Raised in Reserve Mines, Sheldon Currie teaches literature and writing at Saint Francis Xavier University, Antigonish, Nova Scotia. His books include 'The Story so Far'.
I enjoyed listening to THE GLACE BAY MINER'S MUSEUM written by Sheldon Currie and narrated by Mary Colin Chisholm. It has poverty, humour, sadness and a surprise ending. Margaret MacNeil doesn't mind being an outcast. She lost her father and brother to the coal mines and made it clear that she would never marry a coal-miner. Then one day Neil Currie comes to the community. He is a gentle, bagpipe-playing giant of a man. Margaret takes him home, falls in love, and marries him because he vows to stay away from the mines. 4 Cape Breton stars ⭐️️⭐️️⭐️️⭐️️
The tragedy of the Coal Mines in Sydney Nova Scotia was a very real event, and this book attempts to give insight to the daily lives of the families that were impacted by these coal mines. I fear though, I don't really think it landed what it was trying to achieve.
While I understand that this book is written in first person, so it makes sense where the main character would be ignorant the reader would be as well. I think giving the reader more context to understand the horrors of this event would have made it more impactful. As most of the novel we only really understand that it's a very dangerous job, without the best pay, but the novel fails to really explain why people don't go to other options. I think giving us more socio-economic clues would have given better insight as to why the workers the mines were trapped in this position. It is only in a very brief info-dump near the end that gives some insight into a few factors at play, but even then it doesn't explain, why men would choose this job, over a fishery per say.
The ending I feel only cheapens the story. I understand the author may have intended to be a metaphor, but I feel the absurdity of it feels like it makes a mockery of a tragedy people actually went through. I think seeing the fallout of the deaths that happen in the ending chapters, either through her becoming an advocate, moving away or talking about how she never forgot it her whole life would have said more.
Overall, I wanted more from this book, and I feel it failed to accomplish its objective.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I read "The Glace Bay Miners' Museum: The Novel" because I was preparing to lead a discussion of the film "Margaret's Museum" and the film was inspired by the short story with the same title that was later expanded into the novel. Got that? Author Sheldon Currie grew up in a coal mining family in Cape Breton, which had a huge (and sometimes lethal) coal mining industry in the 1940s, when the novel (really a novella at just over 100 pages) takes place. Currie was inspired to write the short story when he saw a sign for the Glace Bay Miners' Museum and wondered what in the world would be in a miners' museum. Protagonist Margaret is a young woman whose mother is teaching her to expect the worst from life. Her mother has good reason to do so as she has lost her husband and son to the "pit." Margaret's grandfather is nearly dead of black lung and requires "whacking" once an hour in order to continue breathing. Still, the doctors who work for the colliery have judged him fit to work. It would be better not to wed at all than to suffer such losses. But then, Margaret meets larger-than-life Neil, who is an exuberant dishwasher, not a miner! The worst that will happen to him, he tells Margaret, is chapped hands. Neil woos Margaret with bagpipes and Gaelic songs, and their adventure together begins. The book is beautiful, as is the film. It includes a bit more about unions than the film. The film "Margaret's Museum" is exquisited--a gentle love story, darkly funny, quirky, and and as devastating as films come. The DVD of the film is hard to find, but it is available in its entirety on YouTube.
This novel has an interesting history. It began its life as a short story, became a radio play, then a novel and in 1995, a successful film, starring Helena Bonhom Carter. It is the moving story of a young couple who experience both hardship and tragedy in their search for happiness.
Margaret MacNeil is a young girl growing up in a coal town on Cape Breton Island in the 1940s. As a youngster she was considered an outcast and had few friends and the loneliness she experienced during that time has followed her as she grew into a young woman. When Neil Currie, a large, opinionated man with a set of bagpipes arrived in town, she was attracted to him but feared his size and the side of him that did not allow him to accept things he did not agree with or that bothered him. But he was a sensitive man with an appreciation for literature and encouraged Margaret to read the journals her grandfather and her great grandmother had written. On those pages, her relatives had dutifully recorded the lives of their family since they had traveled from Britain and arrived on the island. Neil encouraged Margaret to take on the responsibility of continuing the tradition as recorder, since her grandfather was dying and needed someone to inherit the task.
The couple marry after a short courtship and Neil goes to work in the coal mines. It is hard, dirty work and full of danger but there is little choice; the mine is the sole driver of the town’s economy. Margaret is unhappy about this turn of events; she has already lost her father and brother to that dark underworld and fears losing her lover to the same fate.
Neil is friends with Margaret’s brother Ian, a union organizer. The two have very different views of what they believe the union can do to protect the rights of the workers. Ian believes the union will deal with the workers and their issues while Neil is much less certain that such a small organization with little power could stop corporate greed. Nevertheless, the two work together to develop plans for a workers’ strike.
When the worse happens and Neil and Ian are killed in a mining accident, Margaret becomes desperate with grief which sends her headlong into a flurry of activity. She wants both men to be remembered and develops a plan for a mining museum, but it is an unusual one and it shocks the community.
Author Sheldon Curie was born and grew up in Reserve Mines in Cape Breton. He understands the island people, their communities, and their need to rely on the coal mines to fuel their economy. The mines were always a distinctive part of the environment and were powerful big businesses that at one time produced 40% of Canada’s coal. There were few other options for employment in the island communities except on the seas or in the forests. It was physically difficult, dirty work with men miles below the surface, surrounded in darkness by the dangers of gas leaks, potential explosions and the possible collapse of the mine’s walls. Death was not an uncommon event.
As a young boy, Currie had watched the brave wives of the coal miners carry much of the hardship that came with their husband’s steady income. They worried constantly that their loved one would be injured or killed and they would need to find a job as well as care for their children.
Currie creates strong characters in this story and Margaret takes on the compelling voice of the narrator, a woman who is both honest and wise. There are endless discussions in the MacNeil household about workers’ rights and corporate obligations and Ian, Margaret’s brother and Neil often discuss the issue. The dialogue is pitch perfect with simple honest language, filled with humorous moments and the well-known Newfoundland slang. As the narrative unfolds through Margaret’s voice, it explores the divide between rural and urban Cape Bretoners and the differences between the Catholics and Protestants wakes. It also presents the striking symbol of a beached whale for readers to ponder.
The novel is very short, but the brevity heightens the sense of drama and tension, as a sense of gloom pervades the atmosphere and readers can almost feel something tragic will happen. The story explores themes of love, duty, and obligation, ending abruptly with a bizarre ghoulish twist.
It proved to be an interesting read and a lesson on how much can be packed into a few words in such a powerful story.
Well, I was in love with this little book, picking out thoughts I might use as poetry prompts. In fact, not half finished, I put it down and did write a few verses (best are the readings pushing me to write.) The first verse summed my feeling for the book so far:
The Glace Bay Miners' Museum Mid-read
a stream of consciousness not half through when it stops me I want to find a pair of scissors cut some of those thoughts right off the page write about them as if they were mine.
I used three 'prompts' to write three more verses, the words of Margaret, the narrator, taking me back to my childhood. A few days later I finished the book. A back cover blurb had warned me, "the ending of this book is shattering and unforgettable" but I was not prepared to become so completely broken. Then I realized what I had written in my first verse about the book. Was I prescient?
SUCH an interesting story. Definitely not as hard hitting as the movie since its such a short book and its written kinda point blank. Nothing drags at all. Which I didnt love, I wish it were a much longer book with a lot more details cause its a fantastic story, and Margaret makes the perfect main character (pour moi). Im just glad theres a movie cause the movie really brings it to life and does it justice. It adds to it, even.
Saw the movie this book is based on a long time ago (Margaret's Museum, 1995 release) and didn't realize it was based on a short story and then novel (115 pages). It was a quick read, but rich in characters and dialogue, providing both humourous and poignant insight into the coal life of Cape Breton island.
The broken grammar made this a challenging read but the story within the story was moving. I had physical reactions to this book, and that always bodes well with me as a reader. The ending shocked me and I appreciate that.
I’m not even sure to how to rate this little book. I’ve read my Alistair Macleod, I have helped coal miners with black lung, I know how the story ends, how these stories end, but I didn’t quite see this coming. And that might be the genius of it.
Sad and lyrical, marching towards a tragic denouement as Canadian miners and the women who lvoe them struggle against the overwhelming odds of corporate power and the dangers of underground labor.
How I Came To Read This Book: Two words - Canadian Lit. Required course for my degree.
The Plot: Margaret McNeil is your typical hard-done-by Canadian female protagonist, daughter of a bitter Maritime family, and lover of a gruff miner - Neil Currie. In fact, this book is sort of a Maritime version of something like Margaret Laurence's 'Stone Angel' when looking at the younger version of Hagar Shipley.
The Good & The Bad: I don't remember tons about this book, other than the film version starring none other than Helena Bonham Carter. It was pretty typical Can Lit, which sadly, isn't the most enjoyable genre of fiction. The fact it echoed Stone Angel also gave it a downgrade in points for me. I do recall liking this marginally more than some other books I read in that course, but overall, the lack of memorability downgrades it to a 2 in my books (hah).
The Bottom Line: Hagar of the East.
Anything Memorable?: Just the movie version. I swear I've seen a dozen Helena Bonham-Carter projects...'before' she was famous.
I love the diversity of Helena Bonham Carter's roles, so when I saw the movie version of this book I was intrigued to know more about the main character, Margaret. Unfortunately, this is one of those cases where the book really doesn't offer any new insights into the characters. Margaret had a strong voice at the beginning, but the ending left me no less bewildered than in the movie. It felt abrupt and sloppy... which then flavored what I thought of the book as a whole. Disappointing.
This book is an unedited view into the lives of Cape Breton miners. It is a very quick read, making it a highly suitable for a grade 11 college English class. Although there is not significant character development, it is an excellent read to get an understanding of the complexities of life for miners and their families. The author does a very good job describing the external forces that influence the miners' quest to improve their quality of life, and the unfortunate outcome.
I think having visited the Glace Bay Mining Museum and seeing the movie Margaret's Museum made all the difference for me. The book itself didnt thrill me. It was good...but not amazing. Having been to the mine and seen the movies and heard the stories of the lives of miners, I think made me appreciate the story more.
More CanLit (or CLit, as we called it in high school). Very distinctly eastern, very funny, but very sadly true in many parts. I've been to the actual Miner's Museum and it's nothing like the one in the book. If it was, it probably wouldn't have been a required field trip for elementary students.
Once I got past the terrible grammar I was able to enjoy the story. I knew what to expect as I'd seen Margaret's Museum, but it was still an interesting read