Finally, I'm getting around to writing my review in preparation for sending this book on to vivdripper. I'm hoping, zzfriend, that you won't mind a detailed, sometimes critical, review (I believe that one of the reasons for this ring was to get some feedback, right? and I *am* an editor, so I'm going to deliver ;-) ). For those who follow in the ring, you might want to wait until after you've read the book yourself so my comments don't influence your appreciation of the book.
Prefatory Comments:
One caveat--I don't generally care for stories (whether books or movies) in which animals are anthropomorphised to this degree (wearing clothes, operating machinery, being rockstars(!), etc. So it might or might not have been something I would have picked up on my own. It took me a while to get over that initial discomfort, even though I had determined to read with an open mind.
I don't know much about boats or sailing (should I say boating, since there aren't any sails?), so I initially found some of the technical jargon a bit of an obstacle (later in the book & on a second reading it didn't seem to impede as much).
Design (not usually something I comment on in a review, but I know zzfriend will probably be interested in opinions about the look of the original product; not having seen a copy of the new compilation, I don't know what design features have been addressed or changed):
Format--I liked the size/shape of the book, but since it didn't have a standard proportion, it might seem subliminally more juvenile.
Cover/Dustjacket--The colour & jacket design was okay (though again, the illustration might lead to a belief that the book is a children's book). I didn't think the blurb/excerpt on the back was engaging & I probably would not have investigated much further. I think a short plot summary (not a long one as on the front inside flap) with a cliff-hanger would have done better.
Interior--The paragraphing bothered me (i.e. spaces between paragraphs instead of indenting--okay for a computer screen, but not in print). The map was nearly impossible to read, and didn't seem to have much use in any case. I did like the illustrations a lot though (I always enjoy illustrated books--which aren't and shouldn't be just for kids).
Premise:
There were a few nit-picky problems I had with the premise both of the whole and of the specific plot. Although rats wouldn't be saved by the regular Coast Guard, surely the crew's pets would be saved in a regular rescue? (I would have thought so, but I just saw on Animal Miracles last week, some idiot guy on an adrift oil tanker was rescued by a cruise ship & he *forgot* his dog that had been on the ship with him for 2 years! The dog was eventually rescued by the Hawaiian Coast Guard 20-odd days later! Poor thing. If only there had been some Rescue Ferrets around.). About this particular story: why wouldn't the human scientists have brought as much of their data as they could--they would have known how important it was *and* which of the material was most important to preserve.
Story:
Once I got past the anthropomorphization, things picked up for me. I liked the main part of the story--once Chloe came on board as well as the Deepsea Explorer rescue. I really liked the characters, and felt affection for all of them--very well drawn, zzfriend. I thought the "near-death" vision was a little hokey--I think just because it seemed out of place with the "secular realism" of the rest of the book (notwithstanding the doubtful realism of ferret rock stars). I'm curious to know what happens next (do any of these characters appear later?) & would certainly read the other books in the series.