Even though I read the first two Warrior cats series back in middle school, I never touched this super edition, so it was fun and engaging to be right alongside Firestar as he was forced to reevaluate his conception of there always being four clans in the forest. I've heard my friends talk about SkyClan, but up until this week, I had no clue how they fit into the larger picture of the series, and I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised by how well the new clan slots into place with the other four. That being said, I love the creative aspect of rebuilding a clan from scratch. Leader ceremonies are always a favorite of mine, and I like the satisfying pay-off of seeing cats given their warrior names and official clan positions.
However, I'm only rating this book two stars, because of the pacing and the final battle. In terms of pacing, I feel like there are many portions of this book (especially near the beginning) where the only purpose a scene serves is to take up space. I understand that it's important to show Firestar's journey to SkyClan, but that section seemed to drag on for me, and every time Sandstorm questions her relationship with Firestar, I begin to question it more seriously, too. I want to hear these characters talk through their problems more than I want to hear them wandering around unfamiliar towns, searching for one another because they couldn't NOT get lost every few chapters.
As for the final battle, revisiting this series has taught me which plot-lines I find the most engaging. First and foremost would be clan drama, especially drama within a single clan (like the WindClan succession crisis in the fourth book of the second series). Down at the bottom would be conflict with other types of animals (badgers in the second series and rats in this super edition). I dislike these plot-lines, because they bring up more questions for me than they answer. If rats and badgers can learn to speak, then what are the ethics of fighting them? Why can't they live peacefully with cats and all get along? And if these two animals can talk, then who's to saw that the sparrows and voles the cats constantly kill aren't just as sentient as the cats? Personally, when I read the Warrior cats books, I can easily suspend my disbelief about cats behaving like humans and organizing into clans. Even the excessive amount of hunting they do is painful but easy to ignore. However, when these plot-lines are introduced, I find myself questioning the world so much that it nearly falls apart.
All this being said, I enjoy the Warrior cats series immensely, and I have fun thinking about even the plot-lines I dislike. And while I'm glad I finally took the time to read this book, I have to say it is not one of my favorites in the series, especially compared to "Bluestar's Prophecy," the only super edition I had read before this one, which is one of the most classic Warrior cats books in my mind.