Personal and revealing look at Dwight Eisenhower's post-presidential years by one of the few who could intimately tell it. David Eisenhower was Dwight's grandson, and spent a good deal of time with the former President following the latter's retirement to his farm in Gettysburg, PA. He was also Richard Nixon's son-in-law, marrying Nixon's daughter, Julie, in 1968. Obviously, this is a personal reminiscence, but David is a professional writer and historian; Julie is as well. Thus, the quality of this work is much higher than it would be otherwise.
David does a nice job of balancing two competing feelings throughout this book: the professional desire to be accurate and fair, while also remaining personal as he is writing about his grandfather - someone whom he was neither intimately close to nor estranged and distant from. Actually, judging by how most of Eisenhower's relationships went, his relationship with David probably could be considered quite close. David writes of both men's usually unsuccessful attempts to become closer. These efforts would usually be spoiled either by David's maturation from a young boy into a college-age youth who had other interests (racing his car, goofing off with friends, dating Julie Nixon) or by Eisenhower's cold and forbidding remoteness that even forced his wife, Mamie, to remark to David that she didn't think that anyone ever really knew Eisenhower.
As a result, we do not get a fawning portrait of the General (Eisenhower preferred to be called this), although David does seem to be more than generous in his assessment of Eisenhower's record on Civil Rights during the 1950s. But at the same time he does speak fondly of Eisenhower, and relates personal stories that only he could: such as the time Eisenhower "fired" him from painting the fence at his Gettysburg farm only to later "rehire" him that same day. Or the times when Eisenhower would make David drive him into town to run errands; David would leave Ike parked in his Plymouth Valiant while he ran into the drugstore. Can you imagine what people thought when they walked by and saw arguably the most famous American of his time just sitting in a car waiting for his grandson?
One theme that does run throughout the book is Eisenhower's precarious health. While still active when he left office, everyone around him was concerned about how much activity he could stand due to the health problems that he suffered while President. Eisenhower was quite active until late 1965, when he suffered a major heart attack. This really set him back, and although he did recover enough to not be an invalid, he was never at full health again. Throughout the late 1960s, he continued to experience heart problems, and ultimately these forced him to spent the last eleven months of his life in Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington. David keeps the story together: he details his concern and worry about his grandfather as he moves closer to death while at the same time not getting overly sentimental about it. I would not call it a moving portrait per se, but I certainly felt sad when I reached the part where Eisenhower died. David succeeds in providing a proper mixture of both stoicism in the face of adversity and human sorrow at the death of a loved one. In doing so, he keeps a wider focus by detailing how the world viewed Eisenhower as moved toward the end of his life.
Especially noteworthy are Richard Nixon's reflections on his last extended talk with Eisenhower in 1967, although they spoke many more times before Eisenhower died. However, curiously, David does not mention the final few times that the two spoke - after Nixon had been inaugurated as President. He also makes no comment about Nixon's reaction upon hearing the new of his death, and Eisenhower's funeral is dispensed with in a somewhat perfunctory fashion which is at odds with the rest of the book. Perhaps he sees no reason to dwell on that, preferring instead to remember when Eisenhower was alive.
Grade: A-