What do you think?
Rate this book
A History of Modern Criticism, 1750-1950 #2
تاريخ النقد الأدبي الحديث: العصر الرومانسي - الجزء الثاني
في هذا المجلد يــرى " رينيه ويليك " أن الحركات الرومانسية هيمنت على الساحة النقدية مع بداية القرن التاسع عشر في ألمانيا من خلال العرض المقدم مــن " الأخوان و"شليجل " الأثيني، وإنجلترا تمثل في القصائد الغنائية التي كتبها " وردزورث " كولردج"، وفرنسا عرضت السيدة " دي ستال " التفرقة بين الرومانسية والكلاسيكية، وفي إيطاليا حدث جدال حول الكلاسيكي - الرومانسي ( 1816) تحت تأثير ما كتبته " دي ستال " .
- GenresLiterary Criticism
724 pages
First published January 1, 1959
4 people are currently reading
95 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
August 11, 2025
sorprendente lo q uno llega a reirse cn las exposiciones d wellek (p.e. tieck o coleridge). ha sido una buena exposición, no puedo esperar a hacerme cn los otros 5 volúmenes🫠
June 26, 2015
[My review refers to the Brazilian edition of the Book]
This second volume of the magum opus from René Wellek is a tour de force encompassing the first German Romantics (Schlegels) up to Hegel.
It is somewhat more interesting to the modern reader than the first volume, as some of the ideas conveyed by the authors cited in this book are still repeated in modern criticism - be it professional or amateur. From a standpoint of the history of ideas, this book is a must read, as it unveils, though never abandoning the literary criticism, some of the seeds of the modern world.
As with the first book, however, some of the details of the literary criticism and theory of the authors studied are rushed through and end up as semi-comprehensible at best (of course, this may have its roots on the extravagance of some points of view conveyed by the authors themselves). Also, I could detect some (slight) parti-pris concerning the German writers.
The book is most interesting when historical problems are properly placed and discussed (see e.g. the discussion about plagiarism in Coleridge's work, the phases of Vitor Hugo's thought, Madame de Stäel's influence and the chapter about Italian romantic critics). The downpoint is the exposition of the critical thought of the English critics - way too convoluted.
One of the best chapters is the one about Hegel (closely followed by the ones about Schleiermacher, Solger and Schoppenhauer), possibly because Wellek was more learned in the philosophy of German thinkers than the other authors'.
This second volume of the magum opus from René Wellek is a tour de force encompassing the first German Romantics (Schlegels) up to Hegel.
It is somewhat more interesting to the modern reader than the first volume, as some of the ideas conveyed by the authors cited in this book are still repeated in modern criticism - be it professional or amateur. From a standpoint of the history of ideas, this book is a must read, as it unveils, though never abandoning the literary criticism, some of the seeds of the modern world.
As with the first book, however, some of the details of the literary criticism and theory of the authors studied are rushed through and end up as semi-comprehensible at best (of course, this may have its roots on the extravagance of some points of view conveyed by the authors themselves). Also, I could detect some (slight) parti-pris concerning the German writers.
The book is most interesting when historical problems are properly placed and discussed (see e.g. the discussion about plagiarism in Coleridge's work, the phases of Vitor Hugo's thought, Madame de Stäel's influence and the chapter about Italian romantic critics). The downpoint is the exposition of the critical thought of the English critics - way too convoluted.
One of the best chapters is the one about Hegel (closely followed by the ones about Schleiermacher, Solger and Schoppenhauer), possibly because Wellek was more learned in the philosophy of German thinkers than the other authors'.
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews