After First Reading - 2 Stars
John Pinkney annoys me for some reason. Perhaps it's his sir-name, or maybe it's his inability to stick to the bloody topic. Unexplained, mysteries and disappearances, these do not entail ghosts and hauntings and all the bloody material he put in his other book, 'Haunted'. There is one good story about the UFO-related disappearances in the Bass Strait, but otherwise this book was just annoying.
After Second Reading - 2 Stars
I didn't enjoy this any more the second time. Pinkney's loose and unverified book on spiritualism, precognition and mediumship does no favours to said topics. Surely there are many false stories as well as many cases of self-deception. Shit, no matter what you believe, you can't ignore those simple facts. But as someone who is generally open to the idea of life beyond Earth, a firm though proofless believer in ghosts, a faithful Catholic and a generally imaginative person, I have always been partial to things many rationalists refuse to accept. Call in ignorance. Or call it naivety. I myself call it humility. I think he is an arrogant man who thinks that he knows everything. We put too much narrow-minded faith towards empiricism. We think that if something can't be explained through the rigid frame of human logic, then it can't be real. I respectfully disagree.
This book, though, features the most ludicrous stories. Many are not even near conclusive. They cater to the type of person who sees clouds in the sky and swears they see faces, those who base their life expectations on the astrology page of whatever silly magazine. Pinkney even goes so far as to making allegations that his contemporaries (whom he comically admits to beong disliked by) are reincarnated individuals from the past, just because certain similarities in their occupations and character match.
This collection of accounts is of the vaguest and most uncritical kind. No explanation or investigation is provided. And even from a purely sceptical point of view, the stories contained herein are not even particularly scary or interesting. Your average Youtube Top-10 video provides better entertainment.