Memorable characters despite some writing flaws
Warning: This review might contain what some people consider SPOILERS.
Rating: 8/10
PROS:
- There’s an excellent portrayal here of a veteran with both physical and emotional scars. I know very little about PTSD (Post-Traumatic Stress Syndrome), but Sean seems like a very good depiction of it. He says after a panic attack at one point, “It scares me to think all I’ll ever be able to do is fake being civilized.”
- I love the main characters. They’re atypical romance-novel protagonists--almost antiheroes in a way: they’re damaged and poor, yet still they’re happy.
- The guys’ initial impressions of each other are frank--sympathetic, but not pitying--and that bluntness colors their entire relationship. They don’t tread lightly around each other’s disabilities. It’s refreshing (and sometimes a little shocking) how direct they are with each other.
- I got a good sense of the guys’ emotional connection. They’re incredibly sweet to each other, understanding of each other’s flaws and limitations, and they’re just easy together. They banter and are supremely comfortable in each other’s company.
CONS:
- The last several chapters are markedly different from the rest of the story, and I didn’t think there was a good transition between the 2 parts. Most of the book is somber and dramatic, and then the ending is syrupy sweet and seems at odds with the seriousness of the rest of the story.
- I really wanted to see some scenes from Gabe’s POV. The author does a great job of exploring the psychological difficulties of living with Sean’s problems, and I wanted to see the same from Gabe, especially since his disability is so unusual yet he’s remarkably chipper about it. We see external proof of Gabe’s human fragility (quivering voice, shaking hands, etc.), but I wanted to see inside his head.
- There’s a decent amount of sex here, but it’s not the focus of the story. Still, I must admit to being VERY upset about not getting to see Sean bottom for the first time. The characters make a pretty big deal about it: Sean keeps telling Gabe he’s not ready yet but will be eventually, and Gabe’s super understanding, and then when Sean decides he’s ready, Gabe’s excited but still gentle and soothing--“you’re gonna’ love it, I’ll make it good,” etc.--and then…fade to black and the story jumps ahead by 2 weeks.
- The book contains a lot of dialogue, which I think is mostly a good thing since that’s what made me really believe in the guys’ connection. But occasionally their conversations were a little hard for me to follow. They talk about quite a few things I have no knowledge of, like paganism and particular cult movies, and they left me in the dust more than once.
Overall comments: Despite some flaws, I think this book is worth reading if you’re looking for a story about memorable characters. This is a great example of a book in which the characters’ problems still exist at the end but their relationship enables them to better handle those problems.