I want to preface this review by saying, I'm likely one of the biggest mega fans of Fallout you're likely to ever meet. I've played and beaten Fallout, Fallout 2, Fallout 3, Fallout New Vegas (my favorite), Fallout 4 and Fallout Tactics, as well as having played Fallout 76, Fallout Shelter and Fallout Brotherhood of Steel. Additionally, I've seen every episode currently out for the Fallout 2024 TV series and the old web series Fallout Nuka Break. My depth of love and knowledge for this franchise is massive.
And because of that, Fallout New Vegas All Roads was a bit of a letdown for me. Not because it was poorly written or the art was bad, because honestly, neither of those things is remotely true. It let me down because it was supposed to act as a prelude to the game itself, setting up Benny as a character and establishing his history and personal motives, and it did that, but it spent equal, if not more time, fleshing out this character named Chase, a Great Khan who's hooked on chems and undergoing flashbacks to the massacre of Bitter Springs. My question is, why? The character was and remains a nothing of a character with no significance, and while Benny talking to him did give us some exposition and a look into Benny's past, there are other, better ways to do so, than to introduce a nobody character who doesn't speak a single line of dialogue, just to be monologued to.
The characterization of Benny is great and pretty spot on to the version given to us in the game itself, which is honestly a treat, and the art was top notch in my opinion. It was beautifully drawn, and I wish we got more Fallout comics honestly, because I would love to see the Fallout universe expanded on, in either graphic or prose novel form.
Despite what I loved about it, however, this comic didn't really do much to justify existing. The game already establishes quite clearly 90% of what this book relays to us, so as beautiful as it may be, we don't really learn much from it. It's fun, it's cute, but it's a novelty and ultimately skippable. It's not bad by any means, but it's not needed. The very definition of a 2.5 out of 5. Directly in the middle, doing little to justify its existence, but also doesn't need to be erased either.