5+ stars & 7/10 hearts. What a darling little story this is… just so sweet and fresh and relaxing! And still crammed full of excellent advice!
This book is set in late-1880s America and is evidently a protest from Alcott on the popular way of raising girls, and her suggestion of how to actually raise them. It’s fascinating from a historical point of view, giving a great glimpse of what things were like in Alcott’s time; and a lot of what it says still stands true today, and is great inspiration for young women or their parents. ;) From a writing standpoint, it’s tighter and better written than Little Women, yet just as homey, heartwarming, and old-timey.
The plot is delightful. Pretty much just a slice-of-life, everyday story, with awesome characters, and a slew of great reminders and messages. The humour is excellent! I love the Scottish heritage, and the lovely family reunions. And the characters really make the story. Sweet Rose, with her desire to be a good woman and use her life well. <3 Phebe, so brave and strong and humble. Dr. Alec, such a great father-figure and uncle. The aunts were all excellent figures—either encouraging or warning. Aunt Jessie is such a wonderful mother; Aunt Plenty & Aunt Peace are both wonderful; Aunt Jane, Aunt Clara, and Aunt Myra are all warnings in their own way. And the boys! They’re all so funny and real. Archie, of course, is my favourite—kind, dependable, responsible, gentlemanly Archie. Charlie is such a fascinating boy and yet so sad, such a warning. Mac is a dear, and so admirable. The other boys are all funny and sweet in their own ways. And every other side character is living and vibrant. I love the relationships so much. Archie & Charlie are such a pair, and Charlie + Rose’s sweet, cousinly friendship is beautiful. I love seeing how the boys & girls teamed up to help each other fight their failings and develop their strengths. It was a wonderful reminder.
Overall, this is an excellent book for girls of all ages to read, and I quite recommend it <3
A Favourite Quote: “But as a wise old fellow once said, ‘It is necessary to do right; it is not necessary to be happy.’”
A Favourite Humorous Quote: “‘Now I shall preach a short sermon[.] Jack can't always drive[,] and Willie may as well make up his mind to let Marion build her house by his, for she will do it, and he needn't fuss about it. Jamie seems to be a good boy, but I shall preach to him if he isn't[.]. Now you must all remember what I tell you, because I'm the captain, and you should mind me.’
“Here Lieutenant Jack spoke right out in meeting with the rebellious remark,—"Don't care if you are; you'd better mind yourself, and tell how you ... kept the biggest doughnut, and didn't draw fair when we had the truck.’
“‘Yes, and you slapped Frank; I saw you,’ bawled Willie Snow, bobbing up in his pew....
“‘I shan't build my house by Willie's if he don't want me to, so now!" put in little Marion, joining the mutiny....
“Captain Dove looked rather taken aback at this outbreak in the ranks; but, being a dignified and calm personage, he quelled the rising rebellion with great tact and skill by saying, briefly,—‘We will sing the last hymn ... and then we will go and have luncheon.’”
Content: Some mentions of drinking, smoking, & gambling (all condemned except for a toast at Christmas by adults). May contain some euphemisms; a few mentions of saints & gods/goddesses.