have a Kindle, do yourself a favor and buy Witch’s Brew. If you don’t have one, buy one and then buy Witch’s Brew. I took a leap of faith on this book—actually getting myself a Kindle mainly so I could read it, and I was not disappointed.

[Bookish Satty · Rating 5 out of 5]

I got this book from the author, free of cost, in exchange of an honest review from my side.

Firstly I would like to thank Heidi R. Kling, author of Witch's Brew for giving me this opportunity of reading and reviewing this fabulous book.

Whoa! What a great start of an awesome series! I totally loved it! The author really did a remarkable job in writing this book and it's a treat for readers like us and even made the day for me. One of the best witch related book I've ever read and let me tell you that I read quite a lot of books.

A totally unique writing style which is interactive and the readers can choose the path in which the story will move, isn't that great? Well of course it is. The writing style of the author is remarkably just genius with skilled use of words which made the read more and more intriguing.

Forbidden love and the fight against all odds to have your love, yup folks the story is as awesome as you can expect it to be. The author put in it all the spices that make up a great meal and this is not less than any grand festive meal.

There is the pure essence of true love, the heart felt struggle between years of belief and the need of your heart, your soul mate! The whole concept is great without a totally refreshing story line and a well thought out plot where the fully developed characters just fit perfectly.

The quest of Lily and Logan in finding the answers about their true love and going against their own people for saving their love. Full of power-packed action, emotional breakdown, test of true love, soul touching romance, all in one which is presented to you by the author.

Lily is superb and charming with a confident and curious attitude and we have sexy and hot Logan who happens to be warlock, a high pitched whistle over here! Loved their chemistry and over all the dedication of them towards their love.

A must read for ya all and a total page turner and a new take on the fantasy world, fully recommended read which you won't be putting down without completing. Get on the ride, guys!

[Lara · Rating 4 out of 5]

I have to admit that fantasy is not usually my favourite genre, however this book intrigued me from the start. Witch's Brew is the story of Lily, a witch and Logan, a warlock. Throughout their lives, they have been prepared for 'The Gleaning', a magical combat between witches and warlocks necessary for their covens to keep the balance in their magical powers. When they meet, they know that they are supposed to be enemies but cannot help develop feelings for each other, even though this is prohibited.

This book changes point of views between Logan and Lily, which I really liked since it helped show what they were feeling towards each other throughout the whole story. I loved the moments these two characters had between them and I wish that there was time to get to know these characters more. One other great thing about this book is the fact that certain places it lets you choose what you want to happen. This was something which I had never seen in a book and for me it was a really nice surprise which really made this book stand out.

The only negative thing I can say about this book is the fact that the ending came very abruptly and the book seemed to end mid-scene. For me Heidi R. Kling is a new author and this certainly won't be the last book of hers I will be reading.

[Sara Heacox · Rating 5 out of 5]

First of all, I love the action fiction format. When the page came up when I had to choose, I really didn’t know what I wanted to do. And then the entire time I was reading, I kept wondering how my choice affected the story. I had to contain myself from flipping back through to change my choice. I have already gone back and read it again, changing my choices to see how the story will change.

I really like the world that Heidi created. The idea of witch’s and warlock being enemies is really great! Not only that, but you add the everyday dilemmas of being a teenager and you have a great story. I have a new book crush on Logan and Lily is a great heroine. My only problem is that I now have to wait for the next scene to come out!

If you have a Kindle (or even if you don’t) you definitely need to download this title!

*Original review on Eve's Fan Garden (http://evesfangarden.com/blog/2012/01...)

[zapkode · Rating 5 out of 5]

{my thoughts} - This book is about Lily and Logan. Lily is a witch teenager and Logan is a warlock teenager. Both teenagers are forced to decide with what they have been taught to believe in to be right. Which is that each other is each other's enemy. And what their hearts are trying to tell them is right. It's a different kind of book then I have ever read before because it's a choose your own path {adventure} book. It gives you choices at various points within the book and you choose where to go from there. Over all it was a good read and I really enjoyed it. I cannot wait to read book number two! I am dying to find out what they both are going to choose!

{reason for reading} - I was contacted and told that it was free to download through Amazon. So of coarse, since I had it on my to be read list I downloaded it. And I don't regret it one bit.

[Viv Ross · Rating 5 out of 5]

I have seen the "choose an action/option" applied in many books for learning purposes, but I cannot say that I've ever seen it in a leisure book until now. I love it! This trait gives the reader a sense of power, of involvement, and makes this storyline even more appealing than it already is.

I read through each storlyine because I'm that kind of person that will pick door number 1 but still want to at least know what's behind door number 2. For me it did not detract from the book in the least but for others this may not be the best option to pursue.

I thoroughly enjoy the dynamics between Lily, Orchid, Logan, and Chase. I'm especially intrigued by the amulets and certain other objects. My suspicions have been aroused concerning certain other characters and I cannot wait to see what happens next!

[Amy · Rating 4 out of 5]

This review originally appeared here

I’ve been waiting for WITCH’S BREW to come out for what seems like forever. It sounded like all of the things I love to read: witches, warlocks, prophesies, a magic-pocalypse. Also, I was SUPER intrigued by its author-appointed nickname, #sexahmagicbook. Umm…YES PLEASE. And then when I found out that this book was not only totally up my alley plot-wise, but that it was also a new kind of ebook where the reader could choose the path the story would take, I became VERY EAGER to read it. The whole package just sounded so new and awesome, and it was. It was a little different than I thought it would be, but I really enjoyed it. Which is a good thing, cause this is only the first book of TEN. (That sounds more daunting than it really is, I think. The book wasn’t overly long, and it moved at a good pace, too.)

WITCH’S BREW was really fun and fast-paced, and the sexytimes parts were good. I loved the magic, I loved the mythology, and I loved the relationship. And throw a prophecy at me, and I’m pretty much putty in an author’s hands. On occasion, though things felt like they could have been a little smoother (there were few times when important/biggish things happen a little abruptly), but this could have just been a function of the changing perspectives and the different story paths, which are mostly the same, but still plenty different. I will say, though, that I liked one of the paths I chose a little better than the other (I read through it twice) simply because it felt a little more fluid, and the progression of things felt a little more natural. They both had their positives, though, and I would definitely recommend going back and making some new choices after you finish the first run-through. The good from reading them both? You learn more about the mythology and the characters. In fact, I found that there were some things from my second read-through that wouldn’t have made sense if I hadn’t read the book the way I had the first time. PLUS, you get to spend more time with Lily and Logan, who have this great connection that sparks and gives MAJOR tingles. Woot! The bad (if you want to call it that)? You’re essentially rereading the same book over. Essentially. The major points are the same, they just arrive at each one differently. SO worth it, though.

Also, because I’m a nerd about details–especially witchy ones! I LOVE witchy details–there were some things that I wished were explained a little bit more. For instance, there are totem animals. But I’m not sure if all witches and all warlocks have the same animal, or if it’s different with each person. Also, Logan’s tattoos. Do all warlock’s have them, or is it just him? I think it was mentioned that they were a warlock thing, but no other warlock was actually shown to have them. Good thing we have lots of books left to get our fill of magical geekery, though!

But the actual story of WITCH’S BREW was intriguing, with lots of meaty things in the air. The prophecy and the curse that will affect both the witches and the warlocks is obviously the big one. But there’s the whole issue of the funny business that Jacob’s, the head warlock, company is getting up to (because OBVIOUSLY it’s not kosher). There’s DEFINITELY something going on with Lily’s mom, Iris. And Jonah, the barista from the Witch’s Brew coffee shop? I have a theory about him, but I’m going to keep it to myself so that I don’t get TOO embarrassed when it turns out to be wrong. Of course, though, the relationship between Lily and Logan is huge as well, fraught as it is with DANGER and the potential for sexytimes. HOLLA!

I’m definitely excited to keep reading The Spellspinners of Melas County. (Also, I only recently realized that “Melas” is “Salem” spelled backward. Who’s a smarty pants? THIS GIRL.) There’s a lot introduced here, and I’m eager to see where it all goes. I LOVE witches, especially the witches here, who have heaps of Celtic magic overtones. Lily and Logan are apparently Meant To Be, which gives me some cringes, but I like that they’re connection is something that they can neither ignore nor understand. It’s intense. And Logan is almost instantly crush-worthy. I predict that this series is going to get bananas in a really great way, and I can’t wait to keep reading!

Quick Thoughts
Very good, and very cool as well. Going back to read the other choice now! Review to come!

[Angela · Rating 4 out of 5]

First off, this the first book that I have read on my iPod touch/iPad and to be honest, it is not like having a physical book in my hands, but the book was entertaining enough in itself that I was not bothered by this and had a very easy time reading the book. Secondly, this is the frist book that I have read where I was in charge of choosing how the book unfolded. So the development of the story and characters was influenced by the decision that I made. At first I wasn't sure how I felt about that; I use books as my escape and as a nice way to not have to make decision on things that are already predetermined for me by the author, this put a new twist on that. Seriously, now that I have finished the book, I really loved this idea. Very different for a book and I think it will be a very attractive idea for younger readers. However that being said, I as a reader have this insatiable curiosity and need to know every aspect of the characters that I fall in love with, that I couldn't help myself from reading the book one way and then going back and reading it the other/different way. I like to have to full picture. So far in the series, it seemed like regardless of which way you choose, you still got to the same ending. So you have to ask yourself, do I want more mystery and drama or a more detailed love story and entanglements? I thought that in reading the story twice with both pathways, I finally felt like I had the full story. In reading the pathways separately, sometimes it felt as though the writing and events occurred in an abrupt manner, and I would re-read parts of a chapter only to find things to still be a little disjointed.

This is really a perfect series for me to fall in love with. At first I thought that this was another forbidden love trying to beat the odds romance, but I was pleasantly surprised because here I am still wondering about the book, its characters, and the plot. I really enjoyed this bool. I love books with strong characters and flowing, well developed story lines. I can happily say that I have found that here. There is that instand connection with Lilly and Logan that was really described well and was rather alluring. This connection is intese and I like that there is a whole series in which we will be able to watch Lilly and Logan grow as individual characters and how they are affected by and undergo the process of understanding their bond. However, I feel like a lot of the characters introduced in this book are going to be playing more of a role than is initially expected at the beginning of the book. All those characters that we are introduced to can not just be filler characters to drive the story, there just seems to be too many layers within the plot for them to all be superficial. I enjoyed the plot and it will be interesting to see how everything unravels and plays out. I like the concept of witches and warlocks, prophesies, feuds, secrets, magic, and romance...what more could a girl ask for?

Obviously with this being a series, there are still a lot of questions to be answered; i.e. what is going on with creepy Jacob and his private business? Do the warlocks even know about the curse? What does Logan's ink mean? Why does Logan's amulet react with Lilly and Lilly's amulet react to Logan? And the totem animals, they are scattered throughout the story, but what the heck do they mean and how do they play a role in this story? How does the past affect the future? Seriously, what is going to happen next? Why did the book have to end on such a cliff hanger?

All in all, I loved the book. The ideas were fresh, and the writing was easy to read. I loved the book and I am so glad that I was given the opportunity to read it (thank you again)! I can not wait for the second book!

On a formatting note ( an this is just personal option, so do with it as you please): I found that when I was reading the conversations between Logan and Lilly in their heads, there were a few times when I had a hard time distinguishing between what they were saying to each other and what was just a mental reflection. It just seemed like there were a few times that things were supposed to be italicized and weren't and it either caught me off guard or confused me slightly. It only happened once or twice, but I did notice it and wanted to just say a quick blurb, then again, my mind could just be stubborn and not let me read things the way they are written and I apologize. Regardless, it didn't take anything away from the book and I still loved it!

[Lynne · Rating 4 out of 5]

First of all: That COVER!!! OMG, I *HEART* it!!!

WITCH'S BREW is a modern story about a clan of warlocks and a coven of witches who have been living under a shared curse for nearly 100 years. According to their folklore, they must figure out how the break the curse, before the century mark, or risk losing their magic forever.

This is the first book of The Spellspinners of Melas County trilogy. Witch's Brew focuses on introducing us to the main characters, Lily and Logan, giving us mysterious glimpses of their background stories and explaining the somewhat tragic circumstances between the two groups. There's far more to it, but to be only sort of spoilery, basically they are under a curse that has prevented the warlocks and witches from being able to have anything to do with one another - the only exception is that on the winter/spring solstices the witches and warlocks *must* meet together in a sacred place called the Solstice Stones - they must battle in order to glean energy from one another.

The thing the with this series is that there are a couple points in the book/s where the reader gets to pick which direction the story should go in (A or B). In WITCH'S BREW, I decided to chose only the 'A' option/s for the first go through. I quickly realized that I would have to read this book more than once to see what differences the other choices make in the story.
Besides being a well written story and interesting all by itself, this was such an interesting reading experience because I've never read an adventure-type book (altho according to my husband - and what he grew up with, he says a 'proper' make-your-own adventure book should have way more choices scattered throughout the story). Being my first taste, I was okay with the options this book gives. I didn't understand what it meant at first because honestly, when I first spotted this book over a year ago, I was a little annoyed that it was only available online, but after reading it, I understand why this series needs to be digital (I purchased this ebook at amazon)

I did read this book the second time choosing only the #2 options each time. This storyline is basically the same story, but told from a different point of view and you learn more about the characters.
I think I slightly prefer the 2nd read through since the author seems to chill a bit on the romancey part (it's a trilogy, so there's plenty of time for the MC's to fall in love and whatnot!). Also, I'm not sure if I 'need' to reread twice more to do A/B and B/A mixes - as opposed to just the A's and then just the B's.
I found with reading just the A options and then just the B options that even though the paths are somewhat different, both choices eventually get us to the same cliff hanger ending. This book ends just before the next upcoming solstice battle - which sets us up nicely for THE GLEANING, book #2 in the trilogy.
Both times I read this, the story sucked me in from the beginning. I am so curious now with the intriguing glimpses we saw of these characters' back stories and I wonder how they will be connected later on in the story and with other things being alluded to throughout the book I really can't wait to see what happens in the sequel/s.

Since there are some slightly romancey bits, I would recommend this book to ages 14 and up. I think teen girls will easily relate to the angst of the teen-aged main characters and everyone, teens or adults will really enjoy the story .... no matter which options are chosen. This is such a seriously neat concept for a YA fantasy genre book!

Very excited! I won an ecopy of THE GLEANING from evesfangarden.com and coliloquy.com - so I have it loaded on my Nook and will be reading/reviewing very soon. :) Since it was frequently referred to, I'm reeeally looking forward to seeing what actually happens on the battlefield.

[Stephanie (Gorelenore) Cover2CoverBlog · Rating 4 out of 5]

I have owned Witch's Brew for a long time, I got it as a Kindle deal and it has sat on my reader forever, I just never had a chance to read it with other blog tours and books that I was reading. I was given the chance to be on the Spellspinner's tour and was thrilled because now I could read the book that I had been wanting to for some time now AND I was getting the other 2 books in the series as well!

First thing to note is that the Spellspinners books (as stated above) are "Active Fiction" i.e. remember those choose your own adventure books some of us read as kids, well it is kind of like that, only regardless of how you choose you come to the same end, the only difference between the choices is that you get ore of less detail depending on your tastes. SO if you want action ALL THE TIME you can skip over the more informational bits and learn about those thing later in the story, or if you want to know ALL the details, you can read it in that way . I chose both styles depending on where I was in the story, so it was a lot of fun.

Book one begins our introduction into the world of Spellspinners aka witches and warlocks and how they became divided and enemies 100 years prior, not there is a prophecy that may or may not help to reunite them if they can get past their differences.

I really enjoyed this book, but it at times let me asking strange questions, like who the heck people were, there were a lot of flower names, names that start with J and then Lily and Logan (the two L's as I started referring to them as) are the main characters. I also wanted to know more about how the Spinners came to be, and you get more and more of that as you read the other books, but I wanted am overview in book one and it was not really there.

Here Lily and Logan meet, and it is forbidden but also very mysterious and alluring. We learn about some of the background of their worlds and I loved how the book alternated back and forth between their POVs -- small issue though was that when they alternate it is sometimes a reply of what just happened but from the other's POV.

Overall it was a good read, but it took a few chapters to get into the style of the book and writing.

[Ornella · Rating 4 out of 5]

WHATTTTT!! WHYYYY?? would you end it like that?!

I like reading books with witches but I don't really go looking for them. So glad I stumbled upon this one. Really liked the magic aspect, the conflict between the warlocks and the witched, their history and their politics. I really liked how *easy* the magic actually was, none that weird crap about how magic is so awesome, but then you use it and poof you are done, like a one-time magical wonder. It kind of reminded me of the T.V show Sabrina in respects to the use and ease of magic.

Loved all the characters, even the evil-witch Caemillia (cause I just that ending had written her all over it) and the villan Jacob who is seriously creepy and disgusting. Then there is the bubbly Daisy, and the frenemy Orchid, because honestly she has yet to inspire actual trust. Speaking of which, also don't trust cotton candy haired Jonah, there is just something about him that isn't right. I loved the interactions between Lily and Daisy, and Lily and Logan, super-hot Logan *sigh*. I definitely approve of how the romance is developing, it's obvious they like each other but they are still holding back, like they should be.

What I wasn't so keen about was the choosing how the story went. It really upset me, mostly cause I felt like I was going to miss something at the time it felt like a really big decision about how the story would go and I really just don't like to choose D:

But all in all, anyone who even remotely likes stories about witches, this is a definite must!

[Jeanne 'Divinae' · Rating 3 out of 5]

Overall, I liked this first book in this series. I read it on my kindle and it gave you options to continue the storyline one way or another. To my dismay, it wouldn't work correctly on the first choice. It would only let me choose one way(not the option I wanted to go with). But besides that, it was a very quick and fun read. I can't wait to read the next book in the series. In fact, I'd give it 4 stars if there wasn't that flaw of picking the first choice.

Pretty much Warlocks and Witches are 'sworn' enemies. Or so that is what the younger generation is brought up and taught. Lily,a witch, has been a little different since she was little, she has the ability to 'breath'. It is approaching the time of the "gleaning" where warlocks and witches faceoff. They aren't told exactly will happen, and there are all sorts of rumors flying around about what REALLY happens. Lily bends and breaks a few rules. She finds out a truth, their is a curse.

She ends up meeting a warlock named Logan. Logan and her have a special connection. Perhaps a connection that could save not just themselves, but everyone. Sadly, there are person(s) out to get them. I am looking forward to see how things play out for the two of them.

All I have to say is, they better not end up being related. I like the idea of soulmates and that instinct sizzling connection that Lily and Logan feel for each other.

[Dania · Rating 4 out of 5]

I won this book through the Goodreads Firstread program, my review is my honest thoughts on this book.

At first when I found it in the mail, I thought that there won't be anything substantial in it because it only had 179 pages and from what I had experienced writers need at least 300 pages to capture my interest. Boy, was I wrong.

What I didn't bargain on was how quickly I was drawn into the story. The whole witches against wizards gave it a new angle that is quite original. The story has plenty of suspense. And the mystery factor is paced creatively. You find out stuff in small dosages and its scattered across the text, you don't get a mouthful of the mystery solved in one go, which I think is a plus.

Lily and Logan's relationship is complex. They are both trying to fight against their held beliefs about who their enemy is exactly. What I liked most about this book is that you get both their points of view, so you get to experience both of these individuals' motives.

The only thing which I didn't like about the book is when Lily [spoiler] enchanted Orchid to fall in love with Chance, that really wasn't cool to take away her will like that [end spoiler].

I can't believe Kling left off that humongous cliff hanger at the end. WTF?! How long do I have to wait until the next book comes out? I want to know who that was so bad.

[Susan · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a like the old "choose your own adventure" books that I loved as a kid. Part way through there is a choice of actions and then another choice later on. I couldn't not read the whole book, so after I finished with one set of choices I went back and read through the other options. I really enjoyed the story with my choices the first time through. I felt a little lost at first, like maybe there was a previous book in the series that I hadn't read (there isn't), but I soon caught up on the story and characters. I liked the tension between Lily and Logan and the development of their relationship. When I finished the book and the cliffhanger ending I actually howled in frustration! I really want to know what happens next!
When I went through the story with the second set of choices I did not have nearly as good of an experience. It was clear from these choices that Logan was going to be more distant and aggressive and this is true for the storyline that develops from them. I did not like him at all! I guess it makes sense that the choices that I picked would lead to a better story for me personally. It does seem kind of strange that not everyone who reads this book will get the same storyline. I think that this book could have been just fine without these options and I am not sure that they add anything to the story.

[Lanae · Rating 3 out of 5]

I have a couple of issues with this book -
- some of the dialogue just doesn't flow well.
- the flowery names, it's part of the whole witchy thing but there's not enough character development to distinguish the girls as it is, add in similar themed names and I found myself thinking "wait is that the sister or the best friend" once or twice.
- it's a cliffhanger without any sense of a completed adventure here (you're buying this book as a stepping stone to the real action)
- the inevitable love triangle didn't feel at all warranted. It existed for no reason.

Now for the good:
- the story of the witches and warlocks is a good one, with some edits it could be great

Neutral:
The choose your own adventure style book. On the one hand it's charming, lets you feel you're affecting the story, nostalgic for those books in your childhood. On the other hand it doesn't add much to the book and simply distracts you from how short and unfinished this book feels.

Onto the next as I do want to see what happens, but if something doesn't pick up drastically there, I'll be bumping the priority way down on this series, if not ditching it.

* Disclaimer: I received this book at no cost in order to review it. I offered no guarantee of a positive review, though I only request books I think I'll like because why read a book you think you’ll hate?

[Jessica (Books: A true story) · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book felt like Harry Potter goes YA. I found some similarities to Harry Potter like the term "You Know Who," and a a restricted library. I liked the magic. Women, or witch's, magic involves beauty, flowers, healing and nature. The men, or warlocks, are their enemies and have "opposite" powers though it doesn't go into a lot of detail what those powers are. It mentions mind reading powers and potions. The kind of stuff Snape would like. The conflict of having men and women being enemies from a curse was pretty cool. This isn't an average ebook - it has choices in it. It's not quite like choose your own adventure because the story line will end up in the same place. There are two choices in the story and when I went back and read the other choice, they eventually meet up at the same place in the story but it flesh's out the characters and their relationships a little more. If I were reading this again, I would probably read both choices and then move on. The characters were okay. They didn't seem very fleshed out, but they didn't bother me either. My favorite part of this book was the really cool conflict and the background behind it. Can't wait to read the next one. Or you could call it Romeo + Juliet meets witches and magic.

[Wendy · Rating 4 out of 5]

I found Witch's Brew to be a light-hearted, romantic story of 2 teenagers struggling between their growing attraction and their sense of duty to their "families". Ms. Kling puts a new spin on a classic story line by adding the mystical and magical levels to the struggle.

Ms. Kling adds another twist that allows the reader to decide the path of the story. I finished the book, having selected one option and now plan to re-read the book, selecting the other option. I am looking forward to seeing how she has developed the other story line.

The only negative I have about the book (and I'm sure it's not a negative from Ms. Kling's perspective) is that it leaves me wanting more. I am looking forward to reading the next book in the series to see how Lily and Logan's relationship develops.