A book about cool animals, with appalling and abhorrent misogyny, racism, and colonialism seeping through every page.
I loved Durrell's "my family and other animals" a lot and, picked up two more of his books, this being one of them. And this sucks cause I really wanted to love this book!
Immediately I was irked by the backdrop of Durrell traveling to Africa to capture the animals for a zoo! Just casually setting up traps in African forests and capturing animals of the forest for a zoo. Alright, it's written in the late 50s, I told to myself. I am willing to move past things when reading old books and chalk a few things up to "the times". But then there are things one can simply not move past irrespective of when it was written.
I am going to provide a few examples. Starting with the last page I read of this book, after which I had to put it down.
*page 68-69* : After calling pigeon's nests stupid, inefficient and, an irritating menace for a naturalist (he is referring to himself here), Durrell vividly recounts a story about how he saw a lot of pigeon nests in one tree along with a different nest on top of the same tree. Being curious about whose nest that was, he climbed up the tree, "unfortunately" creating a "waterfall of pigeon eggs which bounced and broke against me". Unbothered by it, he continued to climb till the top!
On Reaching the top, he couldn't really determine whose nest it is. This is how he describes what he saw after climbing down: "The ground under the tree was littered with broken eggs, tastefully interspersed with the bodies of a few baby pigeons in a decomposed condition." - I have no words! What an absolutely psychopathic thing to say!
There is sadly more! He then proceeds to complain about one of the egg falling in his pocket and ruining his cigarettes "I had to walk two miles home without a smoke". He also complains about the "strong aroma of eggs" and, how all the eggs falling on him ruined his look. He then ends the story with "I have never really liked the pigeons since then."
What a nauseating display of British colonialism and superiority. Destroying hundreds of pigeon nests, breaking their eggs, even killing some of their babies - for no reason other than a passing curiosity, and then complaining about the destroyed eggs ruining his clothes and cigarettes, while he describes the mindless slaughter he caused as "littered with broken eggs, tastefully interspersed with the bodies of a few baby pigeons in a decomposed condition." - we are talking about a man who is globally known as an animal lover!
And that's just one page!
_
He routinely sees all animals from a deeply anthropocentric lens, and the way he writes about animal courtship is unmissably misogynistic.
"It is among the water-tortoises that we find an example of the 'treat'em rough and they'll love you' school of thought"
While talking about praying mantis, he goes in detail about how it looks strange to him and how the way it moves is "unpleasant" for him. Well, sir, it's not really catering to your gaze! He goes on: "You'd think he would be sensible enough not to trust a bride with a face like that"
He sees two female bird of paradise not interested in the male bird, after the male bird does the courtship dance, and immediately goes "I decided that the females must be especially hard-hearted, or especially inartistic, to have been able to resist such an exhibition." and that he feels "very sorry for the male that his magnificent courtship should go unrewarded"!!! Mr Durrell, must you project your sense of male entitlement on a bird?
_
Here's him describing himself inspecting a dead body of a hippo. "The entire village had accompanied me, for such an enormous windfall of meat was a red-letter day for them. They stood silent and interested while I examined the old male's carcase, and when I had finished and walked away they poured over it like ants, screaming and pushing with excitement, vigorously wielding their knives and machetes." - That's a white British man describing Africans while being on a mission to capture native animals for a zoo!
_
In another one of his anecdotes, he gets a boat and a shotgun, captures a Cayman, and releases it far way from its home, because the Cayman was trying to eat Jacana bird's babies. - A native animal, on its own land, trying to eat its natural diet. But of course Durrell must intervene to save the birds! He also talks about planning a revenge and says things like "I would hunt him out and slaughter him". ... For eating its food?? This is literally a "Naturalist" and a "Conservationist" getting mad on a Cayman... for eating its food, on its own land! Can't make this up!
_
Was really looking forward to reading this and enjoying it. If you are like me and like your animal facts without overt colonialism, racism and misogyny, I suggest skipping this one!
Can't believe this comes from the same guy who wrote "My family and other animals". But as Durrell proclaims: "An ugly or horrifying animal - like an ugly or horrifying human being - is never completely devoid of certain attractive qualities".