Riddle me this:
Have you ever cooked a dish that you are particularly adept at cooking – for example, let’s use the gods’ gift to mankind, mashed potatoes – and after tasting it, thought to yourself: “Hmmmm, something’s missing?” If you’re like me, your first reaction is, “MORE SALT!!!” This does one of two things: 1. makes the dish at least palatable, or 2. ruins it by overcompensating. If we go with the first, then at least you can eat a somewhat enjoyable meal, even though you know something is still missing in the taste; the second makes you curse yourself as you still eat it (ya know, because it’s mashed potatoes).
This is the perfect analogue to express my opinion on this particular novel: something was missing. The story was good enough, but it wasn't spectacular; thus why I awarded a solid three star average. I think the author had some good ideas, but the story doesn't delve below a superficial reading of the text, and it lacked a certain substance that would have allowed me to rate it higher (don't get me wrong, I wasn't expecting it to be Shakespeare). Just like the aforementioned mashed potato scenario, the author, perhaps realizing a lacking, added more and more salt to the story (of course, by salt I mean sex) hoping to make it palatable to the masses. However, he came to the verge of overdoing it; honestly, I think he did overdo it, to the point of making the story trite at times. In the end, for me, it lacked intellectual stimulation and focused solely on visceral stimulation.
In fact, the novel reminded me quite a bit of contemporary gay cinema: a somewhat shallow story (I don’t mean that in its moral sense, merely that it doesn't penetrate deeper than its surface) that keeps audiences watching by throwing in hot guys. However, with all that said, I didn't hate the read, in fact it engendered the crack of a smile and some “awwwww” moments on several occasions. Basically, if you are looking for an easy, light read that doesn't overly stimulate the mind (plenty of visceral stimulation, though), or make one ask probing questions about the human condition, then this would be a good book to consider reading. Personally, I try to look for something deeper in the novels I choose, but - paradoxically - I will probably still read its sequel.