The Trouble With Resurrection: From Paul to the Fourth Gospel

by Bernard Brandon Scott

The term resurrection has come to stand for what Christianity is all about. But a close look reveals that it should not be understood monolithically, but rather as a pluralistic and diverse phenomenon. Early Christian communities were convinced that Rome had not defeated Jesus when they crucified him. They employed a whole host of metaphors to express that conviction. The use of the single term resurrection to cover the phenomenon is a mistake-one that has tyrannized Christianity. Furthermore, most Christians believe in a physical resurrection, although Paul clearly calls this into question. Once that tradition became fixed, it provided the lens through which everything else was viewed-and distorted. The purpose of this book is not to say whether Jesus arose from the grave on the third day, or whether such an event is impossible. Rather, by examining the so-called resurrection stories in chronological order, it aspires to prompt readers to consider questions such as; what does the New Testament really say about the resurrection; what is the influence of Judaism on Christian belief in the resurrection; how did the resurrection become the central belief in Christianity; why did early Christians choose to believe in the resurrection; and why is resurrection not the right word.

Genres: Theology, Biblical Studies, Religion

251 pages, Paperback

First published November 1, 2010

Reviews

[Tanja Walker · Rating 4 out of 5]

I was in Brandon Scott's class on this topic before the book was published. Got a lot out of both. My takeaway is this: the bottom line on the Resurrection of Jesus is not so much what are the facts behind it, but what does it mean for us to say Jesus was resurrected.

[Troy · Rating 5 out of 5]

WOW! There is not a more important book out there for getting an understanding of the many different ways resurrection is seen throughout the Bible (and other contemporary books in Bible times). It covers them all in GREAT detail.

WOW! This is not an easy read. It is a scholarly work that can kind of trudge along at times. HOWEVER, the last chapter, where he sums it up and applies it to life is worthwhile and very inspiring. In addition, the Cameos (blocks of additional information) along the way are very helpful.

I had a copy of this book but have lost it. Did I loan it to you? If so, I'd love to have it back!

[Brian Hamilton · Rating 5 out of 5]

A great read to understanding the difficult concept of Resurrection. What I learned is not what kind of resurrection Christ experienced; whether it was physical or metaphorical. What is important is the understanding of what resurrection means to me as a child of God. Because Jesus was resurrected; I too will be resurrected in death.

[Craig Bergland · Rating 5 out of 5]

A compelling look at the meaning of and biblical evidence for what is meany by resurrection. This isn't light reading, as the author tells us it's a scholarly work for a popular audience. There were times when I had to stop to consider what the author was saying before carrying on, but to me that is a sign of a thought provoking book. In the end, he raises the important question of understanding what resurrection really means in our lives and in our world. Simply an excellent book for anyone interested in serious engaging the resurrection in a scholarly manner.

[F · Rating 3 out of 5]

A bit unclear and disorganized.