3.5 stars
Holy crap! I actually mostly liked this one!
Right away, this book had four things in it's favor:
1) New-to-me characters. I don't recall Cosmo from the first four books, but I liked him. Jane was great too. Patty came around big time from her starry-eyed beginnings of a naïve intern, and Robin was a drunken lush with massive issues but I could see his good qualities attempting to shine through. Wayne was interesting and I liked how expectations were twisted with him and Patty. Hell, even Adam had a couple of good moments near the end there. He's still a douche though.
2) No Sam and Alyssa. I hated their toxic attraction to each other - and that's all it was. The only good thing they could ever say about each other was how sexy the other looked. Their "courtship" was drunk sex and insults. Not a strong foundation for the HEA they apparently got in the previous books, but it got them out of this book, so I wish them well. If this were RL, I'd give them a year if I were feeling generous.
3) No WWII flashbacks. I was right: getting rid of those allowed everything else to flow much better. There was still WWII stuff, since the film being produced was based on the WWII Ghost Army, specifically two gay men who found love for a few days during the war. And we still have one of the WWII survivors in the story, as with the first four books, but here he actually contributes to the current story and doesn't detract. It was all much better used and more seamlessly integrated into the main plot.
4) More Jules. He's no longer just the gay sidekick and finally gets his own time in the spotlight. He's smart, competent and tough. He's a little stupid about love, but he learns to value himself by the end.
Of course, this wouldn't be Troubleshooters if stupid still didn't happen. There's instalove (they knew each other barely a week and were already planning nuptials and saying they couldn't live without the other person, oh geez); drunk sex; ridiculous plot holes you can drive a tank through (military personnel aren't supposed to moonlight while on leave, but here our boy is moonlighting, on national TV no less) (oh, and he's on leave to help his mom who he barely even spends time with) (but hey, all in the name of true love, right?) (oh, and he's not a civilian, he's Special Ops military; how do you even make a mistake like that?); the incredibly contrived TSTL ending that took up the last 20% for a climax that I couldn't even be bothered to care about because it was so predictable I was insulted that I was expected to use brain cells to read it; and most importantly, Cosmo's mom doesn't appear on page ONCE! She's a Broadway musical jamming mama, she's supposedly the reason Cosmo's even in this story, and we don't even get to meet her. The hell!
Cosmo/Jane: Ok, I might have eye rolled at the things I mentioned above, but I really liked them together and separately. They're great characters, they have flaws that make them relatable and their strengths complement each other.
Jules/Robin and Jules/Adam: what a hot holy mess this started out as. I'm glad Jules stuck up for himself and made it clear he deserved better to both Robin and Adam. But geez, the first prominent gay storyline in this series (unless something else happened in the three books I skipped over) and both the potential love interests were both self-involved douches. True, both Robin and Adam were given reasons for being that way, but seriously. It's at least somewhat balanced out with the Jack character and his story, but that's not a big part of the book, though it does inspire all three guys to do better in their own ways. Also, you can tell this is an early '00s romance aimed at het audiences because the het couples get on-page sex times but the gay couples don't. I wonder how many people missed the irony of Jane fighting to make sure the gay and straight couples in her movie got equal screen time, because I sure noticed it. I could feel Brockmann talking to her publishers with those lines. I wonder if that's why the sexy times were kept to a minimum here. Not that I can really complain about a minimum of sex scenes, since that's always a plus for me.
Anyway, I finally got through one of these without skimming or skipping or straining my eyes from constant eye rolling, so this is a definite win in my book.