⭐︎
2.5 Stars Rounded Up
⭐︎
This was strangely disappointing overall.
It felt like Haden (i.e. Hades) was barely in this at all. It felt like it was mainly about Percy (i.e. Persephone) and his life and the people around him and that made this kinda boring at times.
Also, had I known that this was the first part of their story, I probably would have waited and probably not have felt so bereft at the end when it ended on a cliffhanger. I thought this would be their complete story, but nope.
Which, yeah, is probably why it took its time and didn't have much of them, but also at the same time, why not include more of them to keep the reader hooked? As much as I liked and enjoyed Percy, I didn't need so much about his dorm life and his day to day. For such a short book, you'd think there would be more focus on the main couple, but nope.
And when it did focus on them, aside from the hot first scene between them, it wasn't especially detailed.
They did have a few good moments here and there, and one more hot sex scene that I really enjoyed, so those are pluses.
Also, the ending did hook me in for more. So, despite my low rating, I rounded up because I did get me interested for more. And now that we will be spending a lot more time with these two, I'm eager for that.
So this book gets points for that.
But...just, I was disappointed with a lot of the rest. And how it would skip by months at a time, just vaguely describing the time Percy and Haden spent together when Percy's soul would visit Haden. They spend months and months together and yet we barely saw any of it? Any of the foundation of them falling in love? That wasn't good, in my opinion. I wanted more with them, while instead we got more on Percy's relationship with his best friend or these alpha frat bros or his shitty father and so on.
Also, Haden barely tells Percy anything? He doesn't tell him exactly who he is, and why Percy has to stop coming to him, why exactly it's dangerous and that made no sense? Why would he just say "it's dangerous" and leave it at that? Why not explain?
Also, why has Haden not taken his mask off the entire time Percy has known him? What's the reason? Not knowing any of that is annoying.
I feel like, if you're gonna have a multiple book series about the same couple, the first book should be setting the groundwork, not skipping out on a lot of the groundwork to be done in the next book. It doesn't hook the reader.
Instead, so much is left out here and has me left wondering, and not in a good way. It left it so there was barely anything between them in this book so it didn't make for an exciting read.
Honestly, the cliffhanger at the end of this could have been enough to definitely draw the reader in for more in the next book. Keeping so much else out wasn't needed.
Like, cut out some of the unnecessary day to day stuff - like even the stuff with the Alpha frat Percy joins, which wasn't really all that important to the plot - and add more Haden and Percy scenes where get to see they're actually talking and getting to know each other like the text vaguely hints at. That would have been so much better, in my opinion.
So, I was left disappointed at the end of this for those reasons.
But it had enough to keep me interested, especially at the end, to warrant a rounding up instead of down from me. I like this author, and as disappointing as this was, I know this author can do better, so I'm eager to dive into the next book to get more of the main couple I'm here for, and learn a lot more about Haden and the underworld and everything.
Just...this was a weak start, unfortunately. Oh well.