The IPR Bureau (whose motto is "Democracy imposed from without is the severest form of tyranny") works to bring newly discovered planets up to the point where they have a planetary democratic government and then induct them into the galactic federation. Unfortunately, the planet Furnil offers problems. The continent of Kurr has a well-entrenched monarchy, and the citizens seem little inclined to change. In fact, they immerse themselves in art rather than politics...and have been doing so for more than 400 years! So what's a poor IPR agent to do...?
Biggle was born in 1923 in Waterloo, Iowa. He served in World War II as a communications sergeant in a rifle company of the 102nd Infantry Division; during the war, he was wounded twice. His second wound, a shrapnel wound in his leg received near the Elbe River at the end of the war, left him disabled for life.
After the war, Biggle resumed his education. He received an A.B. Degree with High Distinction from Wayne State University and M.M. and Ph.D. degrees from the University of Michigan. Biggle taught at the University of Michigan and at Eastern Michigan University in the 1950s. He began writing professionally in 1955 and became a full-time writer with the publication of his novel, All the Colors of Darkness in 1963; he continued in the writing profession until his death.
Lloyd Biggle Jr. is best known for bringing the arts to science fiction (just as Mack Reynolds brought sociology and economics to SF). He had a gentle, thoughtful style that made his books a pleasure to read; in that, his work resembles that of James White.
The Still, Small Voice of Trumpets is classic Biggle. The premise may perhaps seem a bit naive in these harsh days of realpolitik; a Galactic Federation which cannot expand unless a planet at its borders becomes a planetary democracy, without overt interference by Galactic agents. The natives of the planet, Gurnil, have a relatively low level of technology; they are not aware that aliens walk among them. If they discover that, the planet will be considered "blown", and the Galactic agents will have to withdraw in failure.
Those agents are also hampered by a web of regulations, rules, and maxims.
When Forzon, an officer of the Cultural Survey, is mysteriously reassigned to Gurnil he must not only find out why he was reassigned, but how to apply his speciality, the arts, to turning a brutal monarchy into a peaceful democracy. The natives have a magnificent appreciation of beauty and art, but seem to have virtually no political awareness. Forzon is allowed to introduce one technological innovation to the planet, but how can a single change literally revolutionize an entire world?
Biggle's answer is memorable and believable.
It must be noted that the book was first published in 1968, and that Biggle was not one of the "New Wave" authors who were in ascendence at that time. To some, his style may seem a little old-fashioned, though it's eminently readable. The romantic relationship between Forzon and Ann Curry, one of his agents, may also seem rather a bit dated - although accusations of sexism are not credible, since Forzon never treats Ann with less than respect, and her mistakes are not the stereotypical "stupid helpless female" behavior that was a staple of the poorer sort of science fiction a generation earlier.
The Still, Small Voice of Trumpets is a short, elegant, and thoughtful example of a type of science fiction which is still all too rare. It's well worth reading, and re-reading. Although it's quite a short book, Biggle wrote other memorable books on the same general theme, and most of them are back in print.
Charming. Trumpets save the day. Music, revolution and the conscience of the king. Biggle is quite a witty writer, and as usual it's the Interplanetary Relations Bureau (strategists in orbit and on-the-ground agents) who have to call in a guy from Cultural Services in order to understand a planet and effect the goals spelled out in the 3000-page manual. I only found hard to believe that the IPR people were that dense about art and the cultural functions of the planet they had studied for four hundred years, but perhaps this is typical.
I read this as a pre-teen and was blown away. I approached it as an adult worried I wouldn't be as impressed many years later but I loved it all over again when I re-read it in middle age. SO GOOD.
Fast reading 60s era adult social SciFi. It would probably be rated R because of violence but it is appropriate to the story. "Close your eyes" and it is not graphic. I finished the first third in about 75min and the whole book in about 4 hours. The Trumpets title telegraphs the solution to the problem at hand. I don't know if that is a good or bad thing. But although they are critical to the story, they are also incidental.
The protagonist is a cultural survey officer who is sort of a fish out of water sent to pa lanet to help convert the dictatorship to a democracy. The organization he is working for has no "culture" at all, and he does not understand the native people. But he likes their arts! He has a lot to learn and a difficult problem to solve. On the surface level the book is written from, it is simple, but it is actually quite complex.
Very Recommended. I need to read this more often.
(The cover has absolutely nothing to do with the story.)
This was the first science fiction book I read. It really changed my life. I was now hooked on sci-fi, which made me quite different than most girls in the 70s. The beauty of Mr. Biggle's descriptions had me living in this world and hearing the haunting melodies of the trumpets. I highly recommend this and Mr. Biggle's other works.
Never did I imagine the potential power that trumpets could have. This was such a smart science fiction novel, blending an appreciation for aesthetic art and science fiction tropes in such a beautiful way.
The Still, Small Voice of Trumpets (1968) 206 pages by Lloyd Biggle, Jr.
The Interplanetary Relations Bureau is trying make Gurnil a member planet, but they can't do so until the natives meet certain requirements including a democratic government. The IPR can't impose democracy on them and can't even let them know of the existence of an extraplanetary civilization. The IRP has been on Gurnil for 400 years. They quickly got one continent to become a democracy, but Kurr has kept its monarchy despite all efforts.
Since the normal procedures have failed, they send Jef Forzon from Cultural Services. Forzon's orders are lost and he is kind of shuffled around. When his orders finally do show up he is in charge of Team B on Kurr. All of team B are undercover. Other than a brief encounter with Ann, he has no idea who is working for him. After language lessons he goes to Kurr with the coordinator. He soon discovers he's been betrayed.
Kurr is a prosperous nation and all of the people have a high appreciation of art. Paintings, music, and all of their crafts are beautifully made. Forzon catches onto this right away, whereas the agents that have been in place don't have the appreciation and don't see it in the people. Maybe there is a chance that this CS man can do what the trained field operatives have failed to do for 400 years.
This was a fun read. We followed Jef Forzon the whole way, it's a good thing he's a really likable character. The story holds up really well for being written in the sixties. Very clever ending, of course I thought Forzon would come up with an idea to save the day, but there's stuff I didn't see coming.
While it has not aged quite as well as a fine wine might after 40 years, I still enjoyed this story, and it was a refreshing change of pace compared to so many current novels that seem to be obliged to weave multiple plots and numerous characters across at least 600 or more pages. In comparison, "Trumpets" seemed almost like a novella (especially after having just finished Pandora's Star).
There is very little in the way of typical scifi techno-babble, and no hard science at all, really. Instead, it's about the story (not all that complex, though original -- and it includes trumpets!) and the characters (nothing too deep, but a decent variety and a surprise or two); making for an enjoyable read that you fast-readers can probably consume in a couple evenings (or one long evening?).
An interesting juxtaposition of tyranny and intrigue against a backdrop of beauty, elegance, art, and music. To become inducted into the galactic federation new planets must have a democratic government of the people -- and that can't be brought about obvious 'alien' influence. The conflict within this book is that for over 400 years of hidden agents (the IPR Bureau) working towards that goal, the planet Gurnil steadfastly continues with it's ruling monarchy completely in charge. The king has a habit of chopping an arm of people who displeases him. These subjects are then sentenced to exile in one of many one-arm villages. It's up to an officer of the Cultural Survey to help things along despite the dicates of the IPR who do not see the value of outside help from the Cultural Survery.
I liked this book. It was a bit naive though in it's examination of subversive politics and the people's desire for beauty, but I feel that we all can still learn a message from the pages here.
Forzon is a Cultural Affairs guy in the Inter-Planetary Bureau. He loves art and music and culture, and never gets to work on a new planet until it's already been admitted to the IPR. So why the devil has he suddenly been assigned to lead an advance team that has failed to invisibly bring about a democratic revolution in the kingdom of Kurr (a prerequisite for admission)? And how will he succeed when the IPR's finest operatives have failed for 400 years?
An intriguing First Contact story that comes at things from a different angle. I enjoyed the cultural dimension and how it informed Forzon's plans.
Forzon's attitudes towards women and his relationship with Ann are a bit outdated and grating, but overall this was a fun little novella.
In the interplay of two cultures, one primitive & one advanced, how do the advanced refrain from damaging the primitive. On a planet with a deeply artistic people who have created an expressive and capable life style but are politically & technologically primitive humans wish to introduce democracy as a first step towards contact and federation. Human bureaucrats, unaware of the importance of an artistic nature in this culture, cannot make headway. The Monarch's excesses & cruelties refrain from provoking a revolt by avoiding limiting what the people hold most dear, their music & art. Prequel to World Menders.
A classic from the early 1970s revisited and still enjoyed. Cultural Survey Administrator Jef Forzon is sent to the planet Gurnil to move along its progress toward democracy, and finds himself a fugitive in a whole society of culture vultures. The human mission reads as unbridled paternalism these days, but Biggle has done a good job of moving the story right along and folding in intriguing details about art and, especially, music. A little creaky in the attitudes, but fun.
1982 was the second time I read this book. I had been looking to find it again! This time, it reminded me of these lyrics by Holly Near. (Sorry the copy paste is in caps.) THE JUNTA BROKE THE FINGERS ON VICTOR JARA'S HANDS THEY SAID TO THE GENTLE POET "PLAY YOUR GUITAR NOW IF YOU CAN" VICTOR STARTED SINGING BUT THEY BROUGHT HIS BODY DOWN YOU CAN KILL THAT MAN BUT NOT HIS SONG WHEN IT'S SUNG THE WHOLE WORLD ROUND.
I need to reread this and see if it is still wonderful.
This is a book I remember reading when I was in high school, a piece of science fiction about a group of agents who attempted to prepare alien planets to enter the galactic community. Unlike much of he science fiction I read at that time, this story focussed more on people and the arts (especially music) rather than science and technology.
A story of the determination of a people who have a love of beauty of the arts and music to gain democratic rule. The characters were interesting and fun to identify with their situations. I didn't like the part in the ending where a marriage took place. It was not a necessary plot development and didn't move the plot forward.
This book was AMAZING. Fantastic idea, well written and paced, and a great read overall. The idea of a society that so loves art that it's blind to the atrocities committed around it is so fascinating, and the brilliant way Biggle snuck in trumpets is so good! Read this book as soon as you can!
I was unfamiliar with Biggle's work prior to reading this. This was a surprisingly good, well-plotted and engrossing. Intellectual SciFi. I will look for more of his writings.
While the plot of the story, and the idea behind it is amazing, the writing is bad, characterization horrible. . The protagonist is hardly relatable. He comes off as an all perfect, all knowing, flawless, misogynist male who always has everything prepared and handed to him. Barley does anything in the path of the story, besides one part.(oh please, hold the applause) The misogyny comes in play in the way he comments on what women wear and how they act, it could be argued that it's related to his job, but the way other male characters also speak about women is more proof of the sexism in the writing. Even more proof, the protagonist gets in trouble by the "mistake" of the only female in the story. . His love interest and romantic scenes in the story seem to be thrown in at random intervals just to include a small one paragraph space or even less. I can't even put in words how their love connection began...actually I can so... !!!SPOILER!!! They met, she was the only woman not dressed in a soldiers' uniform, and that's what set her apart, they kissed once randomly (legit don't know how that came about), and at the end of the book the get married. It is literally boiled down to these three scenes. . The only appealing character is one by the name of Tor who at best is considered a character D in the story. If the book was centered more around him or narrated through the eyes of someone less condescending, it would've been a wonderful read. . An example of bad writing, it's not attractive or interesting in anyway to have the protagonist conclude the story at the end with a monotonous monologue explaining something that has been explained throughout the story many times, the same way. Even as a humour effect. . Not recommended. Just read a summary or something. It's not worth the read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Pessimo, pessimo, pessimo. Ho già detto che è pessimo? Non sono riuscito a trovare alcun aspetto favorevole: storia debole ed eccessivamente semplice, personaggi insipidi, ambientazione infantile. La tentazione di abbandonarlo dopo un paio di capitoli è stata forte, ma ho insistito nello sprecare il mio tempo.
Al momento, il peggior romanzo sci-fi che abbia mai letto.
Another great entry by an underhyped master SF author. There's a lot to unpick here. From the ethics of interfering with a civilization purely on the bases of a tidier map, to an engaging adventure of a man sent to destabilise a pretty stable government. Where do the trumpets come into it? Ah, that's the big twist and a marvellous one at that. I really enjoyed this one.
Читала на русском языке. В целом этот писатель средненький. Вроде идеи интересные у него, но социально-политическая подоплека и отношение к женщинам портят остальное, что есть хорошего в его книгах.
Lloyd Biggle, Jr., was a marvelous writer, with a wonderful sense of life. Perhaps what made him such a different type of science-fiction writer was that he was a Ph.D. … in musicology! Many of his science-fiction stories revolved around arts and culture, especially his stories involving the Interplanetary Relations Bureau, the IRB, and its Cultural Survey branch. “The Still, Small Voice of Trumpets” is one of those. I have lost track of how many times during several years I have read “The Still, Small Voice of Trumpets,” and so many other Biggle books, but, each and every time I do, I love it again. For anyone who has read Tony Hillerman's stories of the Navajo police, you will see a certain similarity between the natives of the planet that is the setting of “Trumpets” and the Navajo: a deep and abiding love of the beautiful. In an intriguing plot, the people of the target planet are so aesthetically attuned, they seem to have innate talents for various arts, including music. Burdened by the rule that natives must never be made aware they’re being led, or manipulated, or even watched by the outer-space aliens, the IPR is also burdened by many CAPITAL LETTER maxims, such as DEMOCRACY IMPOSED FROM WITHOUT IS THE SEVEREST FORM OF TYRANNY. Such obstacles are part of this enthralling story, and how the Cultural Survey administrator, who has never before landed on a world that wasn’t already admitted to the community of planets, has to overcome both the bureaucratic obstacles and the tyranny of the native king is the rest of the story. What makes this story so different is how arts and culture are involved in the solution to the IPR and the CS problems. Being a child of the modern age, naturally I see the motion picture possibilities of “The Still, Small Voice of Trumpets,” but that's probably highly unlikely. In the meantime we have this excellent book, a book I have loved several times and a book that I highly recommend to all readers.
The Interplanetary Relations Bureau motto is Democracy imposed from without is the severest form of tyranny.. To manipulate planets to become democracies, the IRB secretly maintains agents to foment revolutions, destabilize and otherwise mess with any native non-democratic government. The short that this was based upon was written in 1961, any resemblance between CIA activities at the time and the IRB must be coincidental.
One of its worst failures to date is the country of Kurr, they've been working on it for 400 years without success, finally someone gets the bright idea to send someone from Cultural Survey, Jef Kozon, to take a look. Kozon arrives and is immediately smitten by the arts of Kurr, and the intense love of beauty that all Kurrians possess, and which the James and Jane Bond types pay little attention to.
Encounters and adventures occur and there are several plot twists, art plays a large role as well as the uniform inability for the IRB secret agents to appreciate it. I find the latter a bit improbable, but it's not a showstopper. Also all supervisors are male, and while there are no sexy lampshades, it suffers from 60s pulp gender expectations. A fun but somewhat dated read.