TL;DR Review: One of the most memorable and horrific deaths in the series that is really the crown for this book. Outside of that, the book often falls into the same tired tropes of the other books, dating it severely and making several characters feel flat. Still a fun, if flawed, read overall.
Content Warnings: Violence, Gore, Death, Murder, Decapitation, Adultery, Memory Loss/Amnesia, PTSD, Panic Attacks, Body Shaming, Slut Shaming, Mental Health.
”I had a dream that I was drawing a silver line.”
Full Review - Contains Spoilers:
This book has stayed in my memory for years, as it has one of the worst (in the best possible way) deaths in the series. It’s absolutely horrific and the build up to the reveal may not be perfect, but it still doesn’t disappoint. Outside of that, it still is very much written like any other Fear Street book. There’s outdated tropes, boring teen drama, unlikable characters, and mental health issues.
It isn’t necessarily as egregious as other examples, but it can make the book a slog to get through at times. Especially because information will seem to be finally presented to Martha, only for the same information to go unanswered yet again for several more chapters. The bait and switch gets frustrating and by the time we finally learn that Adrianna is the one who plotted to kill Martha, only to murder her crush Sean by mistake? It doesn’t matter. It feels like a twist that wasn’t totally worth the payoff, but instead that the whole book was leading up the the intensity of the death itself.
While certainly not the most memorable book overall, it is a fun read and totally worth the horrifying death that’s sure to send chills down your spine. Overall, it’s still probably one of the better books in the series for that reason, but if you’re not looking for that intensity, it might be better if it’s skipped.