Any book that a teen can read is a teen book. Treating this as a teen book is both radical and lame. Rad cause it is honest and straightforward without the all too typical patronizing teen-speak, but lame because well, yeah, what the hell is a teen book? Yes, it deals with high school, yes it deals with teens, but so do lots of books. I suppose it´s all how it´s marketed and if it motivates school libraries to shelve this, it is one not ridiculous teen book, typically housed on cobwebbed high school library shelves. As usual Oates is at full throttle, never beyond the scope of her points, never tangendential, and her hallmark stark prose is as visible as ever.
Also, I´d like to note that I am both a teacher and a homosexual. And though I have never been accused of child-molestation directly, it is not something I don´t worry about, like who will think what if they knew I were gay, will the parents feel comfortable, or will the children be able to get it, or continue to learn from me..., and so on.
My 12th form students asked me if I were, and I got out a yeah, and was met with none of the nightmare situations one could dream of, but I was nervous about the repercussions, not only for the above reasons, but for the questions "will I lose my job?" "will this end my career in education?" and well it didn´t. and it was a good educational and personal decision in the long run, as the two cannot and should not be separated, it is conservative rhetoric that does no one any good, because keeping kids in the dark about who we are, is the same false, patronizing bullshit that teens find so contemptuous about adults, and this alas prevents dialogue.
Yet this behavior is perpetuated through fear. And this breeds the kind of bullshit situations like false molestation accusations, ongoing homophobia, gay teen suicides, and really annoying myopic opinions which don´t just end in high school, but are carried into adulthood and manifest into discrimination, abuse, murder, all perpetuated because we are too shy to ask, or too scared to tell or talk candidly with our teenagers as teachers or as parents.
So, yeah, I give this book 5 stars for not being ridiculous material for teens about gay discrimination, for handling teen-sex maturely and unflinchingly, and raising questions about an infuriatingly taboo topic.