**Warning**
Profanity and spoilers to follow:
Pages 1-133: Five (5) I fucking love you two stars
Pages 134-312: Negative, (-5) negative five fucking what the hell were you thinking stars To say you disappointed me here, Kat, would be an understatement. I lost 90% of my respect for you in a short 20 pages. And half these pages were extremely boring. I do give a bonus point to that wonderful and entertaining parrot, however.
Pages 313-478: (4) Four you people are fucking entertaining stars For the people who said he was too forceful here, clearly, have not read book 1, this was pretty tame compared. And I don't think Reed can honestly be at fault.
Okay, I'm going to start with Kat. I find it the ultimate betrayal to your husband and the love you shared together to start a relation other than friendship with someone you were both close to -such as a best friend- be your husband dead or not . I find it disloyal and highly dishonorable to engage in such activities, it is a knife in the gut to the union you shared together . The fact that people use the excuse of their love for the deceased to rectify their being together makes me the sickest. If your husband were alive, you wouldn't even think about it, if you divorced he'd still never forgive the two of you. So why does the world feel in death it is okay? The worst thing of all was I felt there was little fight from you at all, Kat. Where was your little Irish stubbornness here? Yes, you were depressed and morning but I still don't think that is a good enough reason. How can you say you love someone with all your heart, yet give it away so freely? The first man to show you a little comfort and you go diving head first into his bed. Pathetic, I'm sorry to say. I actually closed one eye while I had to read about your disgusting passion with one another.
Mr. Reed Taylor. Let's get to you because you are not innocent either. You truly are the definition of a rake, aren't you? My god, you'd stick your dick in anything with holes, wouldn't you? I wish you would of been stuck on that island all alone and had to do with making a coconut your mistress. The fact that you, dear sir,knowingly cheated on your wife makes you just as bad. I mean how is she to ever trust it wouldn't happen again because clearly you have no self will. Yes, you are man, you have needs. May I suggest next time you get more reacquainted with rosy palmer. I'd have more to say I'm sure if I actually had to read about your cheating.
With that, I'd say you two are fairly equal in your treachery to one another. The fact that neither of you re-engaged in your cheating after you found one another, I can applaud. Kat, you had every right to be mad at Reed when you found out about Miss Sally Simpson. Reed, I actually think the way you acted when you got back was justified. Not only did you feel betrayed by your wife but your best friend, as well. Yes, you made it seem as if you were still carrying on with your mistress but the author plainly stated you were not. You were only trying to make your wife as jealous as you felt. It was quite clear he still loved her, I can't imagine how hard it would be to come to terms with your wife sleeping with your best friend, and possibly be carrying his child. For the people who seem so upset at Reed, I'd like to point out actions speak louder than words. Did he not still turn to her at the end of the day to make love to her, though he could of easily carried on with Miss Simpson while she resided in the home,yet he did not. Who was there to comfort her when her grandmother died? He was. Did he not protect the child she was carrying by not allowing her to ride to Emerald Hill? Yes. Did he not follow her to Emerald hill, just to be next to her at the end of the night? Could he of not just allowed Jean to die? And finally, he did come to terms with it which I think makes him more of a man than any of you are giving him credit for. He was still a gentleman at heart whether anyone else cares to see it or not. I think she should of at least told him the truth about her and Jean, he had strong suspicions, you can't ever get past a conflict like that in a relationship if all things are not voiced, they will stew and simmer below the surface, always a questioning doubt in ones mind. But apparently if the author says differently, it won't. Kat, and her antics against Miss Sally Simpson was great, and way to get a bitch slap in there. All and all.
I absolutely love you two, Kat and reed.