The latest edition upholds the standard of quality that Glannon originally set: - engages student interest as it teaches, making learning as painless as possible - covers all aspects of the first-year course, including the difficult areas of res judicata, collateral estoppel, and personal and subject matter jurisdiction - presents accessible introductions and interesting examples - makes excellent use of the popular Examples and Explanations format, which is highly effective in learning and applying the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure - gives examples that progress gradually from simple to challenging and build student confidence - uses abundant visual aids, such as diagrams, charts, and documents New and revised material includes: - extensive changes to the chapters in Diversity, Federal Arising-Under Jurisdiction, and Supplemental Jurisdiction in light of recent Supreme Court cases, such as Grable & Sons Metal Products, Inc. v. Darue Engineering & Manufacturing and Exxon-Mobil Corporation v. Allapattah Services, Inc. - a new chapter on Federal Rule 15 (Amendments to Pleadings), including amendments as of right, the relation back of amendments, and the confusing provision for amendments adding claims against new parties - citations reflecting the most current law throughout the book, which has been entirely updated
I used this E&E in my first year, helped out a lot. Civil Procedure is pretty arcane and weird as far as 1L courses go -- there's not as much "common sense" stuff as you'll find in Criminal Law or Torts. On the other hand, that means you can approach it from a purely "I have to just learn these rules" perspective, which might work well for some students.
Either way, Glannon's E&E is highly spoken of for good reason. Go ahead and get it, though it's probably better not to attend law school at all. I wanted to be an astronaut when I was 10, and now I spend all day reading documents and managing cases. There isn't enough liquor in the world to help me -- good thing I quit drinking.
Civil procedure is totally fascinating and this is a pretty good E&E. The rules of subject-matter and in personam jurisdiction, removal, lass actions, and venue set the stage for the intricate game of the civil trial. The advanced concepts like transference of venue and which venue's law controls are pure logic-game fun. I'm actually serious.
What can I say? My CivPro professor assigned this in lieu of a casebook. For this I am grateful. Glannon makes the subject about as palatable and accessible as it can be. However, as it is a first-year law school textbook, I necessarily have love-hate relationship with it, so please view the rating accordingly (in an apples-and-oranges sense, that is; I am not saying that the CivPro E&E is "better" than The Sea Wolf.
Though I did not finish the book, I read and completed the exercises that were relevant to my Civ Pro classes. The main reason I found this E&Es to be better than others (e.g. Contracts, Crim Law), is that Professor Glannon balances explaining the material and providing practice exercises.
That said, there were also good alternatives to reading this book, such as Civ Pro flash cards.
A must read for the first year law student. It doesn't go through enough the first year material to sufficiently prepare a student for their final, but it does cover important material.