As always, Poe remains the master of the super creepy tale. While the works of many of his gothic contemporaries have largely lost their bite when consumed by a modern audience, Poe's work still retains its ability to make your skin crawl.
Many of the stories contained within this volume are variations on some of Poe's favorite themes (e.g. live burials, doppelgangers, crimes of passion, and men who lose the women they love only to find them either reborn or transformed in some way) but each iteration of the theme is given new life, and at no point do you feel you're reading the same thing over and over. This is perhaps due to the fact that Poe's narrators are all very distinct, each bringing unique characteristics to the tales they unravel.
Some of the best stories in this book follow the exploits of Chevalier Auguste Dupin, Poe's remarkable detective, and his unnamed sidekick who narrates all the tales of their adventures. Dupin marks the beginning of the serialized heroic detective story. Without Dupin, it stands to reason that there would have been no Sherlock Holmes, no Shadow, and ultimately no Batman.
While there are other compilations of Poe's work, I prefer this volume for the way in which it compiles its contents, placing stories of similar thematic tone together, and for its overall look and feel. This book was a joy to read.