‘This is my third challenged picture book.’
“Crow Boy” by Taro Yashima is full of gruesome illustrations that are fascinating and compelling at the same time. It contains a strong art element, like the color, size and the structure of each page. The colors are vivid despite the frightening feel they create and the clothing portrayed in the story is very colorful along with the village and how the people are represented. The picture on the cover page is very distinct in that it shows a boy wearing a head covering, which elicits many questions.
The tiny boy, Chibi, is afraid of his teacher and cannot make any friends. He is left alone in the study time and the play time, and is not interested in academics. Instead, he looks out the window, and admires what is out there, he likes to hold and watch insects and listen to many different sounds outside the window. Finally, with Mr. Isobe, Chibi is able to learn and show his talent for imitating the voices of crows during the school talent show and steal the crowd’s hearts. Furthermore, Chibi is honored for the perfect attendance through all the six years of school.
Not every child learns the same and everyone is special in their own way, but specifically cherishing the differences in kids is the overarching theme of this selection. This text can certainly be used to show how kids learn differently and how important it is to cultivate their talent. “Thank you, Mr. Falker” is a great paired selection to use with “Crow Boy,” because it depicts alienation due to one’s differences, and shows the journey of the main character to a positive ending. I can see this book work for the intermediate students, specifically, grades 3 to 5 with the reading level grade equivalent of about 2.9. I think that those ages could read the book on their own, think about the message and describe the transition Chibi goes through from someone very timid and disinterested in school to a talented boy who works hard to support his family. Furthermore, the students can discuss the commonalities and differences between “Crow Boy” and “Thank you, Mr. Falker.” In my eye’s this is a great selection, and I see how it is an award winner. While it was challenged because it “denigrates white American culture and discourages assimilation,” I feel that “Crow Boy” is a very strong read, which teaches about embracing differences, stopping bullying, and cultivating one’s talent.