Jeffrey O.G. Ogbar's exploration of hip-hop history and culture is an essential read for hip-hop and rap scholars, however, not all of the material is as succinctly conveyed or relevant as in other similar monographs.
One of the inherent disadvantages of writing a historical piece of an ongoing cultural movement is the risk of being outdated, and unfortunately many of the elements within "Hip-Hop Revolution" have not stood the test of time. While this is not the fault of Ogbar, there are figures and elements within the story of hip-hop culture which are, in hindsight, sorely overlooked, or, conversely, over-indulged in discussion. For example, at the time of publishing, 2007, Kanye West was simply a new artist on the scene and is treated as a peripheral figure within "Hip-Hop Revolution". In hindsight, a new era of rap was brewing alongside other briefly mentioned artists like Lil Wayne, Lupe Fiasco and Nicki Minaj. On the opposite end, a figure such as 50-Cent receives much attention within the work. With hindsight, we know understand 50-Cent's musical influence as, while important to the history of rap culture, a temporary draw within the time before and during the publishing of "Hip-Hop Revolution". To reiterate, this is not the fault of Ogbar, but it does frame the contributions of the book in a pre-modern fashion.
Two of the biggest positives of "Hip-Hop Revolution", and why it should be required reading for hip-hop scholars, are the connections drawn between minstrel shows and exploration of Latinx contributions in the rap genre. For the former, the entire first chapter draws historical connections between the white audiences of minstrel shows to the present exploitations by white executives and listeners in hip-hop. For the former, Ogbar weaves the analysis of Latinx contributions to hip-hop culture in ways which I have not yet seen in similar monographs, and it should be applauded.
The two biggest positives, however, aide in highlighting some of the biggest faults, which is the structure of some chapters. The two previous elements, which are well executed portions of the text, feel dis-lodged next to some of the other less-focused content. There is nothing necessarily "wrong" within the text, or out of place within a discussion of hip-hop history. What there is, however, is a muddling of tangents which do not result in a clear thesis in each section. Some chapters, such as Chapter 5 on the prison industrial complex, focuses much of it's attention on Ice Cube and his musical development. While the argument is sound, it was not evident that the chapter was to be argued through the lens of a main/singular case study, with the chapter feeling underwhelming.
In summary, Ogbar's text is a great piece of historical and sociological analysis in the pantheon of hip-hop studies, and should be considered alongside other great monographs within similar areas. This comes, however, with a big asterisk, as it succeeds in some areas and underwhelms in others. Either way, it is an informative companion piece to any hip-hop scholar's journey, but just understand the context of the work before jumping in.