What do you think?
Rate this book
Exceptional C++: 47 Engineering Puzzles, Programming Problems, and Solutions
The puzzles and problems in Exceptional C++ not only entertain, they will help you hone your skills to become the sharpest C++ programmer you can be. Many of these problems are culled from the famous Guru of the Week feature of the Internet newsgroup comp.lang.c++, moderated, expanded and updated to conform to the official ISO/ANSI C++ Standard.
Try your skills against the C++ masters and come away with the insight and experience to create more efficient, effective, robust, and portable C++ code.
Try your skills against the C++ masters and come away with the insight and experience to create more efficient, effective, robust, and portable C++ code.
208 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1999
16 people are currently reading
496 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
August 3, 2016
It should be 5 stars because of the quality of the content, but unfortunately this book hasn't been updated for modern C++.
Exceptional C++ honours its name and has great pieces of advice. Some parts, like advanced memory management, are quite tricky, and will require me a second read. Others, like the use of the Pimpl idiom, what to add into an interface, name resolution, and how to write exception-safe code are useful from the first time.
Another great book, fully recommended!
Exceptional C++ honours its name and has great pieces of advice. Some parts, like advanced memory management, are quite tricky, and will require me a second read. Others, like the use of the Pimpl idiom, what to add into an interface, name resolution, and how to write exception-safe code are useful from the first time.
Another great book, fully recommended!
July 9, 2008
This series is really good and brings to light a lot of C++ related issues people need to be aware of.
It also makes you realize, though, how much C++ is your enemy. How you have to fight the language to get stuff done. You may be at a point in your journey where you have become numb to this fact. But then reading this series you think about:
1. The Pimpl idiom, a huge mess of a method to get boxed objects (invisible and automatic in every language of the last 20 years)
2. Slicing, something you have to constantly watch out for in C++ (a complete nonissue in other languages)
3. how basically every component of the C++ standard library except the STL is poorly designed
4. Ridiculous template error messages
5. components of the C++ standard that are almost universally unimplemented and considered stupid (export...)
6. how incredibly primitive is textual inclusion of header files? It's like this is 1965 or something.
7. And C-style macros! Wow.
8. Manual memory management. Oh, wait, now there's shared_ptr! The C++ community has reinvented reference counting garbage collection, only 50 years behind schedule. Oh, and you have to manually write crap for the things you want collected and deal with their interaction with manually collected stuff.
9. The absurd hoops you have to jump through to simulate things like nested functions.
10. Incompatible compilers and library implementations.
And on and on.
Now like I said if you write C++ you are dealing with at least some of these issues all the time, but maybe you have become numb. These books will remind you.
I just don't get it.
It also makes you realize, though, how much C++ is your enemy. How you have to fight the language to get stuff done. You may be at a point in your journey where you have become numb to this fact. But then reading this series you think about:
1. The Pimpl idiom, a huge mess of a method to get boxed objects (invisible and automatic in every language of the last 20 years)
2. Slicing, something you have to constantly watch out for in C++ (a complete nonissue in other languages)
3. how basically every component of the C++ standard library except the STL is poorly designed
4. Ridiculous template error messages
5. components of the C++ standard that are almost universally unimplemented and considered stupid (export...)
6. how incredibly primitive is textual inclusion of header files? It's like this is 1965 or something.
7. And C-style macros! Wow.
8. Manual memory management. Oh, wait, now there's shared_ptr! The C++ community has reinvented reference counting garbage collection, only 50 years behind schedule. Oh, and you have to manually write crap for the things you want collected and deal with their interaction with manually collected stuff.
9. The absurd hoops you have to jump through to simulate things like nested functions.
10. Incompatible compilers and library implementations.
And on and on.
Now like I said if you write C++ you are dealing with at least some of these issues all the time, but maybe you have become numb. These books will remind you.
I just don't get it.
August 21, 2017
The first third-to-half is 5-star material, then it starts to fade. The chapter on exceptions highlights the biggest challenges with exceptions (really any form of transaction logic in procedural programming) in a way I haven't seen comprehensively covered before, well worth reading.
November 23, 2017
This book is a bit outdated, but still has some in-depth and obscure information about C++.
It also made me realize why some people hate C++ so much.
It also made me realize why some people hate C++ so much.
April 10, 2018
Except for the item covering auto_ptr, this book is still relevant today, 18 years after being published.
Not only the content is valuable, but it's also well written and even funny sometimes.
Not only the content is valuable, but it's also well written and even funny sometimes.
August 18, 2020
Some things are outdated but it is still quite relevant and thought provoking! A must read for every C++ programmer out there.
April 10, 2011
Not bad, has some good nuggets here and there... However, I felt the Q&A format of the book added absolutely nothing. It's likely just a relic of him copy/pasting the content from his online column.
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews